Tigerstang said:
Ok folks, I need some help. It's decision time, I guess. I need to finally decide between UF and Miami. I know a lot of people here have chosen Miami over UF, and I'd like to know why. I know a lot about UF (there are a lot of Gators in my family), but admittedly little about Miami (I mean, you only get so much from a one day visit to interview). Folks who picked Miami - what made your decision? I appreciate your advice folks. And I know this might have been discussed before, but I've been out of the country for the past month and have thus missed a lot of discussion on this thread (though I'm sure most of it focused on Red Tide and the perils of Durham, NC).
I got put on hold at UF (I know why, though), but I thought I would chime in because I would have most likely chosen UM over UF anyway for in-state (I'm not pursuing the waitlist). They both have their good aspects and their bad ones, so I'll just make a short list that is based completely on personal opinion.
UM Pros:
- it's really an up-and-coming school. They're getting more research money than ever, their clinical training is highly respected and their basic science teaching is getting better; the new med school dean was the head of internal medicine at Duke and everyone I talk to here about UM brings up how he's a "powerhouse" and he'll "make UM rise in the rankings" (both direct quotes)
-they put their lectures online. The fact that UF doesn't really bothered me because I think it would help me learn and not force me to go to class if I'm sick or was up late the night before.
-UM is P/F for basic science years (I believe? someone correct me if I'm wrong. but at least I know UF is graded)
-more diverse patient population and diseases. My dad was a pathology resident at Jackson years ago and said he's seen stuff there he's never seen anywhere else
-cooler city
-I meshed better with the students I met at UM. I thought they seemed more chill than the students at UF (but that was just my initial impression...it could just be the result of the small sample I met). and UF in general seemed to have a superiority complex that I thought wasn't completely warranted.
UF Pros:
-more established research reputation
-they seem to sort of "teach to the boards", so their students do well on step 1. I think you can do well anywhere if you put in the work and practice a lot, but maybe their teaching style might help.
-Shands is a great hospital
-can/have to do your rotations in other cities to get diverse experiences (can be a good thing or a bad thing, depending on how you look at it)
-smaller city with lower living expenses
-closer to my parent's house
-and of course, there's a piano in the reading room
I don't think you can go wrong with either school, it's just up to your tastes and what you think is important.