i'm an ms1 at utsw. all this studying the past few weeks has made me reminisce about being a pre-med, so i thought i'd contribute my two cents in the form of some mildly-relevant impressions. i used this site a ton, so i guess it's my duty
first the two big pros: cost and the college system. i'm an out of state student and i turned down some private schools and my own - more expensive! - state school to come here. the amount of tuition we pay is absurdly low, and i think it will give us a lot of flexibility when it comes time to choose a career path. this is such a huge pro. don't discount it. cost DOES matter.
the college system is also really great. my group mentor is very good about emphasizing the big picture, and that's really important when bogged down in the nitty-gritty of taking tests and grinding out one low grade after another
he is an amazing guy, and it's a real privilege to have two hours of his time every week.
now, the cons. utsw is very, very traditional. we go to lecture (well, some do, i don't
), study, and take multiple choice exams. it's great in allowing me to choose how i want to study, but i'm not really sure i'm getting any "added value" or something special compared to other schools. most of the faculty really don't seem to care (anatomy is a big exception) - very poorly written syllabi, inane lectures, etc. i've compared what we've learned to what my friends back home have learned, and it's very similar. i guess i knew that medical school curriculums were highly standardized, but it's something else to see it in action - "high ranking" really only matters in terms of research opportunities, imo. parkland was also a selling point for me, but as an ms1 i'm not really in a position to judge whether that was a valid sentiment.
this traditional approach extends to grades. i work pretty dang hard and i have not even come close to sniffing an A. i consider myself a reasonably talented person with pretty good test taking skills, and it's been a new experience for me to walk into the testing room and know that even though i've mastered the majority of the material, i have no chance of scoring well. my friends at home work about as hard and have pretty close to straight As. i have no idea how this impacts residency applications - the admin here of course says it doesn't, for various reasons - but we'll see.
and now for something i really don't have any complaints about - the student body. this is not a bunch of gunners, really and truly. no one will cut you down. they may - and probably will - outwork you, but they will not cut you down.
well anyway, i don't know if the anonymous observations of someone you don't know will affect your decisions, but i know that these sorts of subjective comments - taken as a whole - did help me last year making a choice. i hope they help you a little.
i'll check back for questions i guess. back to physio!
cheers.