I appreciate the time you took to write out a well thought response of how you feel the situation is so I'll respond. I respect your viewpoint and feel that it is a good mindset to go into the graduate program with, but I do feel that you are somewhat misinformed. I just ask that you read the entire response before commenting because I'll try to answer potential questions about certain statements I make throughout the post.
Osteopathic "SMPs" or certificate programs can't be compared to allopathic equivalent programs because osteopathic schools have no formal ranking nor do their programs have a great reputation (possible because of the former) outside of their own school. Everyone recognizes Georgetown SMP and programs such as Tufts MBS or BU MAMS as top tier SMP programs for the reason that they are widely recognized by Adcoms and school officials across the nation. Unfortunately for osteopathic programs, this is not the case because most osteopathic schools, if their name is not KCOM/PCOM/CCOM or DMU-COM, are mainly recognized/reputable within their own region. Just the same, students who are aiming for allopathic schools generally stay away from osteopathic SMPs and choose to attend allopathic SMPs for the general reasoning that Adcoms will not place as high of an emphasis on their graduate grades/coursework since osteopathic schools are generally not as well known.
Thus the question is raised why would someone choose to attend an osteopathic SMP? Osteopathic SMPs
in general have traditionally been regarded as offering a strong linkage into their medical school off of their Masters/certificate programs by using it as a screening/stepping stone program.
Examples below:
Excerpts from ATSU KCOM Handbook
http://www.atsu.edu/kcom/admissions...on/pdfs/BMS Admissions Process_1, 11.7.08.pdf
"In addition, the prescreening process will attempt to ascertain your suitability for the program. Since the majority of applicants aspire to move from the Masters program to the Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine program (or another professional program, such as dental), it is important to discern your potential to move into such programs at the conclusion of the Masters program."
"Graduate students who are interested in applying for admission to either the DO program or another post-graduate program, are encouraged to submit their application at the conclusion of the spring quarter. At this time, the students DO courses and most of the Graduate Program courses have been completed, which helps ensure that the Admissions Committee will have a good sense of the students academic ability, as well as their personal and professional characteristics." (
During interviews, this was translated into "we treat the program as a year long interview")
Touro NV
E-mail correspondence with the Director of Admissions
4. Q: Is the program relatively new because I would like to learn about
Touro-NV MHS' acceptance rate into medical school if such a thing were
available.
A:
Out of the last class, five out of the seven were admitted into our DO class of 2014.
"We like to keep our students" ~ Oscar Parra
Nova Southeastern University MBS
Not faculty or handbook but from "credible sources" who are all MBS students or D1-D3s at Nova
http://forums.studentdoctor.net/showpost.php?p=8127304&postcount=124
http://forums.studentdoctor.net/showpost.php?p=8342475&postcount=139
http://forums.studentdoctor.net/showpost.php?p=8523600&postcount=142
http://forums.studentdoctor.net/showpost.php?p=8352289&postcount=140
**************************************************
I cited those messages/excerpts/quotes above to show a very common trend that osteopathic SMPs are catered and predisposed to accept back their own students. I don't see why this is so hard of a concept to grasp. They take the same classes/courses as the medical/dental students, the same exams, and the same instructors and are required to score an 80% or better. This translates into they have to score
just as well if not better than the current medical school class that was accepted. The whole purpose of the application process and having a complete application is to allow Adcoms to predict/gauge as accurately as possible whether an applicant is capable of successfully making their way through medical school. I can understand that there may be some questions raised about that if you apply to other institutions but
not the same medical school where you took the equivalent coursework as their accepted medical students and scored just as well as their current average if not better. You just proved you can be successful and excel and have solid evidence of a year's worth of grades.
You made a point of asking "when is it AZCOM's responsibility to accept students from their master's program." AZCOM's MA program tuition is:
Biomedical Science M.A. $31,421
I don't know about you, but that's a hell of a lot of money in my opinion for a "formality interview" and a 20% acceptance rate (read on to find out where the 20% came from and yes I know this is only at the minute and there may/probably will be mobility on the list in the future). I know of many schools who have an equivalent tuition cost if not cheaper for their medical students. The class size of the MBS program is said to be 17 on their website for Glendale and TheCloser just commented that about 20 people in his class applied. I'll estimate that to be roughly 1/2 of the students in the MA program (forgive me if I'm wrong in this assumption). Of those 20 students, 4 were accepted and 16 waitlisted. Out of 20 who applied (i'm assuming they qualified for the "formality" interview), 20% were accepted. That's saying you at the
very least met the medical school average (80%) if not exceeded and
had 1 full standard deviation on the MCAT above that of the accepted students. Really? Only 20% for doing that well in an intensive program that costs about 31,000 in tuition? I really do hope that everyone that does qualify ends up getting accepted (even if they got in elsewhere and would rather go elsewhere).
The whole point of my complaint about AZCOM waitlisting students that got into other schools (NSU/CCOM being better schools and yes I do stand by this statement) is very wrong
in my opinion. If the students did just as well if not better for a year's worth of medical school classes from AZCOM, possesses as a full standard deviation higher on the MCAT than the accepted students,
and takes into consideration that the class size has increased from
150 -> 250 medical students, (breathe for air, long sentence I know), why are
proven students being waitlisted yet attending equivalent if not better schools? They paid 31,000 dollars on top of having very valid credentials, this just is hard for me to comprehend the logic behind this.
I am not going to go into detail why these schools are better. If you want to read some "interesting things", here is a link. (again, my point is not to stir up controversy, I just don't want to outline all of CCOM and NSU's board scores, 3rd/4th year rotations, etc):
http://forums.studentdoctor.net/showthread.php?t=403336
The last point I'm going to address is the one about "schools not having SMPs or people not getting into them." Yes you are absolutely right, not all osteopathic schools have SMPs. The thing is the a large portion of them do.
LECOM-> Biomedical Certificate/ M.S
PCOM -> MBS (GA) MBS (PA) Certificate (PA)
NSU -> MBS
TCOM - GSBS
UMDNJ -> MBS
VCOM -> Biomedical Certificate
Touro NY -> M.S.
Touro NV -> M.H.S
KCUMB -> MBS
WCOMP -> M.H.S
ATSU-KCOM-> MBS
LMU-DCOM -> Medical Sci. post bacc
There's probably more but that's all I could come up off the top of my head for osteopathic SMPs and not osteopathic pre-req post-bacc programs (NYCOM/UNECOM/etc).
In response to your other point of "maybe they didn't get into another SMP." I kind of question how they would get into a program (AZCOM) that has a larger acceptance class and a required phone interview and not any others. It's definitely possible but just perusing through the PCOM thread and of those that posted their stats, I'm seeing people with a 2.8 getting in and on PCOM's website, they state their average for those admitted in 2008-2009 as being:
MCAT: Physical = 6.88 Verbal = 7.01 Biological = 7.48
I would like to think that the AZCOM MA students who passed the "formality interview" requirements having a full standard deviation above the accepted medical school average MCAT as being higher than a 20-21 that PCOM has stated here. Then there's LECOM's 1 year program, KCUMB's program etc. who all have roughly equivalent applicant stats. Oh yes, PCOM only accepts 17 in their MBS class as well according to their website. That's already less than the 50% of the MA class that TheCloser estimates applied to AZCOM. None of the other 1 year programs require a phone interview either
They're all substantially cheaper than 31,000 as well.
What's the point I'm trying to get across over this all? It really doesn't seem like AZCOM's MA/MBS program is any easier to get into than its osteopathic counterparts. It's substantially more expensive as well. So it brings me to wonder why would people want to attend AZCOM's MA program
if not for the reason that they like the school and want to go there? There may be those who live in the area and wish to stay close to home but I can't seem to imagine there being a majority of these people. TheCloser already stated that many of his fellow students are angry because they thought that their performance on the program would at the very least carry some weight into the admissions process. I think from the very beginning of this incredibly long post, that these programs are regarded very highly by the same school and apparently this is echoed in the sentiments of TheCloser's classmates.
I apologize again for the long post. These are my own viewpoints/opinions that I have gained from spending way too much time on these boards and researching other programs and if you wish to respond, I would very much like to hear your input, but please at least read through my post and provide some concrete/credible evidence if you wish to respond against it.