- Joined
- Sep 21, 2010
- Messages
- 243
- Reaction score
- 0
Hello everyone. I am a second year who will write the exam in June 2011. Meanwhile let this be a good thread where everyone share their study progress and recent trend of the exam.
when did you start the qbanks?Ok so here is my advice for step: My usmle score was 269/99. Main advice is DO MASSIVE AMOUNTS OF QUESTIONS!! Not once did I read/study goljan rapid review, goljan audio or BRS physiology. I spent the vast majority of my time doing questions. I know its hard to tell on forums which people are just geniuses but let me tell you I am NOT one of those people. In terms of intrinsic IQ/memorization skills I am very average for a medical student. I have to study much harder to get the same grades as those genius people in my med school class.'
Refer to my previous posts for what I was scoring on NBME's, uworld percentage etc.
More Hx-I have had about a year of clinical experience before taking the step.Yes it helped a little bit. When I first started clinics I studied my ass off
but still performed very average on shelf exams (70s range). But my last clinic (medicine) I switched to a new system where I only did questions to study and I did NO reading whatsoever-only questions. My shelf score for medicine=99. So, I continued this method for step and as you can see it paid off immensely.
No only do questions, but whenever you miss a question or learn something from a question write it down on a separate sheet of paper. This is SO important and valuable and high yield-because later on you can read over these notes (write maybe a sentence max for each question short notes-they add up quickly) and remember what you learned from a question a month or two ago.
Now yes you should still go through first aid because this is the most high yield of any source. But go through it fast-limit yourself to ONE WEEK going through first aid. No you are not going to learn even 50% of it in that week but you will learn a little bit and reinforce and learn more by doing questions. I used goljan/brs only to look up things I was unsure about from questions I did-I repeat-use these only as a reference! Question banks (except for uworld) are notorious for having errors so if you arent sure about something yes look it up in goljan/first aid/brs or Wikipedia (my personal favorite).
After the first week of going through first aid my advice is the following: do 200 questions a day. This is very doable and you will still have time to write
short notes for the questions you do. I would do the following question banks in this order
1st: UsmleRx-an easier question bank, has some errors but relatively fewish compared to other qbanks. In the explanation for the question it has the first aid page image to view. Good for learning more from first aid
2nd: Kaplan. Also fewish errors compared to other banks. Questions more picky but overall a good qbank.
3rd: robbins rapid review qbank. Would recommend purchasing online subscription so you can go back and do the questions you missed. DONT purchase subscription to usmleconsult. This qbank is SO INCREDIBLY ERROR FILLED. I started doing this qbank and got frustrated after 1 day because of the incorrect questions and massive amounts of errors. I dont care that goljan approved it, he has obviously never done a single question from this bank. It is a horrible question bank I repeat dont waste your money. If anything your score will decrease by doing these questions because the answers are incorrect and the explanations are WRONG.
4th: Uworld. Do this one last so it is fresh. MARK the questions you got right but only because you guessed or werent really sure about the answer. Go back and do these in addition to the ones you missed.
While doing qbanks do ALL of the nbmes, the free 150 as well as the two uworld assessments. In the beginning I did these tests every two weeks. Towards the end I did a couple of week including two full length test simulations
Ok that is my advice. Not saying this will work for everyone, but for me as a student who has a hard time memorizing information this is finally the system that worked for me. As you can tell Im not one of those superstars that has always done amazing on shelf exams etc that test knowledge. (if anyone wants to know my MCAT score was 34). After doing average on shelf exams I took a risk and changed the way I study and it has paid off. Please let me know if you have any questions about this method-but I think many people would benefit from studying this way.
Seriously almost every question I had on my actual exam I felt like I had encountered a question testing similar concepts before. I had very few WTF questions but had I not done so many questions I would have had many many more WTF questions. A theme I saw on usmle forums is people who
were scoring around 270ish all did at least 3 or 4 question banks-not just
uworld.
Good luck to everyone!
First I couldn't stop thinking about the exam because I was studying for the stupid exam, now that I have taken it I still can't stop thinking about it! I swear I'm just going to drive myself nuts.
I keep going over all the mistakes I made in my head, totally forgotten what I answered on some of these mistakes, which adds another fun dimension. I have completely convinced myself that this was an extremely easy form (not for me mind you) and that I bombed it.
I promised myself that if I did well, I would post here. Long-time lurker.
Couple of tips.
1. Remember: this test is a marathon, not a race. The goal of your studying should be to orchestrate it in such a way that you memorize as much as you can for test day. If you forget tons of stuff the day after the test, you succeeded. I forgot tons of things studied the first couple weeks until I went through First Aid again, and again. It is a marathon, not a race!
2. There is no need to study 1st year stuff (biochem, anatomy, etc) during 2nd year, except physio since that can help with pathophys. You will simply forget all the things you relearned by the time you start your dedicated studying (and will spend time again relearning it). Focus on understanding 2nd year content, so by the time you hit up First Aid, you will not need to look up basic concepts in another book.
3. Do not use too many resources! There is a reason 95% of the people on this board recommend FA + UWorld + (maybe) Goljan book/audio. This is because 95% of the people learned enough during 2nd year to prepare them for the rote memorization of dedicated studying time (which First Aid and UWorld have plenty of).
4. Do not do questions with First Aid in front of you! There is no point in testing how well you can look up things in First Aid. I incorrectly felt justified when I did this with USMLERx, since "I can memorize it later," but this is simply a waste of time. I will say that I got really good at doing questions, but it did not help me learn the material. All in all, I did about 7500 questions from various sources. That's a high number to hit, but it helps!
5. Take a vacation after the exam! This was something I kept looking forward to during my studying, and my month off recharged my batteries well enough for the grind of rotations now.
6. For scheduling, do the three P's first (Physiology, Pathology, Pharm) because these are the most important and most challenging (50% of the test). Do the hardest subjects first when you are not exhausted, because you will hit the wall later. I believe I was very motivated during my 7 weeks of studying, because I promised myself I will never study this hard again in my life. I still hit the wall here and there. Leave the last two weeks or so to cover First Aid again (and hopefully a third time in maybe 2-3 days).
7. Buy the Kaplan qBank BOOK. This book has 850 questions that are also found online. The book is cheap (like $40), and you don't have to worry about your time expiring. I got really frustrated about the nit-picky questions, but it helped solidify the stuff I just learned in First Aid. The USMLERx book is also good for the same reason, but these questions were a regurgitation of First Aid.
8. Everyone has learned how they study best during med school. For me, I studied best away from home. I found a city library close by that had individual rooms where I could crank out 6-8 hours, taking only 5 min breaks. This helped me go through First Aid, which I found really hard to concentrate on. Questions were much easier for me to complete and review, so I tended to do these at home.
9. Exercise. Exercise. Exercise! Find what relieves the stress (as there is plenty of stress), and exercising REALLY helps relieve the stress. If I didn't run or play soccer for more than 2 days, the stress really got to me. I was in the best shape of my life during studying, seriously!!!
10. Day before the test: I finished studying at noon, and spent the rest of the day with my girlfriend (biking, eating dinner, watching a movie). I completely forgot about the exam during this time and relaxed, which was simply amazing. But I am a pretty chill guy compared to my peers, so YMMV.
11. Test day: I got a 30 minute jog and hot tub time in the morning before getting ready. I felt this really relaxed me. Maybe it relaxed me too much, because I had some trouble concentrating on the first block (which I found to be the hardest for me). But my stamina was really good through the day (maybe due to the running and hot tub), munching on some snacks and drinking some gatorade between blocks. I was used to 7 blocks in one day, because I had two opportunities to practice that many blocks in one day during my preparation. A lot of people take 2-3 blocks at a time, but I think this is wrong. You need to rest your mind every hour and reduce the anxiety, and I had more than 15 minutes extra of break time at the end. Don't eat a big lunch! Your mind will shut down for the next couple blocks afterward. It is a marathon, not a race!
12. You will wake up one morning with a question on your mind that you had during the exam. I had trouble sleeping past 8AM after the test. This sucked, but keep your mind off the exam! Do some fun stuff, like going to an amusement park, going on vacation, stealing some cars, breaking into a bank, cheating on your gf, etc. It will definitely keep your mind off the exam.
Pre-studying school administered exam: 195 (this was the most pointless test, because it is a really old test. It simply tested rote-memorization rather than connecting concepts together, which is the beauty of the boards today. So take it with grains and grains of salt!)
4/25 - UWSA1 225 (Pretty excited since my initial goal was a 230+. I still got half the questions wrong, so I felt like an idiot)
5/2 - NBME7 235 (Pumped. Improved, and got lots of questions right. Lots of people say NBME7 is close to the real exam)
5/9 - UWSA2 230 (Boo. Still getting lots of questions wrong)
5/16 - NBME12 247 (Woah. I was completely shocked, and I did not believe this score. I adjusted my goal score to be 240+ and my dream score to be 250)
5/23 - NBME11 238 (This was a downer. I did this test 1.5 weeks before the test, so that I had time to improve, but yet did not want to freak myself out from a bad score. I'm going to tell you, getting this score was the best thing that ever happened to me. I was super dedicated to improving the score and studied like I never studied before, like 12-14 hours a day. Also, I got 87% correct!! WTF?).
6/4 - Real Thing 252 (Jaw dropping. I was in an interview with a patient at the time I got my score haha. I truly believe that walking into the test with as little stress as possible will help. Go on a run and hit the hot tub that morning. I started a little slow, but I was so stress-free I could not believe I was flying through the test. I kept thinking I was going to get a bad score like everyone else thinks, because I felt so care-free during the day, like I was doing something way wrong. You will think you failed, whether you did bad or good, guaranteed!)
As for the subjects on the test, it covers everything and everyone will get a different test. Of course I had questions from left field (partial pressure of nitrogen anyone?), but you have to just answer it and move on. Save the time for questions that you really need to think about.
Recap:
1. UWorld + First Aid + maybe Goljan = success (no other resources needed)
2. You will be plenty motivated to study, but you will be super stressed. Find ways to relieve stress every other day (exercise!!)
3. Take NBMEs and UW-SAs, but at least a week between each. Take the last one 10-15 days before the real test to give you time to really improve.
4. Study the hardest subjects first (3 P's) while you have energy and not burned out.
5. Set a date to start stressing about the exam (for me was 4 months before), and start preparing then.
SGU representin'
what it isssssssss
Seems fake.I benefited a lot from this thread and decided to post my experience after the test.
I am a DO student.
USMLE step 1 = 274/99
I am an international student and rely heavily on private loans. I am very broke so I could not afford any Q Banks or any review materials except some free kaplan books my school gave to me and a 2008 copy of the first AID. I relied mostly on text books from my school library. It was very tough using these text books. I put in a lot of work, realising that i was at a disadvantage. The Kaplan books combined with FA worked miracles for me. I also used a internal medicine book used by students preparing for the step 2 that helped me a lot as far as diagnosis and treatment goes.
my advice is this,
1. know your intracellular signaling pathways.
2. immunology
3 molecular biology.
4. pathology.
These accounted for 94% of all my questions.
Seems fake.
DO student here, got a 240/99. I was hoping for anything above a 230, so I'm happy.
Used First Aid, Goljan, and UWorld.
If I were to do it all over again, I would've skipped class a lot more and started studying about a month earlier (I have a terrible memory and 1.5 months of dedicated study time didn't feel like enough time to relearn all the stuff I'd forgotten plus learn all the stuff I never learned in the first place...).
Hope the rest of you got the scores you wanted!
definitely ...unless this person was already a practicing physician in his home country...but even then it's still unbelievable
Sorry guys, I dont think you got my point. I am an international student currently enrolled @ Des Moines university, a DO school in the US.
Sorry guys, I dont think you got my point. I am an international student currently enrolled @ Des Moines university, a DO school in the US.
Kind of sad..why is there so much hostility towards this DO student anyways? Perhaps he did get the score he did and he clearly seems to have put in a lot of extra effort to obtain relevant tested information. Its not unfathomable to learn the basics principles of medicine and understand them inside out and be able to figure out whats being tested in a question even if you haven't had access to q-banks or 2011 FA. Granted it makes it a lot easier but its not impossible. If this person really did do it then they deserve credit for putting in all the legwork themselves. With that said, I just recently took my step and I can see that FA was helpful, but I can also fully see how I could have studied independently of FA using it simply as a guideline and do all the legwork myself and make all the connections myself. I could have pulled off an equal performance.
...end rant/
just because you feel something is hard doesn't mean its not possible by someone else. Don't be so quick to judge and dismiss people. Besides, what difference does it make that some guy has that high score?
Kind of sad..why is there so much hostility towards this DO student anyways? Perhaps he did get the score he did and he clearly seems to have put in a lot of extra effort to obtain relevant tested information. Its not unfathomable to learn the basics principles of medicine and understand them inside out and be able to figure out whats being tested in a question even if you haven't had access to q-banks or 2011 FA. Granted it makes it a lot easier but its not impossible. If this person really did do it then they deserve credit for putting in all the legwork themselves. With that said, I just recently took my step and I can see that FA was helpful, but I can also fully see how I could have studied independently of FA using it simply as a guideline and do all the legwork myself and make all the connections myself. I could have pulled off an equal performance.
...end rant/
just because you feel something is hard doesn't mean its not possible by someone else. Don't be so quick to judge and dismiss people. Besides, what difference does it make that some guy has that high score?
I really did. Was gonna write up my prep and yada yada post my exam, but felt that there was no one wld want to listen to how a loser prepped haha. Or maybe they wld - to know how NOT to prep?
I really did feel like I failed. 8 brutal hours. Was pretty much depressed that night. Looked up some questions (which I NEVER do) after the exam - and I had missed some gimmes. Even more depressed.
My test was HARD. Def harder than uworld or the practice nbme's. Much much harder. I felt like I could have spent another 2+ wks on FA/Uworld and still wouldn't be enough prep. Yea, it was that bad. Soo depressing.
I was like 'the hell', 'what in the world', 'how am i supposed to know that', 'no way' etc etc throughout my ENTIRE test. lol during uworld practice, I usually marked like 10 or so...but always had at least 10-15 mins to go over each section. The real deal? Marked at least 20-30 (no joke), skipped at least 5-6 per section, and had just <5 mins to go over stuff at the end. So basically, I had zero time to go over my answers...something that I always did in med school. SUCKED. Stems were LONG, confusing (random hint - I dont even bother looking at all the lab values, 70% of them were useless detractors) and tiring. And the cute prometric chic that was hitting on me kept on coming into the room - extra distraction. Argh!
Anyways..
My uworld average was somewhere in the late 60's/early 70's. I cant say exactly cos I kept changing my wrong answers to the right ones when I started doing my prep lol I didnt want to see those depressing 40%. So I actually dropped from 90's at the beginning (LOL) to 60/70's when I decided I knew enough to not feel bad about my score.
Anyways, i'm pretty much an average (+/-) student in class - struggled to make the mean in 1st year exams...things got a bit better 2nd year and honored 3 or so classes, nothing really spectacular.
Boards prep - Total of 6-7 wks prep - about 8 hours a day (on a good day really)...I don't know how all ya'll do 12 hour days. Guess that why you guys all score in the 260's?
Used primarily FA (went over it 2ce) and uworld (1ce)...and wiki. Had an extra neuro resource here and barely touched brs path (but was a bit handy). Thats about it. Prayed a LOT before and after my exam lol definitely needed that and I believe it played a HUGE part in me passing.
I'm beginning to wonder though - is it better to get a harder test? Cos I mean, almost everyone is gonna bomb the harder test, so the curve is a bit better? Cos I promise you - I felt like I failed the thing. Was ridic hard. Maybe all my sections were experimental? No joke. I just wanted to pass at the end - got really really sad during my last block...
So yea - easier test = harder curve? idk..
Anyways, I scored in the mid 230's. Good enough for me really as I'm not going for anything super competitive and I really really did think I failed it...or at best didnt reach the 200 cut off.
Advice - work hard 2nd year. Start board prep early (only if you can and if it doesnt interfere with you learning 2nd year stuff!). I planned on starting early, bout my uworld qbank in January, all pumped and ready to go.
Didnt happen haha. Started using it in May or so. I personally didnt start early cos it was just a bit too much for me to do with all the learning 2nd year, but if you can, more power to you...def wldn't hurt. At least at least try to read a couple pages of FA or something. Wldn't hurt one bit.
FA and Uworld is really all you need. If you know those COLD, and then brush up on your weak areas with other resources, you're good to go.
Lastly, do you. Be honest with yourself about your strengths/weaknesses, and don't compare yourself with ANYONE in med school. Just do you and be the BEST you can be. Thats good enough.
Good luck ya'll.
Oh please.
I heard he also walked out of the exam after 6 blocks. And still got 274..... And then a bomb exploded. The noise bothered him very much so he sat down at a local cafe and drank a cup of green tea. Three weeks later he got his score - delivered to him by a phone call from Hugh Laurie who confirmed that, if the fictitious character Dr House had sat the exam, he wouldn't not have scored anywhere close to a 274.
Oh please.
I heard he also walked out of the exam after 6 blocks. And still got 274..... And then a bomb exploded. The noise bothered him very much so he sat down at a local cafe and drank a cup of green tea. Three weeks later he got his score - delivered to him by a phone call from Hugh Laurie who confirmed that, if the fictitious character Dr House had sat the exam, he wouldn't not have scored anywhere close to a 274.
Why does it matter so much to you if he's lying or telling the truth? Just take what he says with a few grains of salt, if you're suspicious that he's full of it.
Hey what are the NBME Practice tests that you took and where did you purchase them?
Thanks!
don't want some dumb extremely cheap med student to see that post and think that he doesn't have to spend any money preparing for step 1 and that he can just pick an old copy of FA and some old kaplan books from a trash can, use harrison's online version and score a 274. not going to happen.
I would hope that any reasonable med student would realize that once you get to the 270 level it has nothing to do with what materials you studied and more to do with natural talent.
I would hope that any reasonable med student would realize that once you get to the 270 level it has nothing to do with what materials you studied and more to do with natural talent. That being said, if this guy is for real then he's a smart dude. If you all think he's trolling, then why you feeding him homies?
Natural talent? What are you...I don't even...
If you ask me, anything past 250, the biggest factor is what form you got. In other words, luck.
NBME said:Scores on tests with relatively difficult items are adjusted up and those achieved on relatively easy items are adjusted down. These adjustments ensure that the scores that are awarded are comparable regardless of the particular combination of items on any examinee's test form and ensures fairness for all test takers.
Natural talent? What are you...I don't even...
If you ask me, anything past 250, the biggest factor is what form you got. In other words, luck.
WashMe said:If I'm great at topic "x" even though people score poorly on that topic on average, my score will be inflated and I was "lucky" I saw those questions. If I suck at a topic but most other people understand it well, I'll get screwed if I get a bunch of those questions because not only will I miss them, but I'll be scaled down since they are "easy"
According to the link I posted, they do not curve based on a student's performance on individual questions - they only adjust the score based on the final result of your performance on the entire form. If two people take the exact same test, one gets 20 challenging questions wrong, and the other gets 20 easy questions wrong, they both get the exact same score. (Which may be the same score as someone who gets 25 questions wrong on a slightly harder test.)
I think you have a very unrealistic view of the test in general. The NBME's standard error (usually +/- 2 points) specificallyaccounts for that factor of luck. In a 300+ question test, the statistical probability (that the majority of your questions will be in subjects you happen to know exceptionally well) is absolutely miniscule.
I don't mean to come off as arrogant, but it really sounds like you're just trying to make excuses..
You're expected to have a solid understanding of all of those basic disease processes. If you're lacking in one, its to your detriment. You seem to think the standard baseline expectation is a potluck and people either get extra lucky or not. The test material isn't designed that way.eeeeek said:the randomization for questions i'm sure it does not take that into account; the test doesnt have things like for GI, he needs to have 1 GERD, 1 diverticulosis, etc, i'm sure it just pulls 20-30 questions for GI
Is it really +/- 6? Color me surprised - that's a lot larger than I expected. Still not nearly enough (by threefold) to account for WashMe's claims, but I was definitely underestimating
You're expected to have a solid understanding of all of those basic disease processes. If you're lacking in one, its to your detriment. You seem to think the standard baseline expectation is a potluck and people either get extra lucky or not. The test material isn't designed that way.
Is it really +/- 6? Color me surprised - that's a lot larger than I expected. Still not nearly enough (by threefold) to account for WashMe's claims, but I was definitely underestimating
.
WashMe said:'d say that once you hit 250+, then +/- 5-10 points is luck. There is a real difference between a 250 and a 270 though IMO... and tig makes sure we all know it lol
Is it really +/- 6? Color me surprised - that's a lot larger than I expected. Still not nearly enough (by threefold) to account for WashMe's claims, but I was definitely underestimating
You're expected to have a solid understanding of all of those basic disease processes. If you're lacking in one, its to your detriment. You seem to think the standard baseline expectation is a potluck and people either get extra lucky or not. The test material isn't designed that way.