- Joined
- Jun 3, 2005
- Messages
- 108
- Reaction score
- 0
is it hard for men to get in? i heard its easier cause there are less who apply. but someone told me programs dont like men.
whats the truth>? TIA
whats the truth>? TIA
TY06 said:is it hard for men to get in? i heard its easier cause there are less who apply. but someone told me programs dont like men.
whats the truth>? TIA
UCLAMAN said:men are at a premium in the field since not enough apply. the field wants a 50/50 split...unfortunately they can never get that since not enough men apply. northwestern's program has 9 spots...we make sure that at least 1 or 2 are filled by men if not more. most programs also try to make sure that they have at least 1 male(maybe more depending on the size of the program). as one of my ob/gyn advisors puts it "you have one other advantage in the OB/gyn match process...your third leg."
aamna929 said:i don't get it.. not enough apply? most of the ob/gyns in my insurance book are male.. i had to really look to find a female one for me.
aamna929 said:i don't get it.. not enough apply? most of the ob/gyns in my insurance book are male.. i had to really look to find a female one for me.
Andre04 said:The demographic is changing. Currently-practicing ob/gyns are mostly male, especially among the older set, but there's a huge influx of women in residency and starting their careers.
On a personal note, every female ob/gyn I've gone to has been a witch, so I'm glad that there are still men going into it (despite the SN, I'm not a dude). I think it's dangerous for there to be too much estrogen in any field.
superspec said:
Just like it might be dangerous to have too much testosterone in any field?????
Faebinder said:You know the truth behind it.... In general men don't feel very welcome during their OBGYN rotations... and I am not talking about the residents nor the attendings... it's the patients mostly. My experience (6 weeks which were excellent to be honest) was like... oh no students please.... (male student leaves).... alright....
or my favorite worse case scenario.... I'm a male, my resident that day was a male (nice guy), my attending happened to be a male (great guy), and the third year IM resident rotating (decent guy as well)..... patient #3 comes in for her Kolposcopy....She looked at us and asked the attending, What is this? An orgy? Do you mind some privacy?
The usual..... I was out that door before he even said a word.
(I think I recieved a total of 4 asked to go out in my 2 weeks clinic, 2 asked out in my 2 weeks OB and 0 asked out in my 2 weeks of GYN)
I know to some people that's nothing special... but when you see patients arguing male residents to leave... you start to wonder why would I as a male go into that specialty?
juddson said:This is my biggest fear. At some point somebody will post recent study data suggesting that the patient preferences do not portend that poorly for males in the field. But I am skeptical of such data because, as far as I know, the data does not stratify by age of patient. I bet (though, of course it is only a guess without the data) that the older patients skew toward no preference or male preference and the younger patients skew heavily towards a female preference.
If that is true (does anybody know of any studies that break it down this way), it does not bode well for young men entering the field.
Judd
do you guys think its the same deal for fellowships? Easier for men to get into them (urogyn, gynonc)bkrone1 said:Here's another link for you:
University of Kentucky Ob/Gyn: 6/20 male residents
http://www.mc.uky.edu/obg/Residency/currentresidents.asp
I think it is a great time to get into OB/Gyn as a male. In my experience, for every woman that prefers a female MD, I have encountered another woman who preferred male MD's. It's all about pt preference. I think it is good to be a rare commodity.
OBfan said:do you guys think its the same deal for fellowships? Easier for men to get into them (urogyn, gynonc)
Spittz03 said:Wayne State University has >50% males:
Unknown - 1st years
6/12 - 2nd year
5/8 - 3rd years
7/12 - 4th years
juddson said:This is my biggest fear. At some point somebody will post recent study data suggesting that the patient preferences do not portend that poorly for males in the field. But I am skeptical of such data because, as far as I know, the data does not stratify by age of patient. I bet (though, of course it is only a guess without the data) that the older patients skew toward no preference or male preference and the younger patients skew heavily towards a female preference.
If that is true (does anybody know of any studies that break it down this way), it does not bode well for young men entering the field.
Judd
MacGyver said:100% accurate. The only reason older women show no preference for female ob/gyn is because growing up they had no choice but to see a male, so after years of that they got accustomed to male ob/gyns and no longer have any preference.
But its absolutely 180 degrees different for young females today. Today they have a choice, and they show a STRONG preference for female ob/gyns
pruritis_ani said:this topic makes me laugh. i have NEVER seen any male student or resident asked to leave. i have seem the VERY rare muslim pt that strongly prefers a female doc, and we usually can accomadate her.
there is plenty of work out there for smart, empathetic docs of either sex. i come into contact with male and female ob/gyns in the private sector every day. neither group is hurting for patients. they are plenty busy.
so, don't worry about it. if you are capable and nice you will do well. if you aren't, well then you would probably do poorly regardless of your gender.
UCLAMAN said:gees...thank you. finally some support in this thread.
UCLAMAN said:i disagree with this. there will always be women who have a strong preference for female physicians. the question is...what percentage of the female population have such a strong preference? i would argue certainly not the majority(albeit i don't have the 3000 subject study to back that up). anecdotally i think that women in their teens and early 20's may have some reservations seeing a male ob/gyn. however, i think as women get older(later 20's and 30's) i think they start to lose those reservations. and even for those early 20's patients....i would still argue that its not gender that is the deciding factor as to whether a male ob/gyn will have a big practice or not. i think it will come down to a physician's skill and personality rather than his third leg.
i mean...i am pretty sure that a 23y/o woman with a positive triple screen at 15 weeks could give a rats ass about the gender of the person doing the amnio. what she really cares about is how many amnios have you done? the woman having abnormal uterine bleeding could probably care less too...just stop the freakin bleeding, period. there are tons of young women who need or want birth control. for the majority of women...does the gender of the prescribing doc really matter? i mean...just give the woman her ortho evra.
simplified? perhaps. i guess my point is this...there will always be women who strongly prefer a woman ob/gyn. but when it comes down to it...the population of women outside the aforementioned group just want their healthcare from a caring, skilled physician regardless of gender. i mean for most people...when you are sick or have problems, you just want the problem fixed.
don't even get me started about the subspecialties. gyne-onc...you think a woman actually cares about the gender of the person taking out her ovarian or breast cancer? probably the last thing on her mind. REI? a woman who can't conceive, i am sure she could care less about the doc's gender. just get her pregnant. MFM? if you are a high risk patient frankly i dont think the gender of their doc is their primary concern.
Hmmmmm....ALL the female PEOPLE I KNOW prefer female OB/GYN. I have NEVER heard one state the contrary.Billy Shears said:This is only anecdotal, but pretty much all my female friends tell me they prefer a male, and all the male Ob/Gyns I know (8 or 9) have tons of patients. The two female Ob/Gyns are hardly ever busy. So, I doubt it is a problem.
Cardsnurse said:Hmmmmm....ALL the female PEOPLE I KNOW prefer female OB/GYN. I have NEVER heard one state the contrary.
Cardsnurse said:Hmmmmm....ALL the female PEOPLE I KNOW prefer female OB/GYN. I have NEVER heard one state the contrary.
Cardsnurse said:Hi,
While I have had both male and female OB/GYN docs treat me, I mostly didn't have a choice with the male. Any other area-- it wouldn't matter one iota: the best person for the job would. But in this area, I strongly prefer women. Why? well, there were a few instances in my earlier years where the actions of male dr's left me wondering...and, sorry to say, I question any male Dr going into the GYN specialty...sorry...
Cardsnurse said:Billy:
They are second hand to you, and to me, I don't even know them.
Sounds like all the males are upset by my preference, sorry!!!
UCLAMAN said:...and yes, i have had a women doctor perform a genital exam on me. and yes i would not care if my urologist in the future is a woman(in fact, northwestern sent a girl to urology last year and we have another girl going into it this year). and no, i wouldnt mind a woman urologist NOT because of some sick fantasy as you insinuate men think about.
do you think that those two girls should not be in urology? do you think that somehow they do not understand? do you think those girls chose the field so they can somehow take advantage of men?
gees...come on...whats wrong with you?
Cardsnurse said:whatever.......
to each his own
UCLAMAN said:hey...i agree with you 100%.
i am not telling you which doctor to go to. i am not telling you what to do. just don't tell ME i don't belong in this field just because i am a man.
Cardsnurse said:And with all the specialties, I wonder why a man would specialize in women's genitalia/reproductive systems.
Just safer with a woman. Men can abuse things alot-- proven fact.
O.K. So now I am curious why this burning desire to go into OB/GYN you have...Can you share some of the fascination you have?* Or is it salary? Thanks (in all sincerity)UCLAMAN said:i believe these statements are basically implying that men have no place in OB/gyn. so yes, you were not specifically telling me per se not to go into the field. but you sure are questioning my gender's integrity and desire to enter the field and implying that there isn't a place for us in it.
not attacking you...just pointing out that what you say is not a "proven fact."
my apologies for using the term "girls." perhaps i should have used "female medical students" in that post?
...hey i'm cool...thanx for the entertainment/procrastination tonight!
Cardsnurse said:O.K. So now I am curious why this burning desire to go into OB/GYN you have...Can you share some of the fascination you have?* Or is it salary? Thanks (in all sincerity)
*I have none for this area- It was the only area in nursing school I couldn't wait to get over with-- med/surg (although this is a sub-specialty area of that) has been way more interesting-- just me though. I am curious...
Cardsnurse said:I am the last person to be chauvanistic, believe me. I would take male/female/green/blue whatever for anything else. Why would I question that? 1. from my experience with a couple, shall we say, unethical dr's as a young (HMO) patient (late teens) made me 'uncomfortable' then, in being so naivbe at that age, but still remember, and now know what the deal was, 2. Have heard some Dr's talk, not impressed (just look at some of these posts) 3. Think women are waaaaaaaayy more sensitive to this area, and not a large chance of being taken advantage of, or a closet lech, 4. Some might be closet lechs (do you remember that Dr and artificial insemination- he inseminmated his own sperm, remember? just one example) 5. would, if the tables are reversed, you want a woman to be a specialist in penis/scrotal/teste issues? especially reverse that if the culture had women dominant and focused on men visually the way this culture is now. And with all the specialties, I wonder why a man would specialize in women's genitalia/reproductive systems.
Just safer with a woman. Men can abuse things alot-- proven fact.
OBfan said:With statements like this you destroy any credibilty to whatever opinion you may have. Honestly, what planet are you from?lol...geees