dude... just... come on... dude. he called it "baloney". i know you're loyal and you want to get your peep's back and show yer a homey and that attendings gotta stick together and whatnot, but come on. "baloney?" is this setting a good example?
jet, please call bull**** when you see it, no matter who it's coming from. this stuff is important. you guys complain about "slackers" entering the field (although i'd argue the exact opposite is true... and you guys should be nervous), and then he sets this kind of example?
please. don't put words in his mouth and/or justify his posts.
Review my posts on the plethora of academic teachings that I don't think hold water, Volatile.
I remember a lengthy post I wrote about putting a woman to sleep for a C section when necessary....and how residents are taught the "dangers" of doing this, to the point where their fear of same could affect their performance....
Risks of certain clinical situations should be taught in academia, I agree.
But academia fails in conveying that the risks are
VERY LOW if you are a deft clinician.
And yes, volatile, there are many anesthesia myths perpetuated by academia.
I've never used less than a 7.0 tube for a C-section requiring GA.
C-sections requiring GA are just like any other RSI GA, except they desaturate like a morbidly obese person so you have to be quick. And if there is difficulty intubating, a little reverse T-berg and appropriate (read non gastric-insufflating) mask ventilation can be done until you get the tube in. Academia's over-emphasis on parturient aspiration risk is overblown. Pure and simple. To the point of needlessly placing overblown fear in new clinicians...to the point of potentially affecting your performance. Soooo, have you ever heard an academic dude give you an explanation like that for intubating a parturient? I'll bet not. I'll bet they placed fear in your head.
I've yet to figure out why it is taught that an RSI must be done on someone with non-postural GERD.
I've yet to figure out why many clinicians give a pre-op albuterol treatment to an asymptomatic asthmatic.
I think our NPO guidelines need to be modified.
I could go on and on.
Not blindly agreeing.
Just calling it like I see it after ten years making my living in this biz.