I am in the BS/DO program through New Paltz-NYCOM and I am currently a 1st year at NYCOM. Everyone seems to be knocking New Paltz, but I would recommend the program. Yeah, it's not the traditional pre-med school, but who wants to waste their time at those stuffy places anyway. At those schools, their trying to weed out the pre-meds. Do you really want to bust your butt all through college just to have to break your back for another 4 years of medical school? You'll end up having to take a break between college and medical school just to recover from being burnt at college(this happened to a few of my friends). Obviously you graduated from a great high school, so you've proven to yourself that you're smart. College is not only a time to learn a little, it's also a time to have fun. You will have time for fun if you don't have to worry about impressing med schools with 1000s of hours of volunteering at your local hospital, Dr's office, shelter,....
As a plug for New Paltz:
There are so many different and interesting people at New Paltz. In any give day you will see hippies playing their bongos on "Tripping Fields", pre-meds studying in the CSB, artists selling their pottery on the quad, bio and chem majors preparing posters for their research presentations, and film majors interviewing students in the halls. There are so many different classes to take (they also fill those pesky requirements to graduate) and clubs to join. I really had a good time during college and I'm so glad I have those relaxing times to look back on when I'm stressing out for exams now.