got busy earlier so sorry if I was short. I believe you're anatomically correct. I'm not disputing that. however I am telling you that in practice it isn't rare for me or my partners to be in the epidural space, pass the spinal needle, and get no CSF return. If you've asked the patient during epidural placement they can often correctly tell you which side you're off. I believe you can be way left or way right and get no CSF. I also believe that depending on the angle of your tuohy you can get no CSF. I can 100% unequivocally tell you based on lots of experience between myself and my partners that if you don't get CSF your catheter has a higher chance of failure. it still works most of the time (and if it's been a difficult placement we skip CSE and pass the catheter) but it isn't 100%.
I imagine you'll tell me that we aren't getting CSF in those cases, or that our catheters fail in those cases, because we aren't in the epidural space. Honestly, I can't help but shrug off or ignore that. Again, in the last year I've pulled an epidural catheter and placed a spinal once for CS. All other CSs I've used the catheter. I haven't put anyone to sleep unless it's been a true stat CS and we haven't had for bolus to setup. My hospital does around 4000 deliveries a year.
I know everyone on SDN thinks everything they do works every time and it takes them 2 minutes to place every. single. time. that's not what I'm saying. If I were supervising CRNAs or residents I'd be far less hesitant to believe my own words and I'd be far less hesitant to trust the epidurals we routinely use for CS. These are all attending placed CSEs and we all have lots of experience. Many of my partners are OB fellowship trained and I know everyone here thinks that's useless. Interestingly, our OB/GYNs (and therefore our hospital....) place a very high value on it. Also, I'm not fellowship trained.