Hello everyone. I am a canadian IMg and i have been denied SON for IM residency since they capped. Can someone tell me the process to appeal further. I really appreciate it
Yea it’s too frustrating , . I cannot believe it still . Do u know anyone who has appealed last year ?I was denied too, i don't know what to do now. And its freaking Friday so no office is open now and we have to spend the weekend just waiting.
i'm asking around , no luck yetYea it’s too frustrating , . I cannot believe it still . Do u know anyone who has appealed last year ?
Ok please let me know if get any information...i'm asking around , no luck yet
Can u please tell me how to do it ? They have reduced the number of SONs issued this year . Can v start based on that ?Hey guys, I was not issued a SON as well. Perhaps if there is a lot of us a petition can be started?
They made it very clear last year, that they will NO LONGER be "Flexible" with the limits, and offer any SONs by any "appeal" processes. Otherwise, what is the point of even putting a limit?
It sucks, but they made it very clear where they want people going into, and that is mostly FM.
Even last year, people did NOT get SONs for IM(and maybe 1-2 other specialties, but dont have the file open infront of me), and had to re-apply this year.
It absolutely sucks, but it is an expected outcome of their decision process.
Your best bet is call your program director ASAP, explain the situation, and see if they will delay your start date and sponsor H1B. If you are an IMG (non US grad), you need STEP 3 done before you can get H1B. Explain the situation clearly.
IF you are a Canadian at a USMD/USDO program, and didn't get SON for J1, apply for OPTI ASAP(if you havent already done so). You can do your PGY1 on that visa(sorry carribeans, aussie, ireland, only US graduates can back up with this visa). Then you can re-apply for SON J1 next year, and make absolutely sure you are submitted at X:00:00 time stamp. Or hopefully your program may consider sponsoring H1B also. Be creative, some people have offered to put towards their educational stipend amounts towards the costs etc...(just dont go advertising this, as it may not be "allowed").
It is a ****ty process, but it seems they are being firm with things, and this was already the scenario last year..and they made it abundantly clear that would be the norm moving forward. As well they published the cut-offs for each specialty early also.
Lastly: IF you have an alternative citizenship other than Canada, it would be very useful to look into the specifics of using that to get a J1 instead...and how that all would pertain re: ECFMG etc etc. There may be ways to make that work for the lucky few who do have that option. Or marry a US citizen, easier said then done.
It is getting harder and harder for IMGs and it will only get worse. For future students reading and considering foreign programs, make sure you know the ins-and-outs of the process before you commit to it. Be sure you are comfortable with the level of risk.
Those who didn't get a SON this year, may very well get it next year, or find alternative path outside of the J1(H1B, marriage etc).
i don't think ecfmg will do anything as it's the canadian government that is placing the restriction. what province are you from?I am an Indian citizen. Does anyone know how to move forward in this situation. I will be contacting ECFMG soon.
The point is that you may be able to put your alternative citizenship down as where you will do your "2 year home req" for the J1. Maybe. Maybe not. Like i said this is more likely an avenue for those with dual citizenship IN ADVANCE of this whole process, not after its already happened and you've already gotten the process rolling.i don't think ecfmg will do anything as it's the canadian government that is placing the restriction. what province are you from?
I have only Indian citizenship .. n a Canadian PR ., so hope it helps .. but I ll try my best to approach local MP.. But it’s really cruel .. 165 SON will never b enough for IM n it’s very less for other specialities ...The point is that you may be able to put your alternative citizenship down as where you will do your "2 year home req" for the J1. Maybe. Maybe not. Like i said this is more likely an avenue for those with dual citizenship IN ADVANCE of this whole process, not after its already happened and you've already gotten the process rolling.
This was clear last year also, so it is nothing new.I have only Indian citizenship .. n a Canadian PR ., so hope it helps .. but I ll try my best to approach local MP.. But it’s really cruel .. 165 SON will never b enough for IM n it’s very less for other specialities ...
Yes, that was the missing piece to my thought process. I recalled something to that effect, hence why its probably more so of help for someone who is embarking on the IMG pathway as a Canadian, where you can do some paperwork and maneuvering to make your 2nd country of citizenship your "last country of residence" etc.The J visa process in the US requires that your SoN come from the last country of residence. Even if you have a second citizenship, it won't help (theoretically).
Next year, they have lowered the cap to 150.
Wow, didn't realize so many people were missing out on visas this year... kind of shocking. Canada is really one of the only countries that puts caps on their J1 physician sponsorships. Australia, UK, most other countries have unlimited caps for whatever specialty you wish to pursue...
After working so hard and taking on so much debt I didn't want to let my future hang on whether or not I got my SoN paperwork in fast enough, that is complete BS and also ridiculous that there are even caps seeing as many who get J1 visas wont even return to Canada anyways, but will get a J1 waiver and continue practicing in the US.
But anyways, some advice to any applicants in future years reading up on statement of need... Have all the paperwork filled out before the match, including multiple copies of the application form (fill one out for every possible program you could match to), have an email pre-drafted as well so that all you have to do when the match comes out is take a screenshot of NRMP webpage, attach it and hit send. My SoN app was submitted at 1:00 on the dot, not a minute later. Do yourself a favor and have everything ready to submit instantly so that you aren't the one who gets burned by this absurd policy. It takes about 1-2 hours to have copies of all the forms filled out and ACGME documentation pre-downloaded for every program you ranked so that you are 100% ready to smash the submit button as soon as the match gets posted. If you are on rotation or at work or something on match day, take a bathroom break before the match is released or just call in sick for the day. Seriously. Do not underestimate the stakes here or the ridiculous lengths to which other people will go to make sure they beat you to the punch. It might seem overkill to fill out 10 separate application forms, one for each permutation of match results you might receive... but believe me, this is one instance where you don't want to leave anything to chance and I guarantee you there are dozens of people out there who have their applications sent at 1:00 on the dot.
After working so hard and taking on so much debt I didn't want to let my future hang on whether or not I got my SoN paperwork in fast enough, that is complete BS and also ridiculous that there are even caps seeing as many who get J1 visas wont even return to Canada anyways, but will get a J1 waiver and continue practicing in the US.
Nope, have called multiple times. Only gotten the answering machine.Has anyone been physically able to get through to the SON office?
Trying to talk with the MP regarding this. Try to contact ur local Member. Where are you fromIn the reject boat for IM SoN- What are you folks doing?
Thanks a lot for your advise. I have put Indian citizenship even in the application but my mailing address is Canadian one. I will contact ecfmg asap
Many people who applied March 16 and were initially denied, received it today.Has anyone heard back from Health Canada today?
Anyone successful in their appeal?
Regardless of the appeal, people received it if they applied anytime on March 16th, a day to remember.So wait, did they just do a complete 180 and decide to give everyone who appealed it a statement of need regardless of the stated limits now??
Regardless of the appeal, people received it if they applied anytime on March 16th, a day to remember.
Great question. But they are still denied as of Friday.So did the others get denied? Or are they in the process of sorting that out?
I was still denied because i applied late, but trying to sort it out.. keeping my fingers crossed. and yes , they have given to everyone who applied on 16th. I am very much happy for the doctors who got SON. Congrats and good luck