I'm going to begin an OAT section on
www.optometrystudents.com for anyone who is interested (it is completely free so I don't think this violates any advertisement rules??) The site is new and it may be a couple weeks until too much is up, but rest assured I'll do my best to help create this section, so please check it out!
A big thanks to everyone who has posted side by side scores and/or comments, as I'm trying to collate as much data on this as possible.
Long Post, jump to last paragraph for the practice vs. real test scoring conclusions.
I took my OAT on August 15, here are my side by side scores, Opted are in Parentheses:
Bio: (390) 400
General Chemistry (380) 400
Organic Chemistry (350) 390
Reading Comprehension (400) 350 This is just too easy on opted to give an accurate assessment!!
Physics (390) 380
Quantitative Reasoning (400) 400
Note: I counted my correct answers as WRONG when scoring my practice test for the handful of questions on it in which the answer key is wrong. I knew that would never affect the overall score by much, so I didn't really care.
My thoughts on the differences:
Reading Comprehension is ALL about finding a strategy that works FOR YOU! I've said it on many other threads, and I'll briefly repeat here, that the Opted practice reading comp is not at all indicative of your expected oat performance.
According to most people I've heard from so far, all the other sections seemed similar (at least in content) to the opted test, except that yes, biology is very random, so you will likely be asked things on that section you'd have no idea to study for simply based off of the opted practice test.
The remaining question is, did the scoring scale make the actual oat more harsh than the practice test scale?? I still don't have enough data as of yet, so please ANYONE who has taken the oat with the new scale, please post your opted vs. real scores. But, I'm virtually certain the opted practice test DOES USE the old scoring system; I just haven't figured out yet in precisely what ways the new scoring system affects the oat.
However, I do have preliminary guidelines for scoring comparisons based on around a dozen samples; not great at all, but better than nothing I guess. Excluding Reading Comprehension (which is a terrible section on the practice test), most physics, gen. chem and organic chem scores are rarely substantially lower (if lower at all) on the actual oat than the opted practice test. Bio and QR, for whatever reason, are seemingly more likely to be significantly lower (20 or more points). Unfortunately, this could easily be a statistical fluke resulting from the small sample size; I wouldn't even bother using a chi-squared statistical analysis on my conclusions even with double the sample size! Please note that it is very common for multiple scores to go up, sometimes significantly, between the practice and actual oat (I attribute this largely to studying/preparation in the interim time period).
Hope this helps!! And again, I'll start working on an oat section for the site listed above, so please check that out by late september.