I am responding to a PM with the sender's permission. As a medical student, I was allowed only 2 elective rotations. I did one ortho rotation at Botsford and another ortho rotation at a M.D. hospital. It is difficult to comment on different D.O. ortho programs out there. All I can give you is tidbits of information (personal opinions) on different programs. Your best source of information is going to come from current ortho residents. I have only been exposed to two D.O. ortho programs, one program I rotated at and the second is where I did my residency. You asked about didactics, for the most part the didactics varies from program to program from heavy to the minimum. The same can be said about the operative experience. For the most part the attendings are experienced and many have fellowship training. Keep in mind that as a resident operating at a community hospital, it is unlikey that you are going to be involved in complex tertiary type cases. Thats why out rotations are part of the program and why people pursue fellowships. One needs to ask themselve where do they want to end up, either in academics or in the community. Most people choose the latter because it truly offer the better lifestyle in my opinion (IMO). I will offer my comments on different ortho programs but the best information will come from the current residents and from an audition rotations at that program. For those of you like myself that only have 2 months of electives, you need to do more footwork in terms of investigating the different programs.
All the D.O. programs will train you well and I would have been happy to do my residency at any of the D.O. programs. IMO the better programs are the larger programs with extensive resources, where the residents work with large number of attendings, have excellent out rotations, high board pass rates and impressive fellowship placements. Also remember that at most programs, the interviews includes a test of ones orthopedic knowledge (IMO this is totally unnecessary since a residency program has 4 years to teach you orthopedics). The D.O. residencies in the upper 1/4 (in no particular order), keep in mind the following list is strictly my opinion. Also keep in mind that I am now going to be entering an orthopedic practice (the information may be outdated):
Botsford General Hospital
Doctors Hospital (Columbus)
Grandview Hospital
PCOM
Midwestern University
Genesys
St. Vincent
UNDNJ
Again, just one man's opinion. Like I said before I would have been happy to have done my residency at any of the D.O. programs.
You asked about the following (I have minimal information). I feel that if you are interested in these places then do the footwork, gather as much information as possible, and make an informed decision about wheather or not to rotate there. You can be creative, such as, using the weekend, time off, or couple of vaction days to shadow one of the resident/attending to see if you want to spend month long rotation there. Here some information on the programs you asked about:
Des Peres - there seems to be a high emphasis on board scores to get in and performance on the OITE exam (in service exam) as a resident. IMO this is unnecessary pressure on the resident since performance on the OITE does not correlate well with board passage.
Mt. Clemens - I know a guy that graduate from this program, he appeared happy with his experiences, had elective time to pursue additional outside rotations, and in the end he landed a great fellowship.
Garden City - very good program but a strange place. IMO some of the staff in the hospital have issues. The number of ortho applicants out number the number of openings, this does not give them the right to treat interviewees/interns poorly. They were dead last on my rank list.
Doctors (Columbus) a great program, however, I was turn off by the fact that they interviewed a large number of outside people and accepted their "in house" interns. The applicants were notified of the outcome of the interview on the same day as the interview.
Memorial hospital - can't tell you much except; excellent outside rotations, good overall program, probably necessary to do a rotation there or be a Penn resident to be considered for an interview.
PCOM - Again can't tell you much except; strong program and interview process is similar to a cattle call.
I will post my experience with Botsford in another post.
I hope this helps?