- Joined
- Dec 5, 2015
- Messages
- 13,405
- Reaction score
- 39,146
Yes, but I think it's equally harmful to applicants who are looking for similar inspiration on these types of threads, only to find multiple people coming on to immediately tell them how wrong they are for interpreting their pre-veterinary experience as being outside of the standard. It's not a term that's readily well defined unless you're looking into it (the National Center for Education Statistics even says definitions vary), and while it's certainly most common for it to refer to older students I have seen other criteria used before that aren't necessarily wrong either.I don't really think anyone is trying to gate keep here. But people point out when words are misused, and I see this as no exception.
I think using the word incorrectly does a disservice to applicants who are actually nontraditional and may be looking at these posts for other people's life experiences who they may be able to connect with and find inspiration through. That is merely my opinion and you may feel differently of course.
Again, I don't see how it's productive to get into a semantics argument about it with people who are simply looking to share their story of success with others who can hopefully see something of themselves in these posts as well. Coming on specifically to quote them and jokingly needle about them not being non-trads just feels mean-spirited in a thread that is meant to be a celebration of an accomplishment for the people who post here. I think of the Successful Applicants Thread as a place for support, celebration, and inspiration every year and this feels - tonally - like an out of place conversation to have on it.
The point of identifying as non-traditional is to point out that maybe that student experienced different sorts of barriers in their process of approaching this profession. I think coming back to vet med as a second career is a barrier. I also think that coming into vet med from a non-science background is a barrier. So is coming in with children, or being a previous foster child, or being a first generation college student.
All of these things are atypical from the "standard" applicant template and are worthy of consideration as unique experiences that might augment someone's ultimate path to veterinary school. These are also experiences that I'm sure resonate with many of the people who are still hopefuls who are reading these threads in the hopes of seeing a little of themselves in these posts and feeling that maybe their stories will be reflected in one of these threads in a few years.