Well...actually I only got into UNC. But I only applied to 6 schools, mostly in-state. Carolina had always been my first choice without a doubt.
If you have the luxury of making a decision....I am in-state, so of course the affordable tuition at UNC is a big plus for me. If I had to choose between UNC in other school's, things that I view as pros at UNC are their special programs office, classes ending at 12, pass-fail, and the open, friendly, non-competitive environment. The environment is what really sold me at Carolina. For the person deciding between Chapel HIll and Duke, I would look at Duke's retention rate and attitude toward minorities. Even before the lacrosse fiasco, Duke's reputation has been shaky towards minorities, but I have met happy graduate students there.
I have been in touch with the special programs office-I actually contacted them in August, they set up a tour of the medical school for me, I met a recruitor, and I met students. It was very nice of them and I felt as if I already had a support group at UNC before even being accepted. Now, I feel that when coming to UNC I will already have a family of people to talk to, because I kept in contact with my recruiter as well as a few second years.
I didn't go to second look but my friend told me I didn't miss much and they were still trying to sell the school to people, as opposed of a welcome to chapel hill and here's what you do now.
Let me know of y'alls decision and I hope to see you in the fall...