- Joined
- Nov 24, 2007
- Messages
- 11
- Reaction score
- 0
.//////////////////
Since when should we forget about Character, morals and honesty when picking people for medical school? I think times will change back to these values its a cycle if look back in history.
Interesting. What I don't understand is that if Caribbean schools have indeed decided they're *with* US allopathic institutions, why haven't they elected to pursue LCME accreditation? Some Canadian schools are LCME-accredited despite the fact that they are in Canada so geography can't be the answer. If the Caribbean schools have embraced the training missions and priorities of the US allopathic schools, why not just become LCME accredited? The LCME would accredit any school that meets the criteria and has the $$$. There must be more to the story.
Well the short answer from me would be that I don't know (or was that a rhetorical question). I've heard unsubstantiated reasons as to why Caribbean schools can't/don't want LCME accreditation. I do know the bylaws of LCME state that they accredit US and Canadian schools, however I'm sure that could be changed if they decided to expand their scope. Perhaps it has something to do with the "for profit" model of the off-shore schools?
DID not SGU start to go through the process years ago then stopped when they realized they would not be accredited?Well the short answer from me would be that I don't know (or was that a rhetorical question). I've heard unsubstantiated reasons as to why Caribbean schools can't/don't want LCME accreditation. I do know the bylaws of LCME state that they accredit US and Canadian schools, however I'm sure that could be changed if they decided to expand their scope. Perhaps it has something to do with the "for profit" model of the off-shore schools?
Oldpro I've got no idea. I've never heard anything about that either way.DID not SGU start to go through the process years ago then stopped when they realized they would not be accredited?
Yea I thought it was SGU but it could have been AUC? It was one of them anyway.Oldpro I've got no idea. I've never heard anything about that either way.
AMG, IMG and DO all will give you a chance to practice medicine in America. It's the person under the white coat which will really make his/her respect.
Peace.
It sure sounds like a nice generalization. But these degrees afford ppl different opporunities at the gate. I'd say AMG MD being the best option. Though statistically almost 50% of U.S M.D still go te FP and IM route. Of course matching the IM at the university hospital with great shot at the fellowship program isn't the same as getting into community program. Bot U.S M.D an D.O routes are far more preferable to IMG, no matter what your goals may be.
It sure sounds like a nice generalization. But these degrees afford ppl different opporunities at the gate. I'd say AMG MD being the best option. Though statistically almost 50% of U.S M.D still go te FP and IM route. Of course matching the IM at the university hospital with great shot at the fellowship program isn't the same as getting into community program. Bot U.S M.D an D.O routes are far more preferable to IMG, no matter what your goals may be.
Very few sane medical students go into FP, why?? The average FP makes 170k a year, with many medical students with multiple six figure debts, many will want to go into lucrative specialty fields. Anesthesiologists make 300k+ on average and many can make 500k a year.
The OP would have to be insane to pick a Caribbean school if he has the option of going to a US DO program.
I do not get the Point? I know plenty of FMG's and IMG's who did get into great Residencies, I personally am going FP Rural route by choice.
So whats the point?
There is no point, this forum is going no where productive.
amg, img and do who's is best, let residency weed out those who are book smart but suck in clinicals.
I know that school, it's in Australia, Hut river?I'm making my medical degree in photoshop...i can go wherever i want and i can also switch schools with little work.
DO,DO,DO>>>>>>>>>>>>Caribbean MD. bottom line
DO,DO,DO>>>>>>>>>>>>Caribbean MD. bottom line
DO,DO,DO>>>>>>>>>>>>Caribbean MD. bottom line
An MD degree generally makes it easier to practice overseas but don't think that medicine is lucrative outside of the US. In many other countries with socialized medicine, salaries are lower.
McGillGrad illustrated the difficulty of practicing overseas, mentioning European physicians driving taxis in Quebec. I think the only countries that are somewhat open to IMGs outside of the US are Australia and the UK, but they have issues as well. Australia gives preferential treatment to British and South African physicians but physicians from other countries are often discriminated against. Dubai and some oil producing Gulf States hire Western physicians but do you really want to live in the Middle East?
Facts are that this does not include outside the match this is only
But the above poster continues to ignor the plain facts ( this is just something he and I will never agree on), the real facts that outside the match is at least 10% (I believe higher like 20%) so that raises the lowest figure to 60% match rate but I think its way higher like 70% IMO. Hey reality is reality!
Just my Opinion.
AMG, IMG and DO all will give you a chance to practice medicine in America. It's the person under the white coat which will really make his/her respect.
Peace.
Your GPA is excellent, you might want to take a tutoring course to raise your MCAT. If that is your only option DO is better than going to a Caribbean school.
OK, even though this thread is much more comfortable now that certain posters that like to spread misinformation are "ignored" from my view, here's some hard data for people to ponder. A caveat: I have nothing against foreign medical grads, but when people start dissing the profession I love and spreading blatant lies, I use truth and actual data (DOs have to take both the COMLEX and USMLE to be licensed...you're kidding me, right?)
Anyway, here it is:
According to the American Medical Association, the top 20 countries where IMGs come from are:
India - 19.9% (47,581)
Philippines - 8.7% (20,861)
Mexico - 5.8% (13,929)
Pakistan - 4.8% (11,330)
Dominican Republic - 3.3% (7,892)
U.S.S.R. - 2.5% (6,039)
Grenada - 2.4% (5,708)
Egypt - 2.2% (5,202)
Korea - 2.1% (4,982)
Italy - 2.1% (4,978)
China - 2.0% (4,834)
Iran - 2.0% (4,741)
Spain - 1.9% (4,570)
Dominica - 1.9% (4,501)
Germany - 1.9% (4,457)
Syria - 1.5% (3,676)
Columbia - 1.4% (3,335)
Israel 1.4% (3,260)
England- 1.4% (3,245)
Montserrat (3,111)
According to the AMA website, this information is from 2007, pretty current. http://www.ama-assn.org/ama/pub/category/1550.html
According the the Educational Commision for Foreign Medical Graduates, the match rate for ALL IMGs in 2007 was 47%. The match rate for US citizen IMGs for the same year was 50% (yikes!).
http://www.ecfmg.org/cert/factcard.pdf
Now, most people in this forum like to tell you that statistics for IMGs are skewed because people from the big 4 pass the USMLE at high rates and therefore match at high rates compared to other countries, and that IMGs from "other" countries (i.e. non-Caribbean big 4) are the ones that are bringing down the total average.
However, how do you explain the fact that:
1- According to the ECFMG, as a US citizen going abroad for a medical education, you might as well flip a coin for your future (50% match rate?!?!)
2- If supposedly most of the IMGs that pass the USMLE (and therefore become licensed to practice in the US) are from the "big 4", how come most of the IMG physicians in this country are from countries other than the big 4? Grenada (home of SGU) comes in at #7 (at least it's top ten), and the next "big 4" (Dominica, home of Ross) comes in at #14? If most IMGs that pass the USMLE are from the big 4, wouldn't it make sense that the top 4 spots for IMGs in the US are from Dominica, Grenada, Montserrat and Saba? Heck, there are more Russian IMGs in the US than from the big 4 Caribbean schools.
Again, I have nothing against IMGs, but if you piss me off, I pull the big gun: TRUTH. Would you rather have a 100% chance of being a physician, or flip a coin with a 50% chance (and be behind foreign medical graduates from India, Mexico, Russia, Dominican Republic, Egypt, Italy, Iran (IRAN??!)...)
To the OP: choose the path that is best for your personal situation and future plans. However, be warned that a lot of the anonymous information in here and in sites such as valuemd are very biased and plain wrong. Follow the links I've provided in this thread, which come from reputable, unbiased places and make your own decision. Whatever you decide, good luck and I hope you achieve your goal.
A DO is better to have than an "MD" from a Caribbean school. Obviously if you have an MD from a North American school it is another matter.
Anti Caribbean M.D.? Is that because most Caribbean M.D.'s match into more competitive spots than primary care D.O.'s.. Last I checked the Caribbean / FMG M.D.'s that were getting competitive residencies like Neurosurgery, etc... had Ziltch (0) D.O.'s matching into those positions or the ratio was Caribbean > D.O. for competitive.... Ah M.D. really is an M.D. not matter where you go....
Personally, i dont think Allo residencies should accept DO applicants nor should DO applicants should apply. You go to a DO school cause you believe in the philosophy. I was accepted to DO schools, Carrib MD and waitlisted at US MD schools. I choose Carrib MD because i truly did not believe in the DO philosophy and OMM. I will not wast a year of my life and all the effort in learning an unproven, boderline witchcraft OMM techniques. Also, DO residencies are being left unfilled more and more. DO students should be required to at least do an internship year at a AOA accredited hospital in order to be liscened. You are a DO after all shouldnt you do at least some post grad training in a DO program
Personally, i dont think Allo residencies should accept DO applicants nor should DO applicants should apply. You go to a DO school cause you believe in the philosophy. I was accepted to DO schools, Carrib MD and waitlisted at US MD schools. I choose Carrib MD because i truly did not believe in the DO philosophy and OMM. I will not wast a year of my life and all the effort in learning an unproven, boderline witchcraft OMM techniques. Also, DO residencies are being left unfilled more and more. DO students should be required to at least do an internship year at a AOA accredited hospital in order to be liscened. You are a DO after all shouldnt you do at least some post grad training in a DO program
i didnt realize the numbers were so drastic in regards to DO residency spots and DO grads. Then DO grads should have to apply to DO residency then only if they dont recieve a spot then go to MD residency.
I also believe that ALL residency spots in the US should be filled by all eligiable US citizens before a single non- US citizen is taken into residency.
Bingo! Back in the day when DOs were second class citizens only people that truly felt the DO path was a better path to medicine became DOs.
Today, MD and DO are the same. Same drugs, same specilaties, same stethoscopes, same shiny red cars. A blessing and a curse.
As someone once said, Osteopathic medicine is a victim of its own success.
DID not SGU start to go through the process years ago then stopped when they realized they would not be accredited?
LOL, depends on the Caribbean school... AUC, St. George, Ross not as good as a D.O. school... Your kidding, right... Most of the faculty at these places are from medical schools in the states like Johns Hopkins, mayo clinic... Others are from Cambridge, Oxford, Austrialia, Russia (list goes on)... These 3 Caribbean schools match just as well if not better in M.D. competitive residencies than D.O.'s... Going to one of these forementioned 3 is like attening any other medical school (in terms of education) whether your in the U.S. or in France, Ukraine, Ireland, etc....In the end, you get the same degree(M.D.) and learn the same sort of material that physicians have been learning for decades...
Maybe? If you remember I hate these debates with a passion since I see practice as the goal, of course its better to take the best route for your future.oldpro, do you remember me from studentdoc.com? My name on there was Wagdog1.
Two years ago PCOM had a specialty match rate of >67%, rivaling Harvard and JHU... care to revise your statement?