COMs Establishing New Residency Programs

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
As WCU student our dean sent out an email detailing our match stats. While we did have a few peeps get into some competitive AOa spots GS, Ortho and EM, most were scramble/ soap into PC. It was a very high rate of Primary care.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
Really? A majority went unmatched and had to scramble/SOAP?

Sent from my SM-G930V using SDN mobile

Members don't see this ad.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Members don't see this ad :)
My point is that residencies have always been increasing to mimic population growth. At a very consistent rate. The production of new residency programs by COMs is just a part of that natural growth. There will be no sudden explosion is residency programs like we see in medical schools unless the government changes their funding. The small consistent increase in GME does not affect job markets because it is so small, and it doesn't really change from year to year. The oversaturated markets are that way because they are highly desirable areas that lots of people want to live in, not because of GME growth.
Lol Don't you know that the sky is always falling on SDN?

Sent from my SM-G950U using SDN mobile
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
As WCU student our dean sent out an email detailing our match stats. While we did have a few peeps get into some competitive AOa spots GS, Ortho and EM, many were scramble/ soap into PC. It was a very high rate of Primary care.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
Is WCU the school that had a 92.5% placmeent rate?
 
Is WCU the school that had a 92.5% placmeent rate?
Honestly it is impossible to tell. We had a lot of people not match and quite a few failed to soap about 14. Most rescrambled into or were “placed” into TRIs. However as of now 4 do not have residencies and around the time those numbers came out it was 6 or 7. So yes it is most likely us, but I cant confirm this to be sure but the numbers seem to line up. Class size was about 96 ish. Of the remaining 4 they may not meet qualifications to be placed and thus maybe dismissed or repeat the year and I am not sure how COCA looks at this. It could be after graduation these 4 are dismissed and the placement rate will be 100% thus meet COCA standards.

It is a huge embarrassment for myself and many of us that our numbers even approached this level. Administration is in denial about it but seems to be tightening the leaches on the incoming 1st and 2nd year classes. The school has been having trouble filling the 1st year class for two years now and a public sanction from COCA would make this worse.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
1) to assist OP, ACOM has opened i think a 12 resident IM program at the mother hospital SAMC, and plans for 2018 IM in North AL are in the works (but this is associated with a core site and may not be directly from ACOM)

2) It sounds like the 92% match SOM is indeed WC. As bad as that 92% match is, it's equally horrible that 1 in 4 students had to go through the beast which is the SOAP/scramble. I was fortunate to match om match day but my friends who shared their experience say it was a terrifyingly awful experience.

COCA needs to step in. Any school with a match below 98% average makes me uneasy, but below 95% is just wrong.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Update on CUSOM GME development since opening the school. All programs located in NC.

ACGME accredited programs:
1. Dermatology
2. EM x 2
3. OB/GYN
4. Psychiatry
5. IM x 3
6. FM x 2
7. TRI x 2

AOA accredited, transitioning to ACGME
1. General Surgery
2. FM
3. Primary care sports medicine fellowship

Planned/in development
1. Most IM fellowships
2. Several surgical subspecialties
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5 users
Honestly it is impossible to tell. We had a lot of people not match and quite a few failed to soap about 14. Most rescrambled into or were “placed” into TRIs. However as of now 4 do not have residencies and around the time those numbers came out it was 6 or 7. So yes it is most likely us, but I cant confirm this to be sure but the numbers seem to line up. Class size was about 96 ish. Of the remaining 4 they may not meet qualifications to be placed and thus maybe dismissed or repeat the year and I am not sure how COCA looks at this. It could be after graduation these 4 are dismissed and the placement rate will be 100% thus meet COCA standards.

It is a huge embarrassment for myself and many of us that our numbers even approached this level. Administration is in denial about it but seems to be tightening the leaches on the incoming 1st and 2nd year classes. The school has been having trouble filling the 1st year class for two years now and a public sanction from COCA would make this worse.

Wow. A class size of only 96. I was thinking that it was 14 that didn't match in a class size >200. This is why each COM should be required to create a 1-for-1 student to residency position, and not be allowed to operate until this sanction is met.
 
Wow. A class size of only 96. I was thinking that it was 14 that didn't match in a class size >200. This is why each COM should be required to create a 1-for-1 student to residency position, and not be allowed to operate until this sanction is met.
Also, I think due to the high attrition rate at WCU the class size shrunk to 96 from probably ~120 or so that started.

Sent from my SM-G950U using SDN mobile
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Also, I think due to the high attrition rate at WCU the class size shrunk to 96 from probably ~120 or so that started.

Sent from my SM-G950U using SDN mobile
...Double Wow. That's not helping their case at all. That's starting to approach Caribbean levels.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
...Double Wow. That's not helping their case at all. That's starting to approach Caribbean levels.
Yep, and couple that with low COMLEX first time pass rate... That's why they are tightening the rules for their 1st and 2nd year classes.

Sent from my SM-G950U using SDN mobile
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
So if 14 didn’t match, and you started with a class of 120, that’s a success rate of 68%......that is truly horrifying.

I’ve said it before, the crunch will come silently in the number of students who don’t even make it to match day. For the Caribbean, SDN makes sure premeds understand it’s not the match rate they show, but the start to finish numbers that needs scrutiny. If walking onto campus you have a 68% of becoming a practicing physician, I don’t see how this school is any better than the Caribbean.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 users
Wow. A class size of only 96. I was thinking that it was 14 that didn't match in a class size >200. This is why each COM should be required to create a 1-for-1 student to residency position, and not be allowed to operate until this sanction is met.
Thats what is left. The class started at 120 ish. Lost about 10 every year.
Our class was around 116 we are around 94. Attrition rate is pretty high.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
So if 14 didn’t match, and you started with a class of 120, that’s a success rate of 68%......that is truly horrifying.

I’ve said it before, the crunch will come silently in the number of students who don’t even make it to match day. For the Caribbean, SDN makes sure premeds understand it’s not the match rate they show, but the start to finish numbers that needs scrutiny. If walking onto campus you have a 68% of becoming a practicing physician, I don’t see how this school is any better than the Caribbean.
Too bad COCA doesn’t measure success rates.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
That sounds like us. We started with 118, and are graduating 90. If 4+ are unplaced, that's about right. My classes COMLEX 1 pass rate was terrible, but COMLEX 2 score went up 40 points. I think our PE percentage went down. I know at least 1 that lost their residency spot due to a PE failure and 1 was scrambling to find one after passing the second time.
The last email we got in March from admin said they were still trying to secure spots and we would know something soon.

Graduating on the construction site is gonna be real interesting this year.
 
That sounds like us. We started with 118, and are graduating 90. If 4+ are unplaced, that's about right. My classes COMLEX 1 pass rate was terrible, but COMLEX 2 score went up 40 points. I think our PE percentage went down. I know at least 1 that lost their residency spot due to a PE failure and 1 was scrambling to find one after passing the second time.
The last email we got in March from admin said they were still trying to secure spots and we would know something soon.

Graduating on the construction site is gonna be real interesting this year.

Yeah I was hoping i was wrong but I have had other sources confirm that it is us. It is super doubtful COCA will take any real action. Super embarrassing. No only that back on the WCUCOM forum people are chatting up the school ignoring this kind of stuff. 92% placement rate was something I would have avoided a school over now I just cant believe it... blows me away
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Yeah I was hoping i was wrong but I have had other sources confirm that it is us. It is super doubtful COCA will take any real action. Super embarrassing. No only that back on the WCUCOM forum people are chatting up the school ignoring this kind of stuff. 92% placement rate was something I would have avoided a school over now I just cant believe it... blows me away

Would you say though is this because of the school or the students?
 
Would you say though is this because of the school or the students?
The school has had a reputation for malignancy for a while now. I think its not the students IMO.
 
The school has had a reputation for malignancy for a while now. I think its not the students IMO.

I just wonder because from all the info I gather, COMLEX doesn’t seem to be hard to pass and there’s still open residencies on the AOA side. So kinda confused why these students can’t get in unless they have some malignancy on their app
 
I just wonder because from all the info I gather, COMLEX doesn’t seem to be hard to pass and there’s still open residencies on the AOA side. So kinda confused why these students can’t get in unless they have some malignancy on their app
Anything can be hard to pass if you are not given adequate time to prepare. WCU requires mandatory attendance and is a 40 hour a week school from what I remember when I looked at it. Not sure on board prep time, but I would bet it was short. They had professors arguing with students on SDN in either the 2013 or 2014 thread from what I recall. It was bad, very very arrogant faculty.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
WCU was the only school that didn’t accept my DO LOR since they uploaded it to interfolio with a digital signature. I’m glad I crossed them off my list after that.

Overall, I think WCU’s struggles are a result of the school and not the students. It’s sad to watch our colleagues fail to succeed while the regulating bodies just watch. At the very least, sanctioning the school might deter “investors” from founding new schools without a plan to create GME and support their students.

That being said, some of the newer schools seem to be doing fairly well. Some are opening up more residency spots than the branch campuses of the “established schools.” They also have pretty low attrition if the numbers someone posted in another thread are correct.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Anything can be hard to pass if you are not given adequate time to prepare. WCU requires mandatory attendance and is a 40 hour a week school from what I remember when I looked at it. Not sure on board prep time, but I would bet it was short. They had professors arguing with students on SDN in either the 2013 or 2014 thread from what I recall. It was bad, very very arrogant faculty.

It was maybe 6 weeks, if memory serves me. @WorldChanger36 can chime in better than I can, but I believe COMLEX scores went up for their class due to the post-tornado suspension of the mandatory attendance policy.
 
It was maybe 6 weeks, if memory serves me. @WorldChanger36 can chime in better than I can, but I believe COMLEX scores went up for their class due to the post-tornado suspension of the mandatory attendance policy.
While true we did have that post tornado benefit the school added extra stuff and other requirements that slowed us down. All in all we had relatively sinilar prep timing and our scores just barely edged out your class. We were still 10 points below national average, although we had less failures, we had a more normal median. We had more high scorers but not as high as your class mostly mid 600 with our averages being in the low 500. We also had the same number of people take USMLE and I believe we were the first class to have a failure on that.

We on had about 5 to 6 weeks of dedicated study prep time. Some had 2 weeks and some like myself had about 8 due to luck. It was difficult, the school does a great job at getting in your way thinking they were helping.
 
It was maybe 6 weeks, if memory serves me. @WorldChanger36 can chime in better than I can, but I believe COMLEX scores went up for their class due to the post-tornado suspension of the mandatory attendance policy.
6 weeks of actual dedicated or dedicated with required mandatory activities during it?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
While true we did have that post tornado benefit the school added extra stuff and other requirements that slowed us down. All in all we had relatively sinilar prep timing and our scores just barely edged out your class. We were still 10 points below national average, although we had less failures, we had a more normal median. We had more high scorers but not as high as your class mostly mid 600 with our averages being in the low 500. We also had the same number of people take USMLE and I believe we were the first class to have a failure on that.

We on had about 5 to 6 weeks of dedicated study prep time. Some had 2 weeks and some like myself had about 8 due to luck. It was difficult, the school does a great job at getting in your way thinking they were helping.

Hopefully your administration let you know that the average COMLEX Level 1 score this year is about 40 points higher than it has been in the last few years (final average is 557.89). Every school SHOULD have went up SIGNIFICANTLY. I noticed on SDN a lot of students reporting how well their class did on Level 1 compared to previous years oblivious to the fact that there was some sort of inflation this year that resulted in record high averages. If you are trying to compare to previous years, you need to subtract about 40 points.
 
Nothing crazy, but here are the residencies for UIWSOM (they are in San Antonio and Laredo)-

Currently AOA accredited, initial accreditation ACGME:
Family Medicine- 16/16/16
Internal Medicine- 8/8/8

In Development (July 2019 estimated launch):
Psychiatry
Internal Medicine
Preventative Medicine

When I interviewed, they said they were working with a large hospital system in SA for multiple residencies, but I heard that fell through unfortunately (probably because of the merger). I do know the Associate Dean for Graduate Medical Education came from RVU and helped develop multiple programs there, so hopefully he will do the same in SA.
 
6 weeks of actual dedicated or dedicated with required mandatory activities during it?
I want to say there were a couple of required activities. COMSAE was at the end of May. BLS/ACLS/PALS come to mind, and we came back to campus sometime in July for 3rd year orientation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Nothing crazy, but here are the residencies for UIWSOM (they are in San Antonio and Laredo)-

Currently AOA accredited, initial accreditation ACGME:
Family Medicine- 16/16/16
Internal Medicine- 8/8/8

In Development (July 2019 estimated launch):
Psychiatry
Internal Medicine
Preventative Medicine

When I interviewed, they said they were working with a large hospital system in SA for multiple residencies, but I heard that fell through unfortunately (probably because of the merger). I do know the Associate Dean for Graduate Medical Education came from RVU and helped develop multiple programs there, so hopefully he will do the same in SA.

Their Psych program is approved now!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Top