I never really considered MD school either. Of course when I first started working optical I was going to school for law
Quality of life issues are a big factor with me. I would love to have a broader scope of practice, and be able to do more..but I am perfectly happy with the eye biz and really long to have enough time to be a mom too.
Some issues you need to work through before deciding which way to go:
1) Are you interested in only the eye?
2) Are you just disappointed in your mcats and only are hedging your bets so to speak..(ie.. afraid you won't get accepted to med school and therefore trying to convince yourself optometry is better)
3) Do you mind being in the lower end of the health professions?
4) Why are you interested in either profession?
5) What do you expect to get out of it?
OMDs not only are surgeons, but the are disease specialists. While it is becoming more and more popular for ODs to manage diseases, the OMDs have had this field for a long time. The main reason's why are their lack of limitations on therapeutic drugs, and the ability to preform the surgical techniques that might be required. OMDs work with oncologists in various types of retinal cancers. Glaucoma, Diabetic Retinapathy, certain types of tumors, cataracts, and things which are systemic wide or affects the whole body. They can do everything an OD can do and more.
Now, is that worth more to you that being able to practice by the time you are 28? That is something only you can answer.
I am perfectly happy dealing with the eyes. I have been doing so for years now. I enjoy being able to help people maximize their vision and feeling like I am truly providing a service to someone. As I stated before, there is no way I would be willing to go through med school hell and ruin my family life for the extra duties. But that is me...
You need to think about what is right for you, what type of life you seriously want, and which route will make it happen. Because in the end, your happiness and satisfaction is what matters, not our opinions on whether you did the right thing or not...
Cassandra