B
bleach
Could any of you who has either interviewed at University of Illinois at Chicago or externed or attended give some feedback about it ? Thanks
Could any of you who has either interviewed at University of Illinois at Chicago or externed or attended give some feedback about it ? Thanks
and about bu ?
thank you!!
I have a friend who is just finishing his first year there. He has told me both good and bad things, which is probably what you would hear from any resident anywhere.
It's VERY busy. Apparently BU gets the bulk of the Boston trauma, where as Tufts and MGH deal with different populations/pathology so to speak. When he's on call, he works like a dog, and clinic is rough on a daily basis. Attendings are supposedly very solid, and work them as hard as is reasonable as far as didactics, and out of clinic scut work alike.
He said that if he could choose again, he'd likely choose the same, but did not realize from the pitch at the interview how rigorous the program was. However, it sounds like a very well rounded 4-yr program that exposes you to a lot. I know he said he feels he will be well prepared for private practice, or part time hospital work.
Hope that helps.
We should get this thread more active, between all the people on this forum we could probably profile like 2 dozen programs....let's keep 'em coming!!
can anyone throw light on OSMF programs in maryland and dc area?
Maryland anyone?NYU is a great program that is heavy in pathology, orthognathics, and DA/implants. I'm sure they do more but this is what I've heard. If your looking to live in NYC you can't go wrong with it. Plus they have an attending that does head and neck surgery which brings a lot to the program. This is the only North East program that does head and neck to my knowledge so if your looking to be on the East coat and cut big cases I would recommend checking out this program. Only negatives are the cost of the med school, but last year U.S. News ranked it #34.
The only major downside I see to the program is the huge amount of time spent in medical school. Residents spend 1 year as intern, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th year of medical school, 4 months on service, 8 months on G surg, and then 12 months as chief. The length of med school is my only concern with the program but other than that it seems like a great place with very cool residents.
Cunningham (who is now the new department chair) told me that he is working out a deal with the medical school to cut the med school time (and tuition) to 2 years. Residents will do the last 6 mo's of M2, all of M3, and 6 mo's of M4, with the rest of the time being on OMS service and anesthesia. Not sure when and if all this will happen, but I figured I'd let you know since it was a concern for you.
There is no fellow this year. There are rumors we may take one on January. Not sure what was behind this. I don't think it dilutes the experience though because all of our attendings basically treat the same scope of patients. They may not personally do as many neck dissections and flaps as Dr. Marx does each year, but you still get these cases even when you aren't on his service. This place is just so incredibly busy I don't think I could even do it any justice from my descriptions.
And yah, I used to be at Carle before a family emergency pulled me away a couple of years ago... That's a freaking great program too! My family and life outside of OMFS were here in Florida, so it worked out for the best that ended up getting to stay here. I love it here and I absolutely love the program.
Residency 4 years in length with MD Option at the end.
How long is the MD at the end?? If you get your MD after doing gen surg internship, can you still get a medical license?
From my understanding Miami has never had a resident go back and do the required 3 years of medical school plus a general surgery internship. That's 4 years away from OMFS. I never saw the point of doing this. Why not just do a fellowship in OMFS further develop your surgical skills, and be a high skilled dual degreed surgeon rather than a dual degreed surgeon with weak OMFS skills. Now, if someone wants to get the MD to go into plastics or ENT I can the point of going through all that to get the MD.
Check the earlier posts of this thread for reviews on Nebraska, Case, Carle (IL), UMKC, Mayo, UIC. To add my brief impressions on a few:
UIC is becoming a solid program with Miloro. He will likely try to transition the program to an MD integrated format with the eventual goal of replicating Nebraska's program, which he still speaks highly of. I would expect this program to be legit very soon as Miloro is a ball-buster while also being pro-resident. In other words, at Nebraska he would push residents and push for residents and their experience.
That's a nice segue to Nebraska. I think the strongest aspect of this program is the 5 year format, though they haven't had the best passing rates with step 1. They do a fair amount of cosmetics and overall there is a lot of resident cutting. I don't know anything about Desa, but I hear he's the new PD and that he's a really cool guy.
Now onto Case, the other 5 year. Same kind of story - 5 year format is the big benefit, but they get 3 chances to pass Step 1 here instead of 2. Pretty swanky VA facility with tons of 3rds and implants your first year. Good cosmetic exposure. Residents are cool. Cleveland is not cool. Not a Level-1 trauma center.
Metro in Cleveland, last I heard (last year) was that they were not accredited. I haven't heard anything new - hopefully this is resolved. Evidently this is a Level-1, so if they combined forces with Case this could be pretty enticing. However, I have heard the PD at Metro is eternally resistant to this idea of being absorbed. I heard he is a talented guy with a lot to offer, but Metro and Case would be a powerhouse combined program and he is the biggest obstacle. Again, Cleveland is not cool.
Another program that is geographically challenged is Mayo, though supposedly Rochester is more cosmopolitan than you would expect. As for the experience, 40+ months of OMS time and impressive orthognathic numbers and a busy IV sed clinic. Good scope with plenty of the "zebras" that Mayo is prone to getting because of their name. They are also in the process of hiring a 5th attending, so we'll see how that shakes out. Could make that program a real stand-out.
Just up the road in Minneapolis is the University of Minnesota. 4 year program. Sounds pretty busy. They have a history of losing residents from time to time. This could be due to the fact that some of their residents did not rank them very highly but ended up there anyhow, so they didn't start out on the right foot. Doesn't sound like a very pleasant place, though Minneapolis is fun if you can stand the winter. They did just get a cancer guy, but the jury's still out. Seems like if it's busy they should be doing a lot, but I mostly just hear that it's busy.
So, from what I know and what I've heard, the midwest has some bright spots and some black sheep. These are very brief impressions, and I only really have personal information on the programs that were already reviewed in detail, so this info is basically supplementary. Hope it's still helpful.
LeFortsBeWithU, that is easily the best name ever. F'n funny.
Agreed. That is/was the best name. I don't think he has time to post anymore. He matched at Knoxville 2 years ago.I don't know.....there was a guy named Ludwig's Mangina around here a couple years ago (until he got banned). The first time I saw his name I made a scene in the library from laughing so hard.
Agreed. That is/was the best name. I don't think he has time to post anymore. He matched at Knoxville 2 years ago.
Both are the same person. He was banned as LudwigsVagina and came back as LudwigsMangina.There are 2: LudwigsMangina and LudwigsVagina. Both excellent names.
I don't know.....there was a guy named Ludwig's Mangina around here a couple years ago (until he got banned). The first time I saw his name I made a scene in the library from laughing so hard.
Does anybody know anything about Thomas Jefferson University's program?
jake waited for you all night. Quit being a slacker. Anyone have Parkland, UCSF, Houston, MGH, Oregon. And this is by far one of the best threads sdn has but up in quite some time
Externed only at LSU-Shreveport so by no means should I be considered the authority on this program, but since no one else has posted anything on it, I will give my two cents.
Lots of big cases with a broad scope in the OR with limited scope in the Clinic/Dentoalveolar arena. Spent one week there and saw 2 "neck whacks" (one bilateral and one unilateral modified radical neck dissection, each with microvascular free tissue transfer from the forearm). Saw primary lip repair, Double Jaw, tons of trauma, etc.
That is what is what I saw. I think it is also interesting to note that in one day, Dr. *REDACTED* was going from OR to OR while his residents were doing most of the cutting. I.e. he would literally walk into the neck-whack room and help for about and hour, then he would leave and go check on the primary lip repair, etc.
What I gathered from the residents about their scope and numbers:
-Borderline too much trauma
-When asked how often neck-whacks were done, one of the residents said "about two a week."
-Dr. Ghali does the full arsenal of craniofacial procedures including crazy synostosis cases along with primary lips, etc.
-Decent amount of Orthognathic cases.
-Didn't ask about cosmetics, but didn't see any. May be done as private patients of Dr. Ghali. But seeing as Ghali has a chapter in the Peterson textbook on facelifts, I am sure the residents get a fair share of experience.
-Intern year, you get sedation trained and will do some sedations in the clinic taking out wizzies, etc, but aren't going to see alot of this.
Summary:
Strengths: Lots of OR time, with 2 designated ORs, covering the full gamut of OR procedures with possible emphasis on truama and oncology. As a 5th and 6th year resident, you will practically live in the OR, usually doing about 2-3 cases a day or the 1 neck whack. Ghali in himself is a plus, bringing in procedures that other Surgeons in our profession would not even attempt. Very little time in Med School (approximately 16 months I believe). I believe it was 8 months of General Surgery with some flexibility as to which areas you actually rotate through.
Weaknesses: Lots of trauma which might be brutal your intern year only, Very little implant procedures, most of which seemed very basic. I believe resident told me about 40 implants is what he expects to place. Lots of followup care for oncology patients, lots of point and pull in the clinic during your intern and 3rd years.
As for Shreveport itself, the area around the hospital is pretty bad, but the city has some nice areas. One resident described it accurately to me when he said "Shreveport is nice enough that you have stuff to do during residency, but not enough that you feel like your missing something."
If anyone cares to add to/correct something from the above, please feel free to do so.