You only applied to 2 schools? Did you consult anyone on this? That is a very bad idea no matter how good of an applicant you are. Especially since you basically only applied to 1 school. Your NYU application was essentially a throwaway since you have a -very- low MCAT/GPA by their standards. (Stat-hungry)
As another poster pointed out, your problem was not your stats. You do not need to retake the MCAT, especially since you already have 2 scores in the same area. If you feel absolutely confident you can hit about 518 and want to spend that time, it is your life. However, you have a 3.7 and a 511/12 MCAT, and great ECs. It is not unheard of for a URM to matriculate into a T20 with those stats which is why I think you are wasting your time.
Your main problem was your school list. Make use of your 20 applications from FAP. A smarter idea would be to create a great school list now, apply early, and if you still feel like you need to put in another MCAT score (which, again, I advise against but your life/time) take it in August or September. Also be sure you are not applying to state schools which accept few OOS.
@Faha - What do you think his school list should be? (I will remove your stats after, just wanted to make it easier for them to find your info)
Major: Neuroscience
State of Residence: NH
cGPA: 3.68
sGPA: 3.68
Mcat: 511-->512---> 3rd retake July 19th (Been scoring 520+ in my FLs)
URM: AA male, FAP
Clinical Experience
Volunteer: 320 hrs in Ghana
Remote Area Medical Volunteering -- 30 hours
Shadowing
OB/GYN: 40 hrs
General Surgeon: 50 hrs
Family Medecine: 50 hrs
Non-Clinical Volunteering
200 hours - Self-Started Club for Local Volunteering
60 hours - Global Healths Brigade
100 hours - Mentally challenged Individuals and Geriatics
90 hours - Orphanage
Research
1000+ hours- Nanomaterials Laboratory (Publication early August/Late September)
ECs
Vice-Captain of Soccer Team--1.5 years
French Club -- 2 years
My Clothing Line -- 6 years
Diversity Club (Exec Member) -- 2 years
Student Muslim Association(No exec) -- 2 years
Science Tutor -- 2 years
Worked at my school's bookstore - 1 year
School list (in no particular order):
UNC- Chapel Hill
Emory University
Indiana University
University of Wisconsin-Madison
University of Maryland
University of Iowa
University of Minnesota
George Washington University
University of Miami
Albany Medical College
University of Conneticut
University of Utah
I apologize for my late response. I worked all weekend and was knocking out MCAT studying. The only break I had was to see Avengers (3 hrs, jesus.)