- Joined
- Oct 22, 2013
- Messages
- 25,175
- Reaction score
- 35,326
unlynch tartesos
lynch crayola
So Many Feels
-Cray: For extreme diarrhea of the mouth. She manufactured weak reasoning on her snowy vote and piled onto the bad logic of the AM vote. Crazy circular logic that hurts my brain. Very defensive about being told her posts and logic seem wolfy and threw out a "I'm not a wolf, maybe YOU'RE THE WOLF" defense, which always screams wolf to me. In part of her crazy logic used the phrase "If I was you villagers" - maybe just rhetorical flourish, but seems like the type of Freudian slip a wolf would make.
Feels
-PBC: manufactured some weak reasoning for an AM lynch to make her logic seem sounder than it was in reality, and then got a little defensive and backpedaled when someone called her out on it.
-Genny: very defensive about people voting for her and thinking that people are after her just because she was a winning wolf from last game.
Minor Feels
-Kam, STL, Raf, Tartesos: I'm still not a big fan of people who haven't been on at all since the game started, and none of these players have (unless I missed a post somewhere when making my notes?). Non participation seems like an easy excuse to skate through undetected for a few days. Also as a way to not give out too much info on yourself, lest you slip up.
-LoTF: A little defensive on people needling her about participating
-Finn: only because I'm salty about the attempted manacide and my emotions are getting the better of me
No Feels:
-LIS: He's posted earlier and more consistently than last game, but his game play seems normal. Not sure I'd be able to tell if he was a wolf though.
-Finn: actually where she belongs. Still salty though.
-Everybody else who's posted so far
Your vote for me makes total sense, and wasn't particularly rude towards me. Thanks.
I've said before (not that that matters, let me explain *my* logic as you have here), I try to put a vote in every single cycle IRL doesn't stop me from, just as a principle of gameplay. I also try really hard to provide with it at least a sentence of why, because I think votes with *nothing* to go with it, are lame. So I don't think it's surprising D1 vote "logic" can be weak. Especially from me, I guess, the person with the crappiest logic it would seem.
IMHO I did not pile onto the AM vote, perhaps it seemed that way. One, I voted Snowy instead. Two, I was trying to make the point that if the majority of players can't read her being village or wolf at all, then where does that leave us when faced with the decision to lynch her or not? Is this really that illogical and idiotic of a question to ask? I think part of my point is that I'm not sure it's a great early lynch to just lynch the hard to read people as a defensive principle. Same thing with just lynching all the quiet people, which is something that comes up. Or lynching all the annoying people (like me).
The rest of what you find fault with in me, I could address, but the points are well taken as far as what you have to say about my gameplay.