Was accepted here in February. I'm still waiting on a couple other programs, but secured my spot anyway. I think with programs like these it's more of what you make of them and which one fits you best. While past reviews on sdn about this particular program are mixed, I have consistently heard that administration and faculty are very supportive and very enthusiastic about your success. Additionally the Scranton program is taking M1 level courses, at the medical school, that's taught by their faculty. Also I do believe they still offer a conditional interview should you meet certain criteria. While I don't know if we would be taking classes literally along side the M1 students, this sounds like a legitimate SMP, and is for me, a good enough reason to attend. I can't say the same for the Doylestown program because this is not at the medical school.
The only reason any of us are considering an SMP is to simply bolster or medical school application by delivering an optimal performance in an M1 simulated year. No matter which program you choose to attend, they all serve this same purpose and you are only there to do your best. For me personally, the only things I will consider is if it's a legit SMP and the cost of tuition, which of course you only want the cheapest one.