- Joined
- Oct 21, 2005
- Messages
- 3,039
- Reaction score
- 24
Yah - he's clearly planning on being up there at the top! You obviously have a gunner amongst you!
Lottery isn't based solely on luck. Granted that each class makes its own lottery system, but I believe each class has a chance to trade off the clinical sites so that the vast majority of students are happy. As for the rural internships, it comes with the curriculum and since NSU has been doing this for years, it must work to some degree.
You say that you have no choice so I guess it's a null point.
Doc 2b's "Don't go to NSU!!!" thread mysteriously disappeared...I guess he had a change of heart.
Basically, his complaint was this...
During your fourth year, July through December are the "hot" months to do audition rotations at places you'd be interested in for residency. At NSU, we have 3 required rotations to do doing fourth year: 1 month of emergency medicine, and 2 months of rurals. Now most people take the month of July as a study month for Step 2 of your boards, so if you have all 3 of those required rotations during that time, you are left with only 2 months to do away rotations. For the majority of people (myself included), rurals are done later in the year...so I have 4 months in which to do electives.
In his mind (and the minds of many others, including myself), audition rotations are a MAJOR factor in being selected for a residency program. If a program has seen you and know you work really well with them, they are MUCH more likely to take you on as a resident over someone they have not worked with, regardless of board scores, etc.
Its unfortunate that some people get screwed with rotation assignments in that respect, but that's how the system works currently. Fortunately, he WILL have the ability to do an audition rotation during the month of July (which is an extremely competitive month) rather than boards study, and perhaps take his Step 2 later in the year.
When the lottery happened last year 90-95% of the students received their top five choices when everything was said and done. And according to the list there are more than five desirable rotating hospitals. So, I highly doubt you'd get your last choice.When I interviewed, they explained that the order/priority of the lottery was random...whether you get #1 or #230 was entirely random...which I think does come down to luck. I also heard that after the random lottery drawing one of your classmates may or may not want to trade with you, but that still doesn't make it any less random or based on luck. It just means that after the fact one of your classmates may find it in the kindness of their hearts to switch with you so that your clinical years might not be spent at your last choice.
As far as doing something for years going to the conclusion that it works...if current students are complaining that this year's choice of when to do the rural internship is creating an obstacle for ultimately matching and doing audition rotations for their desired career path, I would think that means it's not working. I understand the need to ignore the complaints and believe that everything will work out just fine for you...and that you won't be the one(s) shafted by the random lottery drawing and forced rural internship, but apparently if you look at doc2b's past posts, he/she did just that, but when it was his/her turn at the lottery, wishful thinking didn't get him/her that far.
When I said that I will probably go to NSU simply for its geographic location, I was just being honest, but that doesn't mean that disturbing facts about the school are null.
If many students are not achieving their desired residency spots due to the scheduling of the rural internships, then perhaps our class should rearrange the schedule. NSU doesn't hide the fact that rural care is a core component of their curriculum.
I'd rather have somewhat of a life outside of studying and not try to undermine my classmates to get ahead during the first two years.
Agreed. I'd rather have a cooperative class than a competitive one. Never knew Hasselhoff was so cut throat!
Yah - he's clearly planning on being up there at the top! You obviously have a gunner amongst you!
Shhh! You'll spoil my plans, lol!
Maybe you could do it like the NBA. The highest rank in the class gets the most lottery ping pong balls...and so on, down the line.
Absolutely, I think it would be great if our class or this year's class could rearrange the schedule so that the rural rotations could be done in the late Spring when it won't affect audition rotations/externships....but I get the distinct impression from current student posting on SDN (not only Doc2B but Pegasus), that we, as NSU students, don't get the luxury of deciding when to schedule our rural internship...the school/admin decides, hence Doc2B's complaint. Doc2B's elusive complaint was that for him/her and the majority of his/her classmates the rural internship was during PRIME audition rotation season...thereby, affecting his ability to match into a desired specialty.
No one ever said the NSU tries to keep their mandatory rural care rotation a secret...it is just disturbing that it can be scheduled at a time when you and your future would be better served by doing an audition rotation.
I think the question is, is it feasible? I believe the vast majority of students would prefer to be on the interview rotations rather than be in a rural rotations, but to fit so many students into rural rotations at the same time, may be pretty tough.Count me in! If it is actually possible to mush them rurals into late Spring, well then that is what shall have to happen! I can see no reason for NSU admin to say nay to this if it is doable. Unless they're simply not cool like that.
There are reasons that all of the rurals are not in the spring...getting all rurals in the spring is NEVER going to happen.Count me in! If it is actually possible to mush them rurals into late Spring, well then that is what shall have to happen! I can see no reason for NSU admin to say nay to this if it is doable. Unless they're simply not cool like that.
There are reasons that all of the rurals are not in the spring...getting all rurals in the spring is NEVER going to happen.
First: There are not enough rurual sites to put everyone in the spring. The school has a limited number of places that we do our rurals with.
Second: These clinics are not just allowing us to work there, but actually COUNT on us being there to handle their pateint load. If all of the rurals were in the spring, then these clinics would be understaffed for six months of the year--there therefore less able to serve their populations (and thus completely defeating the purpose of serving the community).
Third: The school gets grants for having students help staff these clinics. If we aren't there, funding goes away...and tuition rises even more (BAD).
All of that being said, I don't think it is fair for some students to have all of their rurals in the spring and other students having all of their rurals in the fall. Right now, rurals are scheduled in blocks of two months (except June and August are blocked together because we get July off). I think that the best solution would be to split the rurals up. Instead of 1/2 of the class having all of theirs in the spring and 1/2 of them all in the fall, give every student one rotation in the fall and one in the spring.
As I think more about going by class rank, I realize that it could be viewed as a competitive thing, I guess, although I don't view it that way. But I think its a lot more fair if it is based on something tangible that can be influenced by the student,versus just luck-of-the-draw! I don't see why we cannot be cooperative and try to do our best. And be rewarded for it.
I only see the competition within the individual to do their best; there's no reason it needs to become cut throat at all. The only person I am ever in "competition" with is myself. I know that I can be a cooperative fellow student, and offer sincere congratulations to another. And if the other does not have an enlightened view of things, and chooses to torment themselves by getting all bent out of shape...oh, well!
If there is no way on the face of the earth to design it so everyone gets what they want for their high tuition, and considering the importance of timing here, then why shoudn't effort be rewarded? You can decide to make this a focus or not. Would you be content if you happen to get screwed and had worked your arse off, while someone with a more "relaxed" style got the best case scenario? I admit, I would be irked.
kai and mike, do you guys find that you have no free time on weekends due to the Monday exams?
All of that being said, I don't think it is fair for some students to have all of their rurals in the spring and other students having all of their rurals in the fall. Right now, rurals are scheduled in blocks of two months (except June and August are blocked together because we get July off). I think that the best solution would be to split the rurals up. Instead of 1/2 of the class having all of theirs in the spring and 1/2 of them all in the fall, give every student one rotation in the fall and one in the spring.
I've joined the paid pool
I believe that the school is pretty deeply rooted in the way that it assigns clinical rotations. This topic came up with our class as well, but after feeling out administration--we decided it was best to not pursue it. Seriously though, I would have been 100% OKAY with ANY of the rotation sites. Yes, there are some that appealed to me more than others...but I feel as if I would get a good education at ANY of them (and that is the only thing that matters in the end).Well, other options for rotation site assignment could be:
-arm wrestling
-alligator wrestling
-talent show
-eating contest
-dance off!
-shoe cobbling
-timed assembly/disassembly of assault rifles
-your suggestions?
Heck, I would probably be hurting myself if we went by class rank, but at least I would feel that I had some ability to determine this aspect of my medical education.
If it is actually possible for us to have some say in how this is done, why don't we at least put it to our class for a vote?
This would be an improvement. So, as it stands right now, half of the class get it good, and the other half get it not so good? I had thought there was more of a graduated high to low thing.
I thought the Monday exam thing was changing? After the last class on Friday, I am not thinking about med school until Monday. Gotta have fun too!
For those who were accepted earlier, we had the chance to make two deposits, one being $750 in December and the other being $1250 in March. In that case, the financial burden came in spurts. The vast majority of us paid out of pocket for the $2K. You will be getting your financial aid information in the upcoming months. As for disbursement of money, it doesn't come until mid-August, so it is prudent that you save money for the first couple of month's rent and moving/living expenses.I hate to sound pathetic but I am dreading the $2000 I owe soon. I am planning on trying to secure my financial sitch as quickly as possible, but I just found out I got accepted. How long does the financial process take? Did everyone just pay this out of pocket?
As for disbursement of money, it doesn't come until mid-August, so it is prudent that you save money for the first couple of month's rent and moving/living expenses.
I have some catching up to do....17 pages on this thread already!
I am a local very non-trad student who interviewed in late March (anyone else there on the 23rd?) and just found out I am accepted! I can help with any local info anyone needs. As for swimming in the ocean, most people are not afraid of the seawater (gasp!) and the other flora and fauna it contains, but swimming in the ocean is not required to get a driver's license or anything. If you make friends with me, I may let you swim in my clean, jellyfish-less pool.
Welcome to South Florida, folks! I look forward to a very cooperative class. I have been so impressed with the students I have met so far (including kaikai...I owe you cookies!)
Nope, it's more latent than that. It really does depend on your lender too.I thought we got our aid the first week of classes. Does anyone know the exact date of disbursement?
The NSU Authorization Form. Lenders will be chosen at a later date. I believe they plan to change the list for this upcoming year.besides FAFSA, what else do we need to turn in? how are lenders chosen?
How does it feel to be almost done Kuba? Hopefully the game will be good tonight.wow. all these posts in a row. its a party!
The NSU Authorization Form. Lenders will be chosen at a later date. I believe they plan to change the list for this upcoming year.
How does it feel to be almost done Kuba? Hopefully the game will be good tonight.
The NSU Authorization Form. Lenders will be chosen at a later date. I believe they plan to change the list for this upcoming year.
Uh, is there a page telling us what exactly needs to be turned in? (everything on sasevan's link? hi sasevan!)
Uh, do I want to authorize any of those things?
Uh, don't we get to choose our own lenders?
Uh, when can we start applying for private loans?
Uh......sorry for all the questions!
hi tr,
i called 954.262.3380 (or 800.806.3680) Offc of Student Fin Assistance.
they looked up my fin asst status and said i was complete except for the NSU Auth Form; actually they had sent me an e-mail previously to this effect
but i had not checked my NSU e-mail account.
if you've already turned in your FAFSA and Auth Form you should be fine; nothing else needs to be filled out until they e-mail you with the request.
to be sure check out your e-mail account and/or call them.
Do not fill out forms that you don't need yet.nevermind; i found the site for this whole process.
http://www.nova.edu/cwis/finaid/forms/download_forms.html
Check out your webstar account. Your financial aid information is located there. You don't choose lenders until you get your fin aid package. At that point, you can go for private loans. You don't want to take out too much or too little until you know what the government is going to give you.Thanks, sasevan!
Check out your webstar account. Your financial aid information is located there. You don't choose lenders until you get your fin aid package. At that point, you can go for private loans. You don't want to take out too much or too little until you know what the government is going to give you.
Well, other options for rotation site assignment could be:
-arm wrestling
-alligator wrestling
-talent show
-eating contest
-dance off!
-shoe cobbling
-timed assembly/disassembly of assault rifles
-your suggestions?
Heck, I would probably be hurting myself if we went by class rank, but at least I would feel that I had some ability to determine this aspect of my medical education.
If it is actually possible for us to have some say in how this is done, why don't we at least put it to our class for a vote?
This would be an improvement. So, as it stands right now, half of the class get it good, and the other half get it not so good? I had thought there was more of a graduated high to low thing.
I thought the Monday exam thing was changing? After the last class on Friday, I am not thinking about med school until Monday. Gotta have fun too!