Whether it’s in the middle of wasteland nowhere or murdertown USA, which med schools do you all think have the worst locations?
New haven is dangerous? Didn’t realize it was that bad in CT.When I visited Yale for a post-doc position interview, it was an armed camp Every security guard was packing iron.
When I visited U Chicago many years ago to visit a friend on the faculty, I was shocked to see that it was an island in the middle of the worst slums in the US.
This is definitely true, to an extent, but you get a lot of hyperbole from medical students about how bad a neighborhood is when really it's just black people living (heard lots of 'bad things' about the area near the school I lived, turns out violent crime rates were actually lower than where most of the students lived it was just this area was predominantly non-white)Many urban hospitals in major cities (NY, Philly, DC) are located in not the best neighborhoods because they're meant to serve these communities that have more violence/issues. I've heard that Temple is not located in the best neighborhood.
New haven is dangerous? Didn’t realize it was that bad in CT.
I agree with UChicago. Had an aunt who lived near Hyde park and had her car broken into multiple times and her townhouse was burglarized. The campus looks really nice, though.
I wholeheartedly agree.This is definitely true, to an extent, but you get a lot of hyperbole from medical students about how bad a neighborhood is when really it's just black people living (heard lots of 'bad things' about the area near the school I lived, turns out violent crime rates were actually lower than where most of the students lived it was just this area was predominantly non-white)
Camden NJ and Youngstown OH would probably qualify on a murder per capita rate. JHU would be one, as Baltimore is # 2 murder rate per capita behind St Louis who is #1.New Haven, CT Crime Rates and Statistics - NeighborhoodScout
Most accurate 2021 crime rates for New Haven, CT. Your chance of being a victim of violent crime in New Haven is 1 in 183 and property crime is 1 in 32. Compare New Haven crime data to other cities, states, and neighborhoods in the U.S. on NeighborhoodScout.www.neighborhoodscout.com
It's hard to find a city more dangerous than New Haven. I love the place, but be on your guard at night
I phrased that incorrectly- it was meant to say it is hard to find many cities more dangerous than New Haven. It certainly isn't the most dangerous city, but it's in the top 50 and was number 4 when I used to work there in the early 2010s. Detroit, Oakland, Baltimore, St. Louis, and several other cities have gotten worse while New Haven has made some improvements over the years. It's still got a homicide rate of 17 per 100,000 so far this year, but will probably end up somewhere near 24 per 100,000 by the end of the year, which is quite concerning but not Detroit.Camden NJ and Youngstown OH would probably qualify on a murder per capita rate. JHU would be one, as Baltimore is # 2 murder rate per capita behind St Louis who is #1.
I looked up the cities with highest murder per capita. I figured Miami would be one, but wasn't in the top 25. Jackson Memorial in Miami used to be a real knife and gun club.I phrased that incorrectly- it was meant to say it is hard to find many cities more dangerous than New Haven. It certainly isn't the most dangerous city, but it's in the top 50 and was number 4 when I used to work there in the early 2010s. Detroit, Oakland, Baltimore, St. Louis, and several other cities have gotten worse while New Haven has made some improvements over the years. It's still got a homicide rate of 17 per 100,000 so far this year, but will probably end up somewhere near 24 per 100,000 by the end of the year, which is quite concerning but not Detroit.
Man, 27, Shot Dead; 3rd Homicide In 4 Days
Someone shot 27-year-old Trequon Lawrence to death Wednesday night, New Haven’s third homicide in four days.The renewed spate of shootings around town led one legislator to call for police and city leaders to offer…www.newhavenindependent.org
YNHH recently lost someone to the escalating violence in the city, things have really started to get bad again recently
Back when it was still the UI looked up the cities with highest murder per capita. I figured Miami would be one, but wasn't in the top 25. Jackson Memorial in Miami used to be a real knife and gun club.
The best training is where we can learn to practice on patients who are vulnerable and have no other choice: " medical training relies disproportionately on the use of poor communities and communities of color." and "Trainees also benefit directly from the denial of comprehensive care to large swaths of American society,"You can get quite good training in hospitals operating in Murdertown, USA.
Idk how true this is but: "In his book, The Social Transformation of American Medicine, the historian Paul Starr describes how American teaching hospitals were deliberately built in centers of urban poverty so that students would have access to poor patients."Many urban hospitals in major cities (NY, Philly, DC) are located in not the best neighborhoods because they're meant to serve these communities that have more violence/issues. I've heard that Temple is not located in the best neighborhood.
I don't think the fact that some people live there their whole lives without incident, provides comforts to anyone. I think the fact that some cities have elevated crime statistics and that the student/ trainee is uncomfortable accepting the possibility of becoming one of those statistics, is why some are hesitant to attend certain schools. I consider this a logical consideration.^^
Tbh I’ve noticed a lot of these threads tend to descend into racist/classist stereotypes of certain cities that face the same problems any urban area would face in terms of crime rates. People will disparage cities like New Haven after a brief visit there, not realizing that people live whole lives there with no issue.
Maybe don’t go into medicine if you’re so afraid of working with lower income communities of color?
Hopkins is by far in a worse area than Yale and WashU.JH worse than WashU imo, WashU is at least flanked by some nicer areas to live (central west end especially). JH is smack in the middle of east baltimore with nothing but housing projects or low income and largely abandoned rowhome blocks all around. They had to pass legislation to allow creating a university police department right now because of how out of control crime has been getting in the hospital campus area
It's all relative I promise the projects and abandoned rowhomes around JHH are a lot worse than CWE. Seen both up close.CWE isn't that nice. Sure apartments are expensive and it's mostly occupied by med students/professional students and residents, but the crime is high. Here is the reported crime for the Central West end from last week alone (as reported by WashU security).
Rochester MN probably up there on most isolated frigid wastelands too if we look at more factors than safety and expenseEasily Geisinger.
They better be careful yelling at strangers like that. Someone might be having a bad day or be a little unhinged thereself and go after them. Ohio State had a few people like that outside of campus.Cities in the Northwest are notorious for tolerating extremely aggressive panhandling. While other cities at least attempt to crack down on this behavior, it's apparently anything goes in Portland and Seattle. This isn't so much a true safety issue as it is a major nuisance, but it can be very intimidating especially if you're a woman and/or by yourself at night.
Aggressive panhandling happens constantly in these cities, including the neighborhoods surrounding UW and OHSU. If you do any kind of walking around, you can expect to be hounded for cigarettes, weed, food, or cash on a regular basis. Most of the time the panhandler will just walk away if you ignore them, but 1 out of every 5 will start screaming unhinged profane nonsense at you. You're very unlikely to be hurt or robbed by a panhandler, but it's hard to feel safe when someone in the throes of an active mental health crisis is shouting that they'll send the devil to kill you because you didn't have a cigarette for them.
Scranton weather isn’t bad it’s just that Scranton is straight out of a Fallout game level of urban decay.Rochester MN probably up there on most isolated frigid wastelands too if we look at more factors than safety and expense
I mixed it up with geiselScranton weather isn’t bad it’s just that Scranton is straight out of a Fallout game level of urban decay.
Y'all just need to learn how to dress for the weather. Winter is the best season up here!Rochester MN probably up there on most isolated frigid wastelands too if we look at more factors than safety and expense
onlyonly 1.5 hours
In perfect road conditiononly
In wintertime in Minnesota, Nature makes a very serious attempt to kill you.Rochester MN probably up there on most isolated frigid wastelands too if we look at more factors than safety and expense
Pssh.In wintertime in Minnesota, Nature makes a very serious attempt to kill you.
It varies, but "very dangerous" is somewhat subjective. Every school publishes COA numbers that include a reasonable allowance for reasonable housing, with or without roommates. You can always borrow up to the COA, everywhere, so "budget conscious" is also variable depending on your resources and willingness to take on debt. If you need the least expensive housing in an expensive urban area, you're going to get what you are willing to pay for.How do budget conscious med students find a place to live for schools like U Chicago, Hopkins and Geisinger that are located in very dangerous neighborhoods? Do these schools have a lot of dorm rooms set aside for medical students?
How do budget conscious med students find a place to live for schools like U Chicago, Hopkins and Geisinger that are located in very dangerous neighborhoods? Do these schools have a lot of dorm rooms set aside for medical students?
Inflationary environment great for borrowers, bad for lenders. Lever upIt varies, but "very dangerous" is somewhat subjective. Every school publishes COA numbers that include a reasonable allowance for reasonable housing, with or without roommates. You can always borrow up to the COA, everywhere, so "budget conscious" is also variable depending on your resources and willingness to take on debt. If you need the least expensive housing in an expensive urban area, you're going to get what you are willing to pay for.
That said, no one guarantees anyone a beautiful living arrangement 5 minutes from the school. Some schools have that, others don't. Some have subsidized dorms or apartments, others don't. Bottom line, everyone seems to manage, and JHU and Pritzker don't seem to have too much difficulty attracting the top students in the country, notwithstanding the fact that they are located in "very dangerous neighborhoods."
It's a fact of life that some of the best schools are located in some of the worst areas. If it's that worrisome, there are around 150 MD programs in the country, and many of them are located in very lovely areas. As always, MSAR is a great place to begin a search.
Scranton isn't that bad, honestly. It just isn't that good either.Easily Geisinger.
Essentially people group up in the less dangerous areas a little ways away from campus. Using Hopkins as an example many people rent rowhomes together in the Fells neighborhoods instead of near campus, or if they do want to live near campus, they live in the very secure apartment complexes (Jefferson Square, or the hopkins owned "929" dorms). Current students will be able to advise about this at interviews/second looks/start of M1.How do budget conscious med students find a place to live for schools like U Chicago, Hopkins and Geisinger that are located in very dangerous neighborhoods? Do these schools have a lot of dorm rooms set aside for medical students?
For investing, maybe. For consumption, never!Inflationary environment great for borrowers, bad for lenders. Lever up
*not financial advice*
The point I was trying to emphasize to the poster was that they should not expect to be safe in the Central West End just because it looks nice.
unless your interest rates are floating...Inflationary environment great for borrowers, bad for lenders. Lever up
*not financial advice*
A lot of medical students at Pritzker get shell-shocked from what I've seen. I definitely was as a college student.Some have subsidized dorms or apartments, others don't. Bottom line, everyone seems to manage, and JHU and Pritzker don't seem to have too much difficulty attracting the top students in the country, notwithstanding the fact that they are located in "very dangerous neighborhoods."
It's a fact of life that some of the best schools are located in some of the worst areas. If it's that worrisome, there are around 150 MD programs in the country, and many of them are located in very lovely areas. As always, MSAR is a great place to begin a search.
Chiraq is on another level.A lot of medical students at Pritzker get shell-shocked from what I've seen. I definitely was as a college student.
No one tells you about the crime (which has literally exponentially increased in the past 5 years) and UChicago will not report anything unless it's literally on campus which excludes literally every living area except college dorms. Even then you still get a lot of emails about gunpoint muggings and people getting hit in the back of the head and robbed in the middle of campus at 9pm walking home. Like, there was an actual homicide probably 2 minutes away from the medical school in the backyard/parking area of a mostly student-occupied apartment complex. Despite being on everyone's social media, and people asking the school wtf happened, no one ever commented and since it's just another murder on top of the dozens that happen every weekend, not even the news covered it.
Also don't even get me started on security on campus and in the hospital area. You can practically walk into the ED armed and no one will know unless you are brandishing your gun as you walk in. Attendings/administration push for more security yet nothing budges, bullet-proof outside windows were just allowed to start processing after what seemed like an eternity (and i'm pretty sure the only thing that made this happen was because some other Chicago hospitals, Sinai and Cook, were actually shot at/up). CPD and chicago as a whole also has its host of issues, most of which are just getting worse, but that's for another time.
Ultimately, are you going to get shot/hurt by attending Pritzker? Probably not, assuming things get better. But will you have fun? Nope. You'll probably be in a constant state of anxiety and fear. You think I'm joking and that it ain't much but that all changes when you hear 20 shots a few blocks down when you're walking home, or you see 15 cop cars racing 90 mph towards the ED because two cops were fatally shot after dealing with a minor parking incident a few minutes away from the ED. I didn't even apply to this school and I go here; ain't good enough to justify this garbage.
Also I live in NYC and not a rich area, definitely still a 'city,' but it is no where near what I have experienced and the amount of fear I feel just walking home at Chicago (sans gunshots). If anyone's planning on going to a place like Hyde Park, do yourself a favor and get the Citizen app...definitely worth it.
How does U Chicago manage its campus tours/overnight stays in such a way as to mask the crime problem on/near campus that you've described?A lot of medical students at Pritzker get shell-shocked from what I've seen. I definitely was as a college student.
No one tells you about the crime (which has literally exponentially increased in the past 5 years) and UChicago will not report anything unless it's literally on campus which excludes literally every living area except college dorms. Even then you still get a lot of emails about gunpoint muggings and people getting hit in the back of the head and robbed in the middle of campus at 9pm walking home. Like, there was an actual homicide probably 2 minutes away from the medical school in the backyard/parking area of a mostly student-occupied apartment complex. Despite being on everyone's social media, and people asking the school wtf happened, no one ever commented and since it's just another murder on top of the dozens that happen every weekend, not even the news covered it.
Also don't even get me started on security on campus and in the hospital area. You can practically walk into the ED armed and no one will know unless you are brandishing your gun as you walk in. Attendings/administration push for more security yet nothing budges, bullet-proof outside windows were just allowed to start processing after what seemed like an eternity (and i'm pretty sure the only thing that made this happen was because some other Chicago hospitals, Sinai and Cook, were actually shot at/up). CPD and chicago as a whole also has its host of issues, most of which are just getting worse, but that's for another time.
Ultimately, are you going to get shot/hurt by attending Pritzker? Probably not, assuming things get better. But will you have fun? Nope. You'll probably be in a constant state of anxiety and fear. You think I'm joking and that it ain't much but that all changes when you hear 20 shots a few blocks down when you're walking home, or you see 15 cop cars racing 90 mph towards the ED because two cops were fatally shot after dealing with a minor parking incident a few minutes away from the ED. I didn't even apply to this school and I go here; ain't good enough to justify this garbage.
Also I live in NYC and not a rich area, definitely still a 'city,' but it is no where near what I have experienced and the amount of fear I feel just walking home at Chicago (sans gunshots). If anyone's planning on going to a place like Hyde Park, do yourself a favor and get the Citizen app...definitely worth it.
Med schools and to a lesser extent elite undergrads have an extreme supply demand balance. So I don’t really think they have to do anything because regardless of how bad it is, they can fill their class 5 times over with elite candidates. Therefore there really is no need to mask thingsHow does U Chicago manage its campus tours/overnight stays in such a way as to mask the crime problem on/near campus that you've described?
Med schools and to a lesser extent elite undergrads have an extreme supply demand balance. So I don’t really think they have to do anything because regardless of how bad it is, they can fill their class 5 times over with elite candidates. Therefore there really is no need to mask things
One of my friends from undergrad is at Prtizker rn and she was summa cum laude at HYPSM, good leadership, high MCAT and Pritzker and her home state school was the only As that she received. Obviously it’s still a very successful cycle, but it’s not like she had a ton of options/leverage to complain about location