“Psychiatry isn’t a real medical specialty”

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

worrieddddpsych

New Member
2+ Year Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2018
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
I was watching a Youtube video and started to scroll through the comments and saw this.

Do other specialists REALLY undermine psychiatrists or is this just some random guys bias?

IMG_4770.JPG

Members don't see this ad.
 
It’s not an issue in the real world.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 6 users
I was watching a Youtube video and started to scroll through the comments and saw this.

Do other specialists REALLY undermine psychiatrists or is this just some random guys bias?

View attachment 253152

why do people read comments sections of...anything
 
  • Like
Reactions: 14 users
Members don't see this ad :)
I was watching a Youtube video and started to scroll through the comments and saw this.

Do other specialists REALLY undermine psychiatrists or is this just some random guys bias?

View attachment 253152

Occasionally people have that bias. If I encounter a physician with that bias, I'll just let them know they should send their consults to a "real" doctor.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
I mentioned this before.

In hospitals doctors occasionally say psychiatry is BS. The same doctors days later are begging you to do a psych consult.

While I was in residency the med residents were worked liked dogs, many of them doing over 80 hrs a week even up until their last year of residency. I was good friends with them and during lunch in the cafeteria one of them pointed out that he's being worked like a dog while my schedule at 2nd year was about 2/3ds his level of stress and hours.

I told him something to the effect of "while you're working your butt off tonight, I'm going on a hot-date, we're going to have some drinks, a nice dinner, spend some quality time with this beautiful lady, and tonight we're going to eff our brains out while you're going to be on-call tonight. So if you want to talk about how much of a wimp I am compared to you sure! And when we're attendings and I'm making more money than you, yeah same thing! A toast to you! You rock!" while I had a tremendous and sarcastic smile on his face that only made him feel worse. A few times afterwards, especially when I saw my fellow med residents overworked, I'd shake my hips kind of like in a dance and tell them how much I wasn't a real doctor with a big smile on my face.

I think I was able to get away with it without any hate cause we were already friends, and when I was a chief, I went a lot out of my way to help the med-residents out.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 6 users
I was watching a Youtube video and started to scroll through the comments and saw this.

Do other specialists REALLY undermine psychiatrists or is this just some random guys bias?

View attachment 253152

Lol are you seriously quoting YouTube video comments?

How many “YAAA” “FIRST” “YO CHECK OUT MY PAGE AND SUBSCRIBE” and “This guy is a nazi” comments did you have to scroll through to get to that one?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 users
I love what I do day to day, and I get to see a lot of suffering people get much better. If some chunk of the population thinks I'm not a real doctor that has pretty much no impact on my life at all.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 6 users
I was watching a Youtube video and started to scroll through the comments and saw this.

Do other specialists REALLY undermine psychiatrists or is this just some random guys bias?

View attachment 253152

Even if other specialities do undermine Psychiatry (which I have encountered fairly rarely so far), I don't think we benefit by dwelling on it.

To quote Supermodel of the World and drag superstar Rupaul - what other people think of me is none of my damn business.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5 users
I love what I do day to day, and I get to see a lot of suffering people get much better. If some chunk of the population thinks I'm not a real doctor that has pretty much no impact on my life at all.

EXACTLY!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
They'll be reminded when they send a referral your way for depression whom they never thought of running thyroid studies on (despite some obvious signs) then you're the one who gets it done, finds a glaring problem, and follows with an update to the other teams involved. (This can be the case for other potential medical issues as well). Psychiatry for the win baby!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
You saw it on the internet therefore it must be true!
 
Members don't see this ad :)
I've just never understood the premise that there is some nebulous uber-medicine that psychiatry is being compared to. How do you even apply realness as a frame of reference? Even if we say internal medicine is the standard, which seems to be the implication, then thank god psychiatry is not "real medicine" because it shouldn't be. Obviously navigating motivation, behaviors, personality, relations, and social context is not the same as prescribing lisinopril 10 and watching some numbers change.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
When comparing cardiology to psychiatry, one psychiatrist said, "the heart is just a dumb pump" when comparing it to the brain.

Another way to look at it schizophrenia or bipolar disorder in some ways is as or more distressing to a patient then cancer or AiDS.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Most comment sections on videos about psych, even like “welcome to our residency” videos with 200 views have comments in all caps about how a psychiatrist tried to control my mind with chemicals. Not worth even glancing at aside from sating curiosity.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Lol are you seriously quoting YouTube video comments?

How many “YAAA” “FIRST” “YO CHECK OUT MY PAGE AND SUBSCRIBE” and “This guy is a nazi” comments did you have to scroll through to get to that one?

lol but the only reason i even made this post was because i’ve heard from numerous people that psychiatry isn’t a real specialty.
 
lol but the only reason i even made this post was because i’ve heard from numerous people that psychiatry isn’t a real specialty.
Whatevs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
If forced to have one, I would pick idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis over schizophrenia every time.

point is, to forgo the mind is more distressing than forgoing the body for many.
 
If forced to have one, I would pick GAD over idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis every time

Apples to apples I’d pick hypertension over depression every time
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Can't believe you're browsing youtube without the best chrome extension ever.

Herp Derp for YouTube™

Improves legibility of youtube comments by changing every comment to "herp derp"
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
If anyone's bored, i suggest the antipsych subreddit. It's gold.
 
Apples to apples I’d pick hypertension over depression every time

I was just trying to point out that it's pointless to compare psychiatric illnesses to medical illnesses. I think this is especially true given the neuropsychiatric effects of many medical illnesses (MS, Parkinson's, lupus, etc)
 
In primary care I hear actually the opposite. Several PCPs tell me they need a psychiatrist in their office and often times are begging to work with me. They also often times complain of being in situations they don't know how to handle such as if the patient tells them they're suicidal.

Some other factors are changing. 1-the scale of psych being all touchy-feeling is largely declining due to several trends such as more scientific advancement, harder requirements in the sciences (e.g. average GPAs are much higher for medstudents vs several years ago) 2-The era of psych patients largely being confined to asylums ended in the 80s, and there was a generational gap. Back in the day psychiatric issues were often times a taboo to talk about among friends and family. The meds got better, more mentally sick people were out in the public instead of long-term hospitals, and it's slowly but surely thrust the issue into the public mindset. 3-People are much more aware of psych issues these days due to the media and other cultural changes such as an aging population where dementia and depression are ever growing concerns.

I've mentioned this before several times. I've seen several psychiatrists not know their medical stuff, heck even their psychiatric stuff, but this is true of all physicians. It's a pet-peeve of mine when I see a patient with a significant medical problem that is easy to catch and their PCP or other physican couldn't catch it, and unfortunately it happens often.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
In primary care I hear actually the opposite. Several PCPs tell me they need a psychiatrist in their office and often times are begging to work with me. They also often times complain of being in situations they don't know how to handle such as if the patient tells them they're suicidal.

Some other factors are changing. 1-the scale of psych being all touchy-feeling is largely declining due to several trends such as more scientific advancement, harder requirements in the sciences (e.g. average GPAs are much higher for medstudents vs several years ago) 2-The era of psych patients largely being confined to asylums ended in the 80s, and there was a generational gap. Back in the day psychiatric issues were often times a taboo to talk about among friends and family. The meds got better, more mentally sick people were out in the public instead of long-term hospitals, and it's slowly but surely thrust the issue into the public mindset. 3-People are much more aware of psych issues these days due to the media and other cultural changes such as an aging population where dementia and depression are ever growing concerns.

I've mentioned this before several times. I've seen several psychiatrists not know their medical stuff, heck even their psychiatric stuff, but this is true of all physicians. It's a pet-peeve of mine when I see a patient with a significant medical problem that is easy to catch and their PCP or other physican couldn't catch it, and unfortunately it happens often.

This is a really good summary, the other factor I would add is that psych specifically went from being extremely non-competitive to being on the rise and I expect it will continue to do so. Having the bottom of the barrel students represent a field will naturally have consequences. As more competitive students go into psych it will continue to diminish this stigma (at least with peers).
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Every acute care hospital ive worked in the other specialties LOVED the psychiatrists...most (besides peds, neuro and some IM/FP/PCP) didnt like practicing psychiatry at all and I do so its a win-win in my experience.

What youll learn is all medical specialties gripe about one another...some people say surgeons arent real doctors but "mechanics" imagine that.

So far as the public goes...let them have their opinions...the public pendulum is swinging in favor of psychiatry in part related to the opioid crisis and the favorable views of emotional self care by the millennial generation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Top