- Joined
- Feb 24, 2022
- Messages
- 1,118
- Reaction score
- 4,477
He was just observing a moment of silence for Ukraine.
He was thinking about all that kickback money deposited into his offshore account after being laundered through Ukraine.He was just observing a moment of silence for Ukraine.
You've never had a stroke/TIA where a patient was aphasic only? We see it all the time, and about half of them have a stroke identified on MRI even though they recovered fully.Have you ever seen a TIA where the pt is motionless and speechless? I have not. I won’t put the probability at 0, but it’s very very low IMO. Moreover he responds when spoken to. It’s more likely a simple partial seizure (if that was pathology).
Some other congressman or senator had a video of him talking and he actually had a TIA or stroke. I think it was rand Paul or Ron paul, can’t remember.
I read all these twitter comments and everyone is like call 911 STAT!!! One MD! wrote “he needs a stat head CT!!!!”
Jeez
I’m not missing anythingYes, SDH can affect the temporal lobe for sure and you do not need to have significant mass effect to have seizure from SDH. I am not saying he certainly has a SDH affecting the temporal lobe, just saying that I would not be surprised if he did. I've seen dozens of patients with no symptoms from SDH other than seizure and with no motor deficits at all. He could have a new GBM or many other causes of seizures originating in the temporal lobe. Also, automatisms are very frequently absent in complex partial seizures. If you require them for a dx of complex partial seizures then you are missing tons of seizures.
I also agree that this could have been presyncope. I already said that. Without a time machine and full ECoG coverage, we will never know. The one certainty was that it was not a TIA so lets stop the stroke code madness and protect our EM brothers/sisters from the medmal liability monster. 50% of Neurologists would have gladly called this a "TIA" and sent the guy home on DAPT.
Aphasia can occur in isolation in TIA or stroke. However this was not aphasia. This was anarthria with behavioral arrest.You've never had a stroke/TIA where a patient was aphasic only? We see it all the time, and about half of them have a stroke identified on MRI even though they recovered fully.
You mean Russia?He was just observing a moment of silence for Ukraine.
This just illustrates the dangerousness of a single organ specialist working up an undifferentiated complaint. They don’t know anything broad about pathology. They don’t know what they don’t know (the good ones admit that). There is no way this was due to a UTI, unlikely to be due to hypotension without collapse, and also unlikely to be due to hypoglycemia. This is where the expertise of an EP comes through. We frequently see presentations of pathology from every specialty. Conjecture from subspecialist about other subspecialties is often errant. Befuddlement, brain fart, old brain, and the vapors are more valid explanations than UTI. TIA, focal seizure and presyncope are much higher on the differential.I’m not missing anything
I can confidently tell you that because I’ve seen hundreds of these consults
All of their EEGs and MRIs were unremarkable
And automatism is not an infrequent association with temporal lobe seizures. Look up the literature. The majority of focal lobe epilepsy is associated with automatism
I still maintain that common things being common. This was either a BP or blood sugar problem. Perhaps he has a UTI who knows.
It is not aphasia and he didn’t have a facial droop like some people here are claiming
Also it’s too short for it to be a seizure. It was what 20 seconds long?
Lol okayThis just illustrates the dangerousness of a single organ specialist working up an undifferentiated complaint. They don’t know anything broad about pathology. They don’t know what they don’t know (the good ones admit that). There is no way this was due to a UTI, unlikely to be due to hypotension without collapse, and also unlikely to be due to hypoglycemia. This is where the expertise of an EP comes through. We frequently see presentations of pathology from every specialty. Conjecture from subspecialist about other subspecialties is often errant. Befuddlement, brain fart, old brain, and the vapors are more valid explanations than UTI. TIA, focal seizure and presyncope are much higher on the differential.
This just illustrates the dangerousness of a single organ specialist working up an undifferentiated complaint. They don’t know anything broad about pathology. They don’t know what they don’t know (the good ones admit that). There is no way this was due to a UTI, unlikely to be due to hypotension without collapse, and also unlikely to be due to hypoglycemia. This is where the expertise of an EP comes through. We frequently see presentations of pathology from every specialty. Conjecture from subspecialist about other subspecialties is often errant. Befuddlement, brain fart, old brain, and the vapors are more valid explanations than UTI. TIA, focal seizure and presyncope are much higher on the differential.
You wrote automatism “very frequently absent”.Amen. Be very afraid of any physician that claims they never miss anything ("I’m not missing anything") because he is about to be humbled. About 25% of complex partial seizures have extra-temporal origin and are more likely to lack automatisms. One of us has read the literature already on this. I've also seen hundreds of these consults and have seen hundreds of video EEGs with CPS recorded and many lacked automatisms. I never said that "automatism is an infrequent association with temporal lobe seizures". Majority have them and 25%ish do not. Last I checked 25% != 0%.
This very well could have been presyncope as I already said again and again. However, if you had seen a thousand presyncope cases then you would be familiar with a tell-tale sign of a patient trying to stabilize himself prior to and during the event. Old Mitch made zero attempt to do so. He likely has an amnestic window to the entire event.
And come on man UTI? You are just pouring gas on the negative fire stereotype of Neurologists. This is why ED MDs are stop listening 5 seconds into a Neurologist giving recommendations.
Presyncope isn’t syncope. Presyncope isn’t always due to orthostatic hypotension.You wrote automatism “very frequently absent”.
Look, we all agree that nothing is definitive, but common things being common. Temporal seizures typically associate with automatism and typically have a duration of 30 seconds to 2 mins. Neither of these two features were present.
Presyncope has triggers. Orthostatic hypotension is a very common one. The poster Mount doesn’t think it’s BP problem without collapse, yet he still maintains presyncope is among the highest differentials.
Regarding the UTI comment, it was to illustrate that encephalopathy (or delirium) in elderly can be provoked by a simple infection.
Mount’s post was insulting. He painted specialists with a broad brush saying we lack sufficient knowledge about broad pathology. Yet, he dismisses the input of two neurologists that this event was unlikely to be a TIA. He could use his own advice to learn some humility.
You guys see that video of him? He was talking and just froze.
So much speculation that he had a TIA or a stroke…or absense seizure.
I think no way this was ischemic in nature. I suppose it could have been a partial seizure, maybe an absense seizure but he is definitely out of the age group for that.
To me it looks like he just stared into space for awhile. We all do that. Notice how he conveniently wakes up when someone addresses him?
We need term limits. I think most Americans would vote for this but those in power would never. Dems/Rep all play in the same sandbox, set the same rules, and fight with each other with the only goal of being voted back in. II just think it's amazing that the greatest country in the world has 80 year olds running things.
Looks like a pretty clear cut near syncopal episode. He appears quite unsteady on his feet. Although this discussion of people saying he was aphasic from a TIA or having a seizure just brings me back to how annoying these patient and mostly patient family interactions can be when they describe clear cut syncope prodrome, lack of focal neuro deficits, and near immediate return to mental baseline and you explain this to them, and you get the “I’m a nurse/doctor, I know what I saw, this was a” insert stroke/seizure/TIA. I’ve found that even many of my EM colleagues have a hard time differentiating syncope from seizure when it is happening right in front of them.
If you watch him take questions 10 mins after, he certainly did not return to baseline - he was confused and kept mumbling "I am fine"
Aphasia can occur in isolation in TIA or stroke. However this was not aphasia. This was anarthria with behavioral arrest.
So you're saying he knew what he was going to say but his muscles were paralyzed preventing him from doing so? Wouldn't he also exhibit facial droop when this occurred? Anarthria usually means people can understand speech but can't speak it. Did he seem to understand what was going on around him?THAT's THE DIAGNOSIS. I've never seen or heard of anarthria. Love it.
So you're saying he knew what he was going to say but his muscles were paralyzed preventing him from doing so? Wouldn't he also exhibit facial droop when this occurred? Anarthria usually means people can understand speech but can't speak it. Did he seem to understand what was going on around him?
He’s still in a hallway bed.Since we're all speculating, does anyone know if his evaluation has been released? I'm guessing he wouldn't have any issues getting a full workup in a timely manner.
I hope that's the case because nothing will initiate real healthcare reform like an upset US Senator.He’s still in a hallway bed.
Lol you know they all get “vip” service and are shielded from the realities their constituents face.I hope that's the case because nothing will initiate real healthcare reform like an upset US Senator.
Didn't work when I had a very prominent US Senator sandwiched between two smelly homeless patients separated by curtains.I hope that's the case because nothing will initiate real healthcare reform like an upset US Senator.
You guys r overthinking this.
1. CT, pan labs, ekg, cxr
2. Call hospitlaist
3. Move on. Majority of the time the neurologist won’t have an answer anyhow.
You guys r overthinking this.
1. CT, pan labs, ekg, cxr
2. Call hospitlaist
3. Move on. Majority of the time the neurologist won’t have an answer anyhow.
Amen. The Neurologist is more than happy to be left out of these "spells" where the clinical event was vague and the patient is totally back to normal prior to ED arrival. When you call me and describe in third-hand info what the patient's wife told EMS who told you who is now telling me, my answer is always going to be: "I have no idea what this was either. If you are asking me whether this was presyncope or seizure or stroke I will never be able to answer that for you. If that is the concern then you can work-up all of the above. I'm more than happy to write that in a note so that the Hospitalist does not try and block the admission."
We have video of ole Mitch's "spell" and there is still contention.
Have you ever seen an MRI in action? It doesn't go "BRRR," it goes "BANG BANG BANG."
Mitch McConnell happened to Mitch McConnell.What happened to Mitch McConnell?
It happened again!
Definitely a seizure. Take a close look at his eye movements. He has right upward deviation that resolves shortly before he recovers. I would CT him and wager on a chronic left SDH.
Theoretically possible for this to be a TIA localizing to right frontotemporal, but unlikely.
That's what I'm thinking. His eyes looked deviated up and to the right.He's clearly not well. Still not a TIA. Absence seizure? His eyes rolled back a bit. There's a better video of the event on YouTube.
In a not-so-shocking revelation, they govern better while they’re seizing. Less chance they mess something up.Proof that there is severe debility and incompetence in both parties.
He's clearly not well. Still not a TIA. Absence seizure? His eyes rolled back a bit. There's a better video of the event on YouTube.
Agreed. He's done a terrible job of representing the wishes of his constituents. Best he freeze up and stop the government from doing anything.In a not-so-shocking revelation, they govern better while they’re seizing. Less chance they mess something up.
I think Mitch has probably had more workups than most of us combined. His doctor needs to put him on keppra and call it a day.That's what I'm thinking. His eyes looked deviated up and to the right.
Maybe he just needed to rebuffer his thought stream.
In all seriousness, dude needs a major workup.