- Joined
- Apr 3, 2006
- Messages
- 520
- Reaction score
- 26
How is the job market for internists who do a 2 year fellowship in CC? Especially if they want the majority of their practice to be ICU shift work type of arrangement.
How is the job market for internists who do a 2 year fellowship in CC? Especially if they want the majority of their practice to be ICU shift work type of arrangement.
Doing a Pulm-CC fellowship makes you more marketable from what I hear which translates into more job opportunities. This is mainly since you can truly be a part of the group and share in all the calls. There are some job openings out there for strictly intensivists but they are a bit more few and far between. Who you know is going to be key.I don't mean to hijack the forum, but I thought this would be a relevant question: is there an avantage technically in doing a P/CCM over a two year CCM program? It may be premature for me to consider this, but right now it's what am interested in: IM and CCM, I don't want to bother with pulmonary but it seems the most conventional way to go through IM to CCM. I was wondering anyone's thoughts on this, preferably residents, fellows, and attendings.
Doing a Pulm-CC fellowship makes you more marketable from what I hear which translates into more job opportunities. This is mainly since you can truly be a part of the group and share in all the calls. There are some job openings out there for strictly intensivists but they are a bit more few and far between. Who you know is going to be key.
I am thinking about doing a critical care fellowship after my residency but I am doing very thorough research on practice patterns and demand for my desired areas before I commit. I am aware of a few ID and Nephro fellows who are doing 1 year CC fellowships after their original IM-subspecialty training which will be very marketable for them. Seems to me that if you are not Pulm-CC then you need to have something that will appeal to a Pulm-CC dominant group (private>academia) since you won't be able to do Pulm consults/clinic. If you are strictly IM-CC then maybe something like ECMO, TEE skills, still being able to Bronch, etc would be my guess but I am still looking into it so take it with a grain of salt.
Perhaps JDH or one of the other Pulm-CC experts will comment.
The reason being is that I'm interested in primary care as well, which is what I would hope to do when I'm not in the ICU. As I understand it, few dedicate their entire practice to CCM for burnout reasons. With this being said, instead of falling back doing pulmonary clinic, I would return to my primary care patients. This is the reason I'm adverse to pulmonary; because I'm not interested in practicing it at all outside of the ICU, so I don't see it economically viable to spend the extra time for it.
I suppose I could go a step further and say (without knowing exactly how this works) if a patient of mine is hospitalized, then I can round on them on the general medicine floor and follow them to the ICU if needed. Of course, this depends on many things such as hospital privileges, institutional policies, open vs closes ICUs, etc. But I can dream.
Would you care to elaborate? I would love the input.
It's like say IM/EM guys, it's ungodly rare to see someone actually do IM, often time due to the salary discrepancies. After working ICU, the last thing I want to deal with is the bull**** insurance companies and bogus complaints and pain seekers for a pittance. Then the next question is, who is going to cover your primary care office when your in the office? You can't run away from a code to see a sick visit, or push off doing a procedure to do a pap. If you're n the ICU, you need to be in the ICU. Then the next question is, who's going to hire you? There is a massive shortage of CC docs, many don't need a primary care intensivist. Then if you're doing the old school IM, where you have office, in pts, and even cover your ICU pts, good luck with that life style, you're pager will..... never ......stop.........
Re anesthisia, you like pay cuts? As you will make less as a gas-icu doc. Than as gas doc. So some work in MICU? Yes. It in theory, it's possible, but I'm theory America can still put a man on the moon.
One of our hospitalists is IM/CC trained and so he sees a combo of regular floor pts as well as ICU pts. The other hospitalists on the group are strictly IM. At least here they're still allowed to manage pts in the ICU but will transfer to the IM/CC guy if they are vented or truly require CC.... procedures, bronch, etc...
That of course will vary on the hospital/ ICU policies and the hospitalist group.
Ultimately I guess he could give up the CC portion and just do IM work, but honestly, between the social work aspect/headaches of a general floor pt, I'm not sure that's much less stressful than his typical ICU duties...
That's a really helpful sentiment. Do you have any idea what kind of pts the IM/CC doc manages in the ICU?
That's a really helpful sentiment. Do you have any idea what kind of pts the IM/CC doc manages in the ICU?
On a relative tangent, it's interesting. I was looking at Pitt's CCM fellowships websites and comparing the sample rotations between the IM pathway and anesthesia and it seems that anesthesia's training is geared strictly toward the surgical patient; this makes sense. However conversely, the IM fellows seem to rotate in both the medical and surgical ICUs. Granted, the surgical patients IM manages are primarily transplant pts, but I believe I saw a trauma/SICU rotation on there, too. This seems to echo a lot of what I read on here: IM/CC (and pulmonary) seem to manage both pts populations more than anesthesia (whom focuses primarily on surgical pts). Do I have the right idea here? Someone please correct me if I'm wrong.
I don't think I would use Pitt's CCM program or the IM-CCM 'rotation schedule' as a represetative of "typical" of IM-based CCM fellowships...
HH
It's like say IM/EM guys, it's ungodly rare to see someone actually do IM, often time due to the salary discrepancies. After working ICU, the last thing I want to deal with is the bull**** insurance companies and bogus complaints and pain seekers for a pittance. Then the next question is, who is going to cover your primary care office when your in the office? You can't run away from a code to see a sick visit, or push off doing a procedure to do a pap. If you're n the ICU, you need to be in the ICU. Then the next question is, who's going to hire you? There is a massive shortage of CC docs, many don't need a primary care intensivist. Then if you're doing the old school IM, where you have office, in pts, and even cover your ICU pts, good luck with that life style, you're pager will..... never ......stop.........
As I last remember from applying to fellowship, you can apply for CCM fellowship through ERAS, but there is no match. So you can get offers well before match day. You may even get an offer after your first interview.
As far as working as a hospitalist and covering ICU beds. This is more practical in smaller hospitals with lower acuity patients, where the ICU demands are less. There is a skill set you need to acquire to take care of higher acuity patients, such therapeutic bronchoscopy, chest tube placement, DIFFICULT airway management in addition to standard airway management, management of advance ventilator modes, and temporary pacemaker insertion and management.
Certainly there are institution where you can outsource many of these procedures and tasks to consultants, but the ability to perform these skills competently is among the many other prerequisites of what makes an intensivist.
Intensivist pay varies widely. There are some places where intensivists are paid less than hospitalist. In general, ICU billing is a high level of billing and a busy unit with more complex patients and procedure will lead to higher RVUs and higher billing overall. Hence, you will make more money if your contract is set up such as way where you benefit from productivity. This is a job you will find in a private practice physician group model.
If you are looking for salary pay, you are looking at a starting base salary starting as low as $210,000 academic centers, In community hospitals starting ranges from $230,000-280,000. However that is base pay, many jobs offer productivity incentives. I found one academic non-tenure track clinical instructor job where base salary was $230,000, with RVU bonuses over $50,000 for productivity. This was in a very major city. On the flip side, I found an academic job in the same city that paid a base of $180,000, with some billing incentives that is spilt among the physician group, and a $10,000 sign on bonus. That job was a nocturnal job, but in a mostly supervisory role over the fellows. None of these academic jobs were 7 on and off, there were 7 on in the ICU, and the off days where administrative.
Community jobs are better if you think about it as an hourly or "shift" wage. I found a community job, also in a very major city, that paid on the order of $1700 a 12hr shift, for a minumum of 15 shifts a month. That comes out to $306,000 a year. If you work more you get paid more. But not billing incentives.
There are lots of jobs out there. The burn out in ICU medicine is similar to the burnout faced by EM and Hospitalist. Hence why people do pulmonary as well. Jobs in Renal/CC and ID/CC are exceedingly rare, and difficult to find a scenario where you get to do both specialties. Pulmonary as I said in my last post is a harder job overall. There are fewer true off days, but you do have the back-up of have a pulmoanry practice to fall back on if you get tired of the ICU.
Feel free to email or IM if you have any other questions.
Best if luck to you Bostonredsox! The demand for CCM is definitely high, and I foresee a healthy job market in the coming years. A few general tips, during my own job search I was asked at each interview what procedures I knew and what my numbers were. I was also asked if I knew more advanced procedures such as percutaneous tracheostomy or any advanced bronchoscope modalities. My point is, the more things you know how to do, the more marketable you are as an intensivist. So in that one year you do fellowship, crank up your procedural numbers like crazy, ESPECIALLY for intubations! Also certifying in Echo and bedside ultrasound is the future of this field, and something you should seriously consider. The ACCP has an excellent albeit expensive process to certify in ultrasound. Goodluck!
The ACCP has an excellent albeit expensive process to certify in ultrasound. Goodluck!
. I see that it offers additional certificates in bronchoscopy, vent management, and airway management. Aren't those things that any intensivist should know how to do anyway?
You're intensivists are comfortable with all difficult airway technique and do EBUS/TBNA in the ICU?
And there is vent management and there is vent management. Not every intensivist is the same.
Some of the intensivists I've work with indeed do not handle difficult airways, but they should learn how. Anesthesiologists aren't in the building 24 hours a day if something goes wrong. As far as the bronchoscopy certificate is concerned, I see that you can learn Endobronchial Ultrasound in just 2 days. My friends who went into pulmonary have been wasting their time. I also see that ACCP is developing a Critical Care Management certificate