- Joined
- Feb 7, 2005
- Messages
- 369
- Reaction score
- 0
I never saw the question....if you asked it before at all.trustwomen said:Just answer the question. Do I have a right to withdraw my tube?
Hypothetically, you would have the right to disconnect that hypothetical tube. Of course, you could hypothetically do just about anything, hypothetically speaking of course. What's any of that matter to you though, since you claim to be more interested in staying practical?
That argument doesn't correlate to abortion well anyway. It would be more similar to the attempting to have your kidney removed from another person since a fetus is directly attached to the mothers blood stream (no, factories, machinery, or external tubes required). From the viewpoint of a fetus, your kidneys are its kidneys. And, you don't have the autonomy to take someones kidney's from them without their permission.
Further, you neglect the fact that a fetus is recieving its oxygen supply through its "dialysis machine". So, a more similar equivalent would be considering whether or not it would be feasible for you to suffocate that person while withdrawing your tube/ removing your kidney.