With good technique and lots of local, routine use of sedation for an LP should generally not be needed. The sedation is more for parental anxiety than anything else. Kids' interlaminar spaces are wide open. A properly performed LP should not make someone feel like they're having an awake laminectomy or L2 bone-biopsy. In fact, a properly performed, well anesthetized LP often times hurts less than the IV attempt. That being said, yes, some people and parents just go bonkers at the thought of a non-sedated anything, so it's on a case by case basis. Also, if the patient is going to flail like a fish, sedation can be helpful. But adding sedation for an LP as a normal course of business probably extends your procedure time 4 fold or more.
/oldschool/