Specialization after MD /mbbs durations

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Apollosiris1

Full Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
May 14, 2015
Messages
16
Reaction score
1
Ok, so as far as I know, after completing MD, you go for a specialisation (post grad iswhat they call it I guess, I'm sorry, not very familiar with the system in the US), but in the US, specializations like orthopaedic surgery take a good 6 years, while in India after mbbs about 3-3.5 years. What is the difference in the course that makes the length vary so greatly.
Thank you :)

Members don't see this ad.
 
You can't practice medicine in US as mbbs. The only recognized medical degrees in US are MD and DO.

There is no degree similar to mbbs in US.

One of the difference is that in US, medical school is AFTER bachelors degree (4yrs) while in India, you can go to medical school right out of high school.

The difference in specialty years is a result of a more rounded, in depth, higher standards and for all intensive purposes, better training.
 
You can't practice medicine in US as mbbs. The only recognized medical degrees in US are MD and DO.

There is no degree similar to mbbs in US.
Sorry this is inaccurate.

As the holder of an MBBS degree, I can verify you can certainly practice in the US without a DO or MD. The degree, along with the BMBS, MBChB, MC BCh, BMed, are recognized as equivalent and are not a barrier to training or working in the US.

If you have any professors educated in the UK, South Africa, Australia, Singapore, India, Pakistan, etc. they likely hold an MBBS or one of the other degrees above. In many countries, the MD is a research degree, awarded after a certain period of time in practice and completion of a research dissertation (akin to a PhD).

The difference in specialty years is a result of a more rounded, in depth, higher standards and for all INTENTS AND purposes, better training.

In regards to why the post graduate training is different in length may be related to the fact that many countries require "Foundation Years" or general medicine training after medical school before applying for specialization; the training may be less intense or lesser in quality but we are not in a position to judge that. Of note, the Medical Council of India has recently suggested that Orthopedic training encompassing the breadth of the field, needs to increase in length, perhaps to the same length required in the US, and the UK.

Finally, the US does not have sole ownership of quality medical training or care. It is naive to assume so.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 6 users
Members don't see this ad :)
The fact that you're not in india
 
Sorry this is inaccurate.

As the holder of an MBBS degree, I can verify you can certainly practice in the US without a DO or MD. The degree, along with the BMBS, MBChB, MC BCh, BMed, are recognized as equivalent and are not a barrier to training or working in the US.

If you have any professors educated in the UK, South Africa, Australia, Singapore, India, Pakistan, etc. they likely hold an MBBS or one of the other degrees above. In many countries, the MD is a research degree, awarded after a certain period of time in practice and completion of a research dissertation (akin to a PhD).



In regards to why the post graduate training is different in length may be related to the fact that many countries require "Foundation Years" or general medicine training after medical school before applying for specialization; the training may be less intense or lesser in quality but we are not in a position to judge that. Of note, the Medical Council of India has recently suggested that Orthopedic training encompassing the breadth of the field, needs to increase in length, perhaps to the same length required in the US, and the UK.

Finally, the US does not have sole ownership of quality medical training or care. It is naive to assume so.

Oh, very helpful thank you. And yes, assuming monopoly of America in medicine is naive, but it is also considered as one of the top destinations for studying and practicing the same.

Ps are you Indian? You seem to have a lot of knowledge about India and the US at the same time, so you could probably give your experience in India as a doctor, that is if you are from India :p
 
Oh, very helpful thank you. And yes, assuming monopoly of America in medicine is naive, but it is also considered as one of the top destinations for studying and practicing the same.

Ps are you Indian? You seem to have a lot of knowledge about India and the US at the same time, so you could probably give your experience in India as a doctor, that is if you are from India :p
Is she Indian? No.
A cougar? Yes.
 
Oh, very helpful thank you. And yes, assuming monopoly of America in medicine is naive, but it is also considered as one of the top destinations for studying and practicing the same.

Ps are you Indian? You seem to have a lot of knowledge about India and the US at the same time, so you could probably give your experience in India as a doctor, that is if you are from India :p
No, not Indian just have some knowledge about things outside the U.S.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Top