USMLE Why ketogenic diet is contraindicate with porphyria and pyruvate carboxylase deficiency

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

pzh200707

Full Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Aug 8, 2015
Messages
18
Reaction score
2
any idea?

Members don't see this ad.
 
Some organs in the body can not utilize ketone bodies for energy. Examples include RBC's and the liver. Therefore, it is essential that glucose levels are maintained even if there is a high level of ketone bodies.

Pyruvate carboxylase is an enzyme needed for gluconeogenesis. If someone has pyruvate carboxylase deficiency, they mostly rely on carbohydrate intake to maintain glucose levels. On a ketogenic diet, glucose levels are maintained mostly by gluconeogenesis from proteins, since the carb intake is minimal. Therefore, if someone who has pyruvate carboxylase deficiency goes on a ketogenic diet, they will likely have low levels of glucose due to the lack of gluconeogenesis and lack of carb intake.

I am a little less clear about the contraindication in porphyria. What I do know is that glucose is an inhibitor of the first step in heme synthesis (which is ALA synthase converting succinyl CoA and glycine to ALA), and that we typically give glucose to patients with acute intermittent porphyria to inhibit the production of the porphobilinogen (an intermediate in the heme synthesis pathway, and the causative agent of the symptoms in acute intermittent porphyria). Patients on a ketogenic diet generally have a lower glucose level than they would have if off the diet, although their glucose level is still within normal limits. I presume that this relative lowering of glucose can disinhibit ALA synthase, and thus make it more likely to develop the symptoms of porphyria.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
Some organs in the body can not utilize ketone bodies for energy. Examples include RBC's and the liver. Therefore, it is essential that glucose levels are maintained even if there is a high level of ketone bodies.

Pyruvate carboxylase is an enzyme needed for gluconeogenesis. If someone has pyruvate carboxylase deficiency, they mostly rely on carbohydrate intake to maintain glucose levels. On a ketogenic diet, glucose levels are maintained mostly by gluconeogenesis from proteins, since the carb intake is minimal. Therefore, if someone who has pyruvate carboxylase deficiency goes on a ketogenic diet, they will likely have low levels of glucose due to the lack of gluconeogenesis and lack of carb intake.

I am a little less clear about the contraindication in porphyria. What I do know is that glucose is an inhibitor of the first step in heme synthesis (which is ALA synthase converting succinyl CoA and glycine to ALA), and that we typically give glucose to patients with acute intermittent porphyria to inhibit the production of the porphobilinogen (an intermediate in the heme synthesis pathway, and the causative agent of the symptoms in acute intermittent porphyria). Patients on a ketogenic diet generally have a lower glucose level than they would have if off the diet, although their glucose level is still within normal limits. I presume that this relative lowering of glucose can disinhibit ALA synthase, and thus make it more likely to develop the symptoms of porphyria.

Excellent answer! thanks
 
Top