Well I can certainly say I'm surprised by the responses in this thread, in a psychiatry sub-forum no less.
I am absolutely glad she's been found not guilty. If anyone deserves to be sitting it jail, it's her former husband. His criminal negligence is appalling. He forced his obviously disturbed wife off the Haldol during her pregnancy with her last child, pushed her into having more kids despite her own hesitance and knowing it wouldn't be an intelligent decision considering the multiple bouts of PPD she experienced with her earlier children, and yet he still left their children in the care of an openly suicidal, schizophrenic mother. It's worth noting her father died just a few months earlier so the emotional effects of that must also must be taken into consideration. Oh, and he forced her to live on a bloody bus. With five kids. Give me a break.
Even her own psychiatrist told her to think positively about 'happy' things just days before the murders. I'm speechless about that one.
I can agree that her method of action was well thought out and carefully planned, but that doesn't mean insanity still can't be the underlying issue here. She thought she was saving her kids' souls. She was planning on killing herself because she was convinced she was going to hell anyway, but she wanted to ensure her children were going to heaven. She was hearing things and seeing things. She was psychotic in the very real sense of the word. In her mind, what she was doing was the
right thing to do because it was the only option that would save her kids (check out the legal definition of insanity). There was reasoning behind her actions, as crazy as that reasoning was.
I don't understand why many seem to think a life spent institutionalized is some sort of break from prison. It's hardly a pleasant life. Plus, being found not guilty by reason of insanity basically means no chance of parole/release, and no chance of appeal for a lighter sentence. She will most likely be institutionalized for life.
At the end of the day, this case just illustrates how mismanaged her care was (which is also the case for many others who are mentally is), as well as how much progress needs to be made not only in producing competent psychiatrists and similar professionals, but also in informing the general public about mental illness.
My money is on schizophrenia, and PPD with the resulting psychosis. This definitely isn't BPD
or BP.