Europeman,
I am a surgery resident. PGY-5
We put in a lot of lines. I don't know how many at this point. I would estimate >500. Who knows and who cares.
See my post about a neck hematoma not causing a problem in an intubated patient. I agree with you on that.
In an unintubated patient a neck hematoma can be a problem. Again, hasn't happened to be me, but has happened to 2 people I know who were solid residents using u/s in difficult necks. I doubt it was from vein. I suspect there was some sort unrecognized carotid stick, the lines were in the vein, The carotid wasn't dilated. No big hematoma at time of placement. Then 30 min to an hour later patient has unstable airway and dies. Even if it doesn't cause a problem you're gonna be pretty nervous for a while.
They didn't open up the neck hematoma in either case, but I think this is going to be easier said than done, as opposed to bleeding from a carotid endarectomy or thyroidectomy where you can just cut the suture line and the deep space is open. This is going to be an epic flail if the patient survives.
I think you guys are overstating the risk of an rp bleed. Again if you stick the groin in the right place the risk of rp bleed is essentially 0, you'll get a thigh or groin hematoma, and teh artery and vein are compressible. If for some reason you stick femoral artery and it bleeds into the rp that isn't that hard to control surgically, You have a small hole in the femoral arery in the groin. The rp hematoma you can't cotnrol surgically are spontaneous ones from lumbars and such. Besides they almost all stop and tamponade off as soon as coagulopathy is corrected. In the mean time the bleeding would be slow and you could keep up with transfusions...... and you're not slashing somebodies neck open at bedside. I say would and could cause, again I can't remember this happening from a cvc, I'm sure it has, but most of the time I've seen after a cardiac cath where where there was a dilator in the artery or it's spontaneous. If you want to talk about uncontrollable the perforation of the L IJ/ SCV confluence via a dilator would be much worse.
Whoever said femorals had a 3-4 higher infection rate than IJ's. That's just not true
Ann Intern Med. 2012 Nov 20;157(10):JC5-8. doi: 10.7326/0003-4819-157-10-201211200-02008.
Review: Femoral and subclavian or internal jugular venous catheters do not differ for bloodstream infections.
Whalen F.
That being said. If the patient described above had a normal iNR and didn't have hostile neck anatomy, I'd put in the IJ, but again I think a femoral line is an reasonable choice in an unintubated or squirrelly supercoagulopathic patient