- Joined
- Apr 29, 2013
- Messages
- 486
- Reaction score
- 693
Currently there are 58 COMs
Last edited:
Especially no STEP 1 scored, matching as DO will be exponentially tougher now, and most people if not all, will be relegated to the areas with 40k population that just happens to have a FM residency near by. STEP 1 turning into P/F was a response by the MD physicians to the growing number of DO schools. You're going to grow the number of DO schools to overwhelm our residency applications? we gonna turn step 1 P/F and we can't bother considering your 240 as a DO vs our 220 MD because it's P/F now, so sucks for you.DOs will just replace the carrib grads mainly. However the matching will also get much harder for those in schools not highly ranked
No, it was a response to the fact that Step I mania was making all med student literally sick.Especially no STEP 1 scored, matching as DO will be exponentially tougher now, and most people if not all, will be relegated to the areas with 40k population that just happens to have a FM residency near by. STEP 1 turning into P/F was a response by the MD physicians to the growing number of DO schools. You're going to grow the number of DO schools to overwhelm our residency applications? we gonna turn step 1 P/F and we can't bother considering your 240 as a DO vs our 220 MD because it's P/F now, so sucks for you.
"most"I wish that were the case but sadly most DOs are ashamed of their initials and try to hide it anyway they can.
Just on social media alone I’ve I’d say 4/5 DOs in competitive specialties just write “Dr. John Doe” whereas nearly every MD is John Doe, MD
There was one who started neurosurg residency at 24 (skipped a grade and did a 7 year BS/DO. Imagine how much someone like that could do advocating for the field
Just ignore @dartaniandoc , he just comes on these boards to talk down about DO’s since he goes to a low tier MD.. N=1, but I know many more DO’s that advertise that they are DO’s and patients actually seek them out because of it……"most"
Come on, let's not generalize tens of thousands of people based on some instagram bios.
Lmao what? I've seen many, many DOs list themselves as John/Jane Doe, DO on social media, and these are some very established leaders at top placesI wish that were the case but sadly most DOs are ashamed of their initials and try to hide it anyway they can.
Just on social media alone I’ve I’d say 4/5 DOs in competitive specialties just write “Dr. John Doe” whereas nearly every MD is John Doe, MD
There was one who started neurosurg residency at 24 (skipped a grade and did a 7 year BS/DO. Imagine how much someone like that could do advocating for the field
I should ignore but to address your stupidity using 2020 charting outcomesP/F step was mostly pushed by top tier MD schools and hurts mid and low-tier (me) MD as much as it hurts DOs. At the same time, very few DOs were scoring high on step to begin with. I’d have to look at the data but I recall like fewer than 10 DOs score >260 in any given year and maybe ~100 score in the 240s. These students will probably still rock step 2 and shine in other areas like research
Some of the MD’s who come on these boards to talk down about DO’s have some serious issues, like wth cares… I haven’t met an actual person on my rotations that cares about the MD/DO thingCant wait for the number of DOs to outgrow MDs. Our kids will be asking “what’s a MD? Are they real doctors?”
Dude that’s like 4-5 ppl out of thousands hahahaah way to self select… I am sure there are 4-5 MD’s I can find right now that only go by Dr so and so on social media, doesn’t mean jack or that they don’t like the letters behind thier name.Lol okay…. I see tons of sponsored IG posts especially from DO derms, ENTs and whatnot all hiding their credentials
Doctorjesss (peds)
Drbrianfiani (neurosurg)
Doctor.sina_ (ENT)
Drrickysayal (ENT)
harmanbh_ (from medbros YT channel, his brother goes to yale and sister goes to mayo) he deletes people's comments when they ask him about anything DO related. He even got Medschoolinsiders (the huge YT channel) to disable comments on the video they collabbed on
I can add more as I come across them.
Lol he said only like ten people scored >250 out of DO schools hahahahI should ignore but to address your stupidity using 2020 charting outcomes
Matched DO step 1 average 227.7 (s.d. = 15.4)
Matched MD step 1 234.0 (s.d. = 17.0)
Matched DO step 2 average 240.5 (s.d. = 13.4)
Matched MD step 2 average 246.9 (s.d. = 14.2)
Of course there's a difference (and I know the DO population is self selected) but do you see how those datasets overlap way more than you indicate?
If step 1 scores were a normal distribution you'd have at least 15-20% scoring 240 or above. 5,243 DOs took step 1 in the data set. 15% would be 786 students. I'm sure it's not a perfectly normal distribution but I am sure you are completely wrong. Do you just make stuff up?
Let's add up all the DOs in each specialty in the NRMP match (no ophtho or uro!) that scored from 251-260 and >260! Spoiler: you're provably wrong.
251-260:
Gas: 19
Child neuro: 0
Derm: 10
Radiology: 23
EM: 23
FM: 11
GS: 11
IM: 40
Med/peds: 0
Interv. Rads: 8
Nsg: 1
Neuro: 5
Obgyn: 7
Ortho: 31
ENT: 6
Path: 2
Peds: 4
PMR: 3
Plastics: 0
Psych: 3
Vascular surgery: 0
---------
Total 251-260: 207
260+:
Gas: 1
Child neuro: 0
Derm: 3
Radiology: 2
EM: 5
FM: 0
GS: 4
IM: 5
Med/peds: 0
Interv. Rads: 4
Nsg: 1
Neuro: 5
Obgyn: 1
Ortho: 4
ENT: 1
Path: 1
Peds: 1
PMR: 0
Plastics: 0
Psych: 0
Vascular surgery: 1
------
Total 260+: 39
Actually the step 1 average for USMD for all applicants not just matched is 231..Lol he said only like ten people scored >250 out of DO schools hahahah
Yes I opted to look at matched applicants for that, arbitrarily.Actually the step 1 average for USMD for all applicants not just matched is 231..
Gently stroking one's ego due to their cohort having slightly higher numbers than another cohort (all well above what either cohort was scoring 15 years ago with no discernible impact on anything other than the construct that is The Match) is one thing, but doing so with pretend data is even more pathetic.
Whatever man just let people be, the real hard world will teach them eventually….Gently stroking one's ego due to their cohort having slightly higher numbers than another cohort (all well above what either cohort was scoring 15 years ago with no discernible impact on anything other than the construct that is The Match) is one thing, but doing so with pretend data is even more pathetic.
I should ignore but to address your stupidity using 2020 charting outcomes
Matched DO step 1 average 227.7 (s.d. = 15.4)
Matched MD step 1 234.0 (s.d. = 17.0)
Matched DO step 2 average 240.5 (s.d. = 13.4)
Matched MD step 2 average 246.9 (s.d. = 14.2)
Of course there's a difference (and I know the DO population is self selected) but do you see how those datasets overlap way more than you indicate?
I agree that the DO step 1 average would be lower if all DOs took it, but I think it‘s all due to self-selection. At my school, all that you had to do to qualify to sit for boards was pass a crappy comsae with a 450 or above, and have completed all classes and stayed in good standing, and then you were qualified to register for both step and comlex. So anyone who qualified for one, qualified for both, and I’ve never heard of anyone being advised not to take the step exams.I agree with the overarching point but the % of MD students that take the Steps is essentially 100%, whereas the % of DO students that take the Steps I'd significantly lower. I would wager that the actual Step scores for DO students would be significantly lower if they were all required to take it. Im open to seeing data on this, but I imagine DO schools only allow/encourage their top students to take Step
Works the same way at my school. Sure there is self selection on who takes it but I know of people who could do well on step or atleast close to average but only take comlex because they want to do family Med or peds. So it can go both ways…I agree that the DO step 1 average would be lower if all DOs took it, but I think it‘s all due to self-selection. At my school, all that you had to do to qualify to sit for boards was pass a crappy comsae with a 450 or above, and have completed all classes and stayed in good standing, and then you were qualified to register for both step and comlex. So anyone who qualified for one, qualified for both, and I’ve never heard of anyone being advised not to take the step exams.
I’d actually be interested to see if there are any DO schools that restrict any students’ ability to take step 1 while allowing them to take level 1. You would think that wouldn’t be a thing at all since no DO is required to take any of the step exams for licensure.
Yep! Some really smart people in my class wanting to do basic things don’t take step - and also the military people, since they’re guaranteed a residency somewhere. I don’t know a single military person who’s taking any of the step exams.Works the same way at my school. Sure there is self selection on who takes it but I know of people who could do well on step or atleast close to average but only take comlex because they want to do family Med or peds. So it can go both ways…
That's why I said they're self selected.I agree with the overarching point but the % of MD students that take the Steps is essentially 100%, whereas the % of DO students that take the Steps I'd significantly lower. I would wager that the actual Step scores for DO students would be significantly lower if they were all required to take it. Im open to seeing data on this, but I imagine DO schools only allow/encourage their top students to take Step
He's the guy that made the thread.Where is jkdoctor when you need him to say “Whoot whoot!!”
Totally missed that, my badThat's why I said they're self selected.
My reasoning behind believing the average would not drop off a cliff if all DO students had to take it is this: They would know day 1 it's coming and can't back out. Everyone performs far better in that scenario. If you can be chicken **** and waffle on taking it of course you would do worse (or not take at all). The whole career path is based on rising to the occasion and people think they couldn't do that to score average on a multiple choice exam you study for for 2 years? No way...
Sure. I'm referring to the average score as a cohort. Of course, not everyone can be average individually.In the same breath though, all MD studentd historically knew that it was coming too and there are still half of them that score below the average.
My school had a very bad step 1 pass rate last year, but comlex was fine. Not sure if it was bad advising or a weak cohort. This year they will make us take an NBME exam and "comfortably pass" before they allow us to sit for step 1. Yet to learn what score will be required or which NBME exam. Shows you that the two exams are completely different and people can very well be caught off-guard if they don't prepare hard. I think it will get worse with the P/F change because students will get complacent. Failure is a very real possibility.
Uh… Uro and ophtho are their own match… I personally know a 250+ DO that matched MD Optho this cycle.Let's add up all the DOs in each specialty in the NRMP match (no ophtho or uro!)
Uh… Uro and ophtho are their own match… I personally know a 250+ DO that matched MD Optho this cycle.
2/3rds of my kids take Step I.I agree with the overarching point but the % of MD students that take the Steps is essentially 100%, whereas the % of DO students that take the Steps I'd significantly lower. I would wager that the actual Step scores for DO students would be significantly lower if they were all required to take it. Im open to seeing data on this, but I imagine DO schools only allow/encourage their top students to take Step
I agree with the overarching point but the % of MD students that take the Steps is essentially 100%, whereas the % of DO students that take the Steps I'd significantly lower. I would wager that the actual Step scores for DO students would be significantly lower if they were all required to take it. Im open to seeing data on this, but I imagine DO schools only allow/encourage their top students to take Step
And for those that take it, are they generally the top 2/3 of the class?2/3rds of my kids take Step I.
I have no idea why they push conquest so hard. My class tried so hard to get our school to buy us uworld but they just wouldn’t budge and I have no idea why.Part of the problem is that students don’t actively seek out how to prep. We have schools that keep trying to push combank and comquest down our throats that it’s no wonder DO students don’t do well on step1. Even the students on reddit mostly use garbage comlex resources for step1 and they’re probably more informed than your average DO student.
Most likely yes. Most top students take step and bottom dont. But I haven’t ever heard of my school advising a student of not taking stepAnd for those that take it, are they generally the top 2/3 of the class?
I have no idea why they push conquest so hard. My class tried so hard to get our school to buy us uworld but they just wouldn’t budge and I have no idea why.
Pretty sure it was top MD programs being upset that they were losing out to low or mid tier MDs who hustled more than them. Sincerely doubt that the existence of DOs even crossed their minds.Especially no STEP 1 scored, matching as DO will be exponentially tougher now, and most people if not all, will be relegated to the areas with 40k population that just happens to have a FM residency near by. STEP 1 turning into P/F was a response by the MD physicians to the growing number of DO schools. You're going to grow the number of DO schools to overwhelm our residency applications? we gonna turn step 1 P/F and we can't bother considering your 240 as a DO vs our 220 MD because it's P/F now, so sucks for you.
Pretty much.And for those that take it, are they generally the top 2/3 of the class?
Yeah but you need to match before you can practiceIt's cute when neckbeards come along, regardless if they are either MD or DO, and try to start a pissing match about who's degree does what.
In practice NO ONE cares.
Were they losing out?Pretty sure it was top MD programs being upset that they were losing out to low or mid tier MDs who hustled more than them. Sincerely doubt that the existence of DOs even crossed their minds.
No matter the tier, a 225 step 1 wasn’t going to beat a low tier USMD with a 250+ with an otherwise equivalent app at the same program.Were they losing out?
Really? What program are we talking?No matter the tier, a 225 step 1 wasn’t going to beat a low tier USMD with a 250+ with an otherwise equivalent app at the same program.
Whatever program. Whatever specialty.Really? What program are we talking?
Also otherwise equivalent app is next to impossible