I am not sure which is better. I think in the long run CHELA is better. I am not 100% sure. In the short run, AMS seems to be better than B of A. If you want to be 100% sure call B of A to see what they really mean by "principal rate reduction"
Okay, so I've dropped out of SDN for a while....now it's time to pick a lender for my Stafford loans. I've narrowed it down to CHELA and Wells Fargo. If I didn't do my calculations wrong, I think that Wells Fargo is the better choice, assuming that you're not going to pay off your loans in just 5 years. (Wells Fargo: 2% interest reduction after 36 months v.s. CHELA: 1.5% interest reduction right away)
Using the Sallie Mae calculator, assuming $100,000 loan (wishful thinking really)
CHELA:
$100,000 - $800 (health care rebate) = 99,200
interest of 5.05%
monthly loan = 1055
total interest = 27352
total loan with interest: 126,552
Wells Fargo:
For the first 36 months, you would have paid off about $30,000 of the principle. For the second 7 years, you would owe $70,000 at 4.55% interest.
The total cost would come out to be
$122,838
details of calculation for Wells Fargo:
assuming a 10 repayment plan for 100,000 at 6.55% interest, the interest payment would be 36,564 and the monthly payment would be 1,138.
In 36 months, you would have paid 40,968, but only about 30,000 of which is principle (the rest is interest: 36,564/120 months = 305/month of interest. 305 * 36 months = 10969. So 40968 -10969 = about 30,000.
Using the sallie mae calculator, I found the interest and total payment for the last 7 years at 4.55%. When I added the first 3 years and the last 7 years, the total cost is 122,838.
Ahh, I think that I'm spending way too much time on this. I never had to borrow any money from undergrad (I went to UCLA) so this is my first attempt to making sure that I don't get ripped off....help! Any suggestions or should I just pick one?