This is a response to the following PM:
I saw your post about Baylor and UTSW. It seems to me that UTSW and Baylor are both top tier schools, but a certain "gunner culture" is more prevalent at Southwestern (this is what I've heard, not what I think). Also, i heard that there is a new grading policy for first years that is making things much more competitive at UTSW. Honestly, I don't think I don't think I could really go wrong with either school, but I wanted to see what you think. I've been accepted to BCM and hope to match at UTSW, what would be some factors that you think should make me choose UTSW over BCM? I def. would like your input, especially since you go to UTSW. Alright, take care.
Response:
You're right; there is a new grading policy here . . . and it's an ABC system with a bell curve. In my honest opinion, I think it's an improvement. I'm a 4th year and I wish that that is how I was graded. In my case, in many of our classes, most people made A's or B+'s. That made people try really hard for the A's because if you made a B+, then that meant you were in the bottom half. It also meant that for the people in the middle of the class, there was a lot of luck involved and if you happened to miss the cutoff, it kinda stank. So really, it just helps reward the people who are doing well and takes some luck out of it for the people in the middle. Overall, people will have lower GPAs, but nobody is going to care about your GPA when you apply for residency -- it's class rank that matters, if anything. You should ask somebody from Baylor, but I think (except for the first semester where it is pass/fail), they have H/HP/P/F on a bell curve, and you are ranked on that, so really its the same system. In fact even at exclusively pass/fail programs, Cornell being the one I specifically know about, although you don't get grades along the way, they actually keep track of your test scores and assign come residency application time. So all that is to say, don't worry about the grading system. Whether you like it or not, you are going to be compared against your peers.
As far as the "gunner" culture of UTSW, from the people I've talked to at Baylor, it's really the same. You should ask Baylor people for specifics on that. As for UTSW, many people are indeed gunning for the top grades. It's only natural for that to happen if you've selected people that have made the best grades/MCAT scores in undergrad. However, people help each other out with study aids, and I have never been sabotaged or anything like that. People DO complain a lot here. The amount other people whine about trivial matters would be my main complaint. Personally, I study when I want to study, and when I get tired, I stop. It's pretty simple, and it keeps me happy. But yes, people will moan baout how hard they're working, but trust me, those people arent struggling to pass, their gunning for A's. It's self-inflicted and you can easily escape it. My guess would be Baylor is comparable.
One clear advantage of Baylor is that you get a lot more elective time. Here, you have 1 month elective during third year, and you could take 3 electives to start 4th year before applying. I think its enough, but more electives probably never hurt anybody.
Supposedly, at Baylor, Surgery runs the show, while at UTSW, Internal Medicine runs the show. I'm not sure what to make of that- I'm applying for Psychiatry.
As far as Houston vs. Dallas, although I grew up in Houston, I mush prefer Dallas. They're quite similar except Dallas is more compact, has less traffic, and has better weather. Dallas is less ethnically diverse as far as the population of the city but has plenty of cultural things to do and tons of good food. They are both pretty cheap to live in. Also of note for some of you, Dallas has the most attractive women of any city I have ever been to.
You should ask about the call schedule at Baylor. Here, Medicine is q4 overnight (i.e., you spend the night every 4th night), and half of the Surgery rotation is q3 overnight. The call is light otherwise. Ob-gyn was q4 when I've did it but now you don't really take call any more; instead you take night shifts, but don't have to work the day duting those times. Ob-gyn is a big deal here. Parkland Hosp. delivers more babies than Washington, Idaho, Montana, and Oregon combined. What that means for you is that you get to deliver a lot of babies yourseld.
If you're thinking Medicine or Ob-gyn, here might be a better fit.
If you're thinking Surgery, maybe baylor would match better. These are broad generalizations of course.
Not sure about Psych at Baylor, but it was good enough here to make me want to spend my life in it.
Out childrens hospital is ranked in the top 20, but at Baylor I think you go to Texas childres which is top 5.
Derm and Ophtho are top-notch here, dunno about Baylor.
I believe our Plastic Surgery program is ranked #1 in the country.
As for the out-of-staters, UTSW gives all of the out-of-staters scholarships so they actually pay the instate rate.
As for medschools out-of-state, I would really recommend that the Texans stay in-state. I wouldn't forget Galveston, either-- they have a very laid-back, humane attitude and really gear themselves for board prep. People make stellar board scores their. I heard of two Galvestoners in the 260s this past year. There were four 260+ in my class that I know of. National average is 215 (standard dev of 20). UTSW average is 230.
I don't think out-of-state is worth it; I went to Duke undergrad. I'm glad I returned to TX for undergrad.
I hope all of that helps. I'll check the board again later, but I fly to Cali for interviews Saturday. If you have questions but dont see responses on the board, just PM me, and i'll make sure to respond when I get a chance.
Best of Luck to all of you . . .