Question no. 12, block 2.
I'll paraphrase the question: A 5 year old child with a viral URTI is brought in by her mother. She asks for a prescription of antibiotics for her child, mentioning that "last time" he was prescribed some by another doctor, and they helped him. What would be the most appropriate response?
Option C was: "Why do you think antibiotics would help your son recover?"
Option E was: "I understand your concern, but antibiotics would not treat your child's illness and would put him at risk of adverse effects"
I remember a similar question in UWorld, and the general idea I've picked up is to always engage the patient in a discussion to understand his/her thinking, so that it can be addressed. For this reason, I picked C, since I felt it was the better way to initiate dialogue, as opposed to E, which I felt comes afterwards. This is in line with what I've learned in UWorld.
The correct answer was E. C was marked as incorrect because it was "condescending". English isn't my first language, but I'm by no means poor at it. I have difficulty understanding how option C is condescending, unless the tone made it so. Considering 64% got the question right, I can only conclude I'm missing something thats preventing me from realizing what makes C condescending/rude.
Any help will be appreciated!
I'll paraphrase the question: A 5 year old child with a viral URTI is brought in by her mother. She asks for a prescription of antibiotics for her child, mentioning that "last time" he was prescribed some by another doctor, and they helped him. What would be the most appropriate response?
Option C was: "Why do you think antibiotics would help your son recover?"
Option E was: "I understand your concern, but antibiotics would not treat your child's illness and would put him at risk of adverse effects"
I remember a similar question in UWorld, and the general idea I've picked up is to always engage the patient in a discussion to understand his/her thinking, so that it can be addressed. For this reason, I picked C, since I felt it was the better way to initiate dialogue, as opposed to E, which I felt comes afterwards. This is in line with what I've learned in UWorld.
The correct answer was E. C was marked as incorrect because it was "condescending". English isn't my first language, but I'm by no means poor at it. I have difficulty understanding how option C is condescending, unless the tone made it so. Considering 64% got the question right, I can only conclude I'm missing something thats preventing me from realizing what makes C condescending/rude.
Any help will be appreciated!