- Joined
- Feb 20, 2021
- Messages
- 2
- Reaction score
- 0
I’ve been working at a large law firm after graduating from a “top” law school (one of Harvard/Stanford/Yale). I originally wanted to go to law school because I really love learning how complicated systems work and was hoping that gaining specialized knowledge of the legal system would allow me to make positive difference in people’s lives. In practice, I came to feel that (a) the vast majority of the “positive differences” you can make as a lawyer are much more symbolic than practical and (b) the law isn’t really a coherent system that someone can gain “specialized knowledge” of in a meaningful way.
I had hoped that some of my concerns about the field’s awfulness would be resolved once I started practicing, but actually working in the profession has only made me even more convinced that many lawyers are in fact deeply amoral people who are totally indifferent about whether they make the world a worse place. Switching to something more "public interest"-oriented would be less revolting, but I don’t think it would resolve the deeper structural issues I have with the law. Namely, even the “good guys” don’t seem to have a great understanding of what exactly they think the legal system is supposed to be accomplishing in the first place.
I really just want to fulfill my original career goal (i.e. work on understanding complex systems in order to help people in an intellectually honest way), and I haven’t been able to think of anything other than medicine that seems to match that requirement so well. I particularly value the moral clarity that comes from being able to reduce someone’s suffering (currently going through the process of trying to donate my kidney and it’s the most enthusiastic I’ve ever been about something), but I’ve gotten the impression on here that people who want to go into medicine in order to “help people” are, like, super naïve in some way? I’m not totally clear on why this is the case—most of the complaints I've seen from disillusioned physicians seem to relate to increases in paperwork, “insufficient” pay, long hours, fear of being exposed to litigation, etc.
Anyway, I’m pretty optimistic I would enjoy the day-to-day work (well, at least a lot more than I would enjoy any other normal career), but obviously it’s a bit tricky to get meaningful shadowing opportunities right now to confirm that. At this point, I’m mainly wondering if there’s anything I’m failing to think about from a theoretical level—like, is there anything structural about the practice of medicine that should make me skeptical that I’d be able to find fulfillment here?
I had hoped that some of my concerns about the field’s awfulness would be resolved once I started practicing, but actually working in the profession has only made me even more convinced that many lawyers are in fact deeply amoral people who are totally indifferent about whether they make the world a worse place. Switching to something more "public interest"-oriented would be less revolting, but I don’t think it would resolve the deeper structural issues I have with the law. Namely, even the “good guys” don’t seem to have a great understanding of what exactly they think the legal system is supposed to be accomplishing in the first place.
I really just want to fulfill my original career goal (i.e. work on understanding complex systems in order to help people in an intellectually honest way), and I haven’t been able to think of anything other than medicine that seems to match that requirement so well. I particularly value the moral clarity that comes from being able to reduce someone’s suffering (currently going through the process of trying to donate my kidney and it’s the most enthusiastic I’ve ever been about something), but I’ve gotten the impression on here that people who want to go into medicine in order to “help people” are, like, super naïve in some way? I’m not totally clear on why this is the case—most of the complaints I've seen from disillusioned physicians seem to relate to increases in paperwork, “insufficient” pay, long hours, fear of being exposed to litigation, etc.
Anyway, I’m pretty optimistic I would enjoy the day-to-day work (well, at least a lot more than I would enjoy any other normal career), but obviously it’s a bit tricky to get meaningful shadowing opportunities right now to confirm that. At this point, I’m mainly wondering if there’s anything I’m failing to think about from a theoretical level—like, is there anything structural about the practice of medicine that should make me skeptical that I’d be able to find fulfillment here?
Last edited: