Answering Questions - Recent Neurosurgery Graduate

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Thanks again for doing this!

I'm a fourth year who will be applying to neurosurgery residencies this fall. You mentioned a few times that you had a family during residency, as somebody who is married and will be having kids during residency are there any specific things I should look for in a residency? Also, if you were applying to residency again, what features would you seek out in a residency (assuming that at this point I am hoping to go into academics)?

While I'm sure there is a lot of variability, do you know what a normal schedule for a junior faculty member is in academics? It seems like there is a lot of flexibility in private practice to find a setup that meets your goals/interests. I'm guessing that this is not as true for academics, but would love to hear your perspectives. Thanks!

There are a lot of things that you can look for in a residency such as subspecialty opportunities, work hour rules, pass rate of boards, relationship between attendings and residents, and location of residency. In my opinion, how happy you will be during residency is much more important than prestige of the program. Your family should be most important and I fully believe that your satisfaction during residency is a greater factor in determining how great a neurosurgeon you will become. You will get great training in almost all neurosurgery programs. There are many programs that are known for being family friendly (ex. Barrows, Mayo, UVA, Yale). You will find some programs in which over half the residents are married and may have children.

I'm not too knowledgeable on typical junior academic schedules, but I can vouch that schedules are generally less flexible, especially at trauma centers.

How long until we have brain transplants?

With humans!? A very long time, definitely not during my career. We do not yet have the ability to properly reattach the spinal chord, so any patient undergoing the surgery would end up being a quadriplegic. I have heard about partial-brain transplants in the future, involving tissue samples.

I understand that if one wants to pursue research, academic institutions are the way to go. But is it possible to be in private practice and still do research? How would that work?

Actually it is possible. Not common, but possible. My group owns a spine center in which research is done. Additionally, some job opportunities I've seen state that they are private practice, but have research opportunities.

Members don't see this ad.
 
There are many programs that are known for being family friendly (ex. Barrows, Mayo, UVA, Yale).

Could you just briefly expand on this? What makes programs like these more family friendly than others?
 
How different and similar are the procedures in adult and pediatric cases? What are the pros and cons in both (money/mortality/morbidity/malpractice frequency/lifestyle/all other aspects)?

I have seen a lot of shows in pediatric neurosurgery and cases involving congenital defects seemed very intriguing.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
First of all, I would like to thank you for taking the time to educate us about such a special field.

I have three questions:

1. How do you describe your typical day in office? many consults? post-op follow-ups?

2. How often do you perform complex, lengthy procedures? and do you operate on kids?

3. How often do you work with other specialists such neurologists, ENT's, Radiologists...etc?

Thank you,
 
I have to say, it's encouraging to know that a reasonable lifestyle in achievable as a neurosurg attending. I've never shadowed a neurosurgeon (would love to) and don't have any exposure to the field, but I've always been so scared by the prospect of a seemingly-endless, grueling, possibly marriage-wrecking residency that I wouldn't even consider it.

Assuming an "average" marriage relationship, am I being unreasonable in my fear of the neurosurg residency? I feel like I can deal with hard work for whatever length of time if I love it (and I wouldn't choose any field without loving it) but I don't know if it would be worth it to risk losing someone I love.

Thanks a bunch for taking the time to answer questions here. :)
 
Could you just briefly expand on this? What makes programs like these more family friendly than others?

Uh several different things including slightly fewer hours worked (on average), many residents have children (so similar mindset), and location (family friendly setting/environment).

How different and similar are the procedures in adult and pediatric cases? What are the pros and cons in both (money/mortality/morbidity/malpractice frequency/lifestyle/all other aspects)?

I have seen a lot of shows in pediatric neurosurgery and cases involving congenital defects seemed very intriguing.

Honestly, our group does not handle pediatric cases. Many neurosurgeons are not comfortable doing pediatric cases without a fellowship. Additionally, hospital staff (ICU, anesthesiologists, etc.) are also uncomfortable without proper specialization and experience. To handle such cases you generally need a full team (pediatric anesthesiologist, pediatric neurosurgeon, etc.) which many hospitals do not have access to. These cases are usually sent out to the state large academic center. As for lifestyle and money, positions are usually academic (so less pay) and hours are usually more unpredictable. I personally could do pediatric cases, but the hospital would prefer that my group and I not take these cases.

But yeah, pediatric neurosurgery cases are really intriguing and if you are interested, don't worry too much about lifestyle and money because these can be adjusted. Outcomes are fairly good. Malpractice is constantly changing, but as a neurosurgeon you will get sued. It's really not a big deal. Many neurosurgeons get sued multiple times per year, but you will very rarely lose a case. Mistakes happen. You're human.
Just do your best and act in the best interest of the patient and you shouldn't have to worry about malpractice.

First of all, I would like to thank you for taking the time to educate us about such a special field.

I have three questions:

1. How do you describe your typical day in office? many consults? post-op follow-ups?

2. How often do you perform complex, lengthy procedures? and do you operate on kids?

3. How often do you work with other specialists such neurologists, ENT's, Radiologists...etc?

Thank you,

1. Clinic is generally pretty busy. Today I had to finish up a surgery so I arrived late to clinic (around 2:30). Finished up around 4:30 and saw a total of 9 patients. It just depends.

2. There are a good deal of complex procedures, but they are not all necessarily lengthy. Some procedures (I kid you not) I can do in 8-15 minutes. Average cases are 2-3 hours, with the occasional 4-5 hour case. 8 hour+ surgeries are rare, and I usually only have to do that one surgery that day. The longest surgery I have done was I think ~20 hours, but I rotated with 2 other neurosurgeons.

3. I guess frequently, but usually indirectly. It's a well-oiled machine. I occasionally have to consult with other physicians about a patient. I sometimes work with non-neurosurgeons on cases if they can be beneficial (ex. ENT).

I have to say, it's encouraging to know that a reasonable lifestyle in achievable as a neurosurg attending. I've never shadowed a neurosurgeon (would love to) and don't have any exposure to the field, but I've always been so scared by the prospect of a seemingly-endless, grueling, possibly marriage-wrecking residency that I wouldn't even consider it.

Assuming an "average" marriage relationship, am I being unreasonable in my fear of the neurosurg residency? I feel like I can deal with hard work for whatever length of time if I love it (and I wouldn't choose any field without loving it) but I don't know if it would be worth it to risk losing someone I love.

Thanks a bunch for taking the time to answer questions here. :)

Yeah there are actually a lot of neurosurgeons that are happily married. You have to understand that much of the negative information you hear about neurosurgery is spread by people who are not neurosurgeons nor residents. Ex. there are first and second year med students preaching in the allopathic forum about how horrible neurosurgery residency is. Stories are often blown out of proportion. Unfortunately, neurosurgeon residents also occasionally exaggerate their conditions when talking to buddies in different residencies.

Neurosurgery residency may not be as horrible as people make it out to be, but it's still tough. If you are in a relationship, it's all about prioritizing and time budgeting. Unfortunately 80 hour weeks do occur and are common, but if your significant other is willing to make some sacrifices, you will both get through just fine. As I've said earlier, you do get at least 1 weekend completely free per month, several weeks vacation a year plus holidays, and some years are actually much more manageable (research year). You don't have to make residency your life. I spent time with family, went out with friends, traveled, went to weddings, etc.

Remember, the 6-7 years will fly by. After that you're home free. Adjust your lifestyle as you see fit.

kjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjnhbvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv01111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

Hi.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Thank you so much for all this information. But here's some more questions :)

Is there any information on the rankings of neurosurgery residency programs? Are there programs that focus more on spine or brain or pediatric cases?
And are there any malignant programs? If so, which ones?

What do you think is a good salary range to live comfortably with a family (4-6 kids)? I was thinking at least 400-500k.
 
Last edited:
Thank you so much for all this information. But here's some more questions :)

Is there any information on the rankings of neurosurgery residency programs? Are there programs that focus more on spine or brain or pediatric cases?
And are there any malignant programs? If so, which ones?

What do you think is a good salary range to live comfortably with a family (4-6 kids)? I was thinking at least 400-500k.

It has probably changed since I went through the process, but you'll have to do a good bit of research to find the best program for you. The most prestigious program might not always be the best fit for you. Some programs do have stronger focus in some areas, hence my ability to do spine without a fellowship.

Ummmm 400-500 is honestly way more than you need. You can probably put away 50k before taxes. Say you net 300k after taxes (gross 450k), that's 25k per month. Looking at a lavish lifestyle example: Million dollar mortgage is ~5k (with down payment), 200k in cars is a lease payment of ~3k per month, miscellaneous expenses/food may be ~10k. After all of that you still have 7k left over... So I'd say even 200k is enough for a comfortable lifestyle with a large family (granted you wouldn't live the lifestyle above, but still a comfortable one). 250k puts you in upper middle class for a family that size i'd say and anything above 500k is upper class (of course depends on location).

People keep dreading the health care changes and the pay cuts that will likely follow. No, they don't make sense, but don't base your decision on entering medicine based on this. Although money should never be the sole reason for doing something, there is still no way in hell that you won't have enough money to live comfortably as a physician.
 
I know you said you made nearly one million starting, is this before or after taxes? Also, what is the salary for the very top neuro/spine or just highest paid neurosurgeons in general?
Thanks,
 
I know you said you made nearly one million starting, is this before or after taxes? Also, what is the salary for the very top neuro/spine or just highest paid neurosurgeons in general?
Thanks,

Actually I said I made around $750k. This is before taxes, but after malpractice. Taxes will take out a considerable chunk. Maybe close to $500k after taxes. Based on the MGMA data, 90th percentile for neurosurgeons is ~$910k.

The truth is that the top 1% of every specialty all make similar amounts of money. Ex. The best dermpath doctors in the world have salaries greater than that of any normal surgeon. Most of us won't ever reach that level.

Compensation on average will go down in the future. Who knows what's in store for us 10-20 years from now. Just pick a specialty you enjoy and it won't matter.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Members don't see this ad :)
Hi xf3rn4nd3sx!

Have you run into any AOA trained neurosurgeons? Job-wise, do you think there would be any issues coming from an osteopathic neurosurgery program?

Thanks,

Nk1
 
Hi xf3rn4nd3sx!

Have you run into any AOA trained neurosurgeons? Job-wise, do you think there would be any issues coming from an osteopathic neurosurgery program?

Thanks,

Nk1

Yes, I've met quite a few AOA neurosurgeons. Job-wise, very few job opportunities say that they will not hire from an osteopathic neurosurgery program, but most are accepting. You won't have any trouble finding a job in this environment.
 
Spine is not a popular fellowship option for those in ortho (even though it is high paying) because of the notorious patient population, do you ever find your spine patients difficult to deal with? If you don't do spine, are you pretty much AWOL in private practice neurosurgery?
 
Spine is not a popular fellowship option for those in ortho (even though it is high paying) because of the notorious patient population, do you ever find your spine patients difficult to deal with? If you don't do spine, are you pretty much AWOL in private practice neurosurgery?

Well, spine patients can be difficult to deal with. Although many are grateful and do benefit from the surgeries, you just cannot please some of them. The ones that are grateful though make it worth while. Giving someone the ability to walk comfortably again or not have pain moving about is a great feeling. What do you mean by AWOL in private practice? In private practice if you work at a hospital with orthopedic spine surgeons or in a large group that has many neuro-spine surgeons, then you can do almost exclusively brain. Additionally, if you did a fellowship in endovascular neurosurgery (or any further specialization), you could easily find a position with no spine work.
 
Thank you for taking the time to help us out,

I am currently a rising M2 at a small school that does not have a neurosurgery program. Do you have any advice on how I can still remain competitive with applicants from other larger institutions?
 
Thank you for taking the time to help us out,

I am currently a rising M2 at a small school that does not have a neurosurgery program. Do you have any advice on how I can still remain competitive with applicants from other larger institutions?

Hi, other than the obvious having high USMLE scores, you can do additional research and get good recommendations. One advantage of being at a smaller school is that you can often form closer relationships with staff and get great letters of recommendation. I think the neurosurgery match rate is somewhere around 80%, so I don't think you should have any problem matching if you do well at your school in general.
 
What advice would you give an Osteopathic student looking to match at an Allopathic program? Particularly one who is not near enough to an academic program to do research during the school year. I realize it's very much an uphill battle, but it's a dream of mine and I want to prepare if it's at all possible.
 
How would you suggest the order of 3rd year clinical rotations? Do you prefer Surgery to be first, middle, or last?

I was thinking this (based on what I seen on SDN):
Peds
Neurology
IM
(winter break)
Surgery
FM
Ob/Gyn
Psych
 
How would you suggest the order of 3rd year clinical rotations? Do you prefer Surgery to be first, middle, or last?

I was thinking this (based on what I seen on SDN):
Peds
Neurology
IM
(winter break)
Surgery
FM
Ob/Gyn
Psych

That looks pretty good. I think surgery middle or last allows you to better compare surgery to other rotations. Best of luck on rotations.
 
Let me thank you for this thread. You went to top 5 undergraduate and medical school so I believe you have an idea about top tier residency programs. I know this have been done many times before but I want your input. May you rank these programs on solid clinical training and research basis, regardless to location:
MGH, BWH, Barrow, UVa, U penn, Hopkins, U pitts, Jefferson, Wash U, U of Wash, Mayo, Cleveland, Columbia, Cornell, NYU, UCSF, UCLA, Stanford, Duke, UNC, Emory, Utah, UAB, UTsouthwestern, Baylor, Vanderbilt, U Michigan.

P.S. I heard that MGH and Hopkins are overrated in training although they have great faculty.
 
What advice would you give an Osteopathic student looking to match at an Allopathic program? Particularly one who is not near enough to an academic program to do research during the school year. I realize it's very much an uphill battle, but it's a dream of mine and I want to prepare if it's at all possible.

Apply to North Shore LIJ. They're taking one Allopathic and one osteopathic resident until they get approval for 2 allopathic spots a year. Its an allopathic program in every way (and a pretty damn strong one).
 
What advice would you give an Osteopathic student looking to match at an Allopathic program? Particularly one who is not near enough to an academic program to do research during the school year. I realize it's very much an uphill battle, but it's a dream of mine and I want to prepare if it's at all possible.

Oh sorry, I think I missed your question :oops:

Luckily it sounds like Chakrabs has you covered :thumbup:
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Thanks for your reply! What would you say gives an Osteopathic student a good shot at other Allopathic programs? Is it just the same board scores, LORs, clinical grades, great sub-Is advice that Allopathic students get? Would taking a year off to do research be helpful, as I see sometimes advised for FMGs?
 
Let me thank you for this thread. You went to top 5 undergraduate and medical school so I believe you have an idea about top tier residency programs. I know this have been done many times before but I want your input. May you rank these programs on solid clinical training and research basis, regardless to location:
MGH, BWH, Barrow, UVa, U penn, Hopkins, U pitts, Jefferson, Wash U, U of Wash, Mayo, Cleveland, Columbia, Cornell, NYU, UCSF, UCLA, Stanford, Duke, UNC, Emory, Utah, UAB, UTsouthwestern, Baylor, Vanderbilt, U Michigan.

P.S. I heard that MGH and Hopkins are overrated in training although they have great faculty.

If you ranked those programs based on clinical training, research, and the two combined you would have three vastly different lists. Also, not sure why you included some programs here and why you left some others off.

Neurosurgery residency match isn't simply "the best" clinical training, research, or location. Many other factors play a significant role such as family (e.g. kids, family support, spouse career), institutional culture (hospital/program size, malignant/not, resident autonomy), personal bias, etc. along with the fact that, for the most part, you are locked in for seven years.
 
This is a wonderful thing you are doing for us on this site. I appreciate you taking the time to answer these questions and offer your own experiences.

Do you have any insight on Sub-I's and Step 2?
 
Hey, everyone! I'm currently in my first year of private practice (so, I guess I didn't graduate that recently) and would be happy to answer any questions any residents/med students/pre-meds may have about the specialty/lifestyle/etc during and after residency. I've been browsing these forums for several years, but only recently made an account (last year). I've been meaning to this for a while to give back to the community, so feel free to ask anything.

(I'll probably be going to sleep shortly, but will answer any questions posted tomorrow!)

This may well have been asked already, but if not: to what extent does neurosurgery residency lifestyle change year to year?
 
This is a wonderful thing you are doing for us on this site. I appreciate you taking the time to answer these questions and offer your own experiences.

Do you have any insight on Sub-I's and Step 2?

"First and foremost, your goal should be to go out and get a really good sense of what another program’s all about. This is your chance to learn what aspects of a program are really important to you. For example, are you ok with a place where the residents aren’t all the best of friends, if you get great technical experience? Or are you ok with having less operative experience in the junior years if the attendings are great mentors and the department is really tight? The sub-I is a time to get a sense of what you want, and to learn how to look for it in a program so you can judge others on interview days.

Second, of course, the sub-I is a chance to make a great positive impression on an individual program. It’s a chance to “audition” at a place you are genuinely interested in. This means you need to choose a place where you have a chance in hell of matching based on your objective application that’s in a city where you would consider living. If Rochester Minn isn’t for you, don’t waste a month there just to get a good letter...there are plenty of strong programs out there; pick one you’d actually consider ranking at the top of your list."

-Uncle Harvey (neurosurgery website)

Step 2 definitely isn't as important as Step 1. If you did well enough on Step 1, there is honestly no reason to take Step 2 before matching.

This may well have been asked already, but if not: to what extent does neurosurgery residency lifestyle change year to year?

Residency lifestyle gets easier year to year in terms of hours, but you have more responsibilities. One year will be research in which lifestyle is much easier, you have much less call, and just less strenuous work in general. Your final year of residency is basically like managing your own practice. You have your own patients, etc.
 
Residency lifestyle gets easier year to year in terms of hours, but you have more responsibilities. One year will be research in which lifestyle is much easier, you have much less call, and just less strenuous work in general. Your final year of residency is basically like managing your own practice. You have your own patients, etc.

Nice to know that even neurosurg doesn't break this mold
 
Next year I will be entering harvard university and I am fascinated by the CNS in general. Do you believe that a doctor who went to a very prestigious medical school would have more patient volume/compensation as a private practice spinal surgeon? Excluding the consideration of the health care bill, I am simply asking in our current system. Also, are you aware of a time when reimbursement fees were the most? I am not interested in neurosurgery because of the money, I am interested because the brain is truly a miraculous organ.
 
I will be an M1 at the University of Toledo College of Medicine this year. Believe it or not, but your advice and recommendations have resurrected my once strong interest in the field of Neurosurgery. Thank you so much for taking the time to share information with all of us on this thread. It certainly must be a sacrifice with everything else you have going on. Just a few clarifying questions:
1) I am most concerned about lifestyle, which I know you have addressed excessively. I am married with a 1 year old son and love more family more than life itself. It seems a little daunting to think my son will be 12 years old by the time I complete residency if I become a neurosurgeon, and we plan on having several more children. Can you give any more specifics about how hours/responsibilities change from year to year in residency? Does this differ greatly from program to program? I've been looking at some residency programs recently and it seems some have 2 years of research, more or less research focus, etc?
2) How does practice as a neurosurgeon vary in different geographical areas? For example, would a Neurosurgeon in Idaho or Montana work less hours than one in NYC or Seattle? How would this affect compensation?
3) Why is there so much conflicting information out there about salary? It is definitely not my only interest in becoming a neurosurgeon, but certainly important with a family and consideration of loan debt. I've read posts on this forum of people saying that neurosurgeons make 150-200k a year. That seems crazy - are these people just misinformed or talking about information they have nor real knowledge of? Is your starting salary that you have shared rare or exceptional for a starting neurosurgeon?
4) You mentioned that you know people who work 50 hrs a week, 4 days a week including call. Does that mean that they work a 40 hour week with 10 hours of call at night? How does this affect compensation? I of course know it probably means less, but just looking for more specifics.
5) Is lifestyle better in academics/private practice? This seems unclear from a lot of information I have read, and I would assume it is somewhat situational, but any insights would be great.
6) What is typical for vacation time 1) during residency and 2) in private practice?

I apologize if I have asked too much or gone into too great of detail here. I have just been reading these posts for a while and have thought a lot about the information you have presented. Thanks again!
 
Next year I will be entering harvard university and I am fascinated by the CNS in general. Do you believe that a doctor who went to a very prestigious medical school would have more patient volume/compensation as a private practice spinal surgeon? Excluding the consideration of the health care bill, I am simply asking in our current system. Also, are you aware of a time when reimbursement fees were the most? I am not interested in neurosurgery because of the money, I am interested because the brain is truly a miraculous organ.

No, probably not. In private practice it matters very little if you went to a prestigious medical school. Most neurosurgeons have plenty of volume, so it isn't really a problem regardless. I'm not sure of when reimbursement fees were the most, but they have sharply declined from the 80s. Probably still the highest compensation on average, but it's more than enough to be comfortable.

I will be an M1 at the University of Toledo College of Medicine this year. Believe it or not, but your advice and recommendations have resurrected my once strong interest in the field of Neurosurgery. Thank you so much for taking the time to share information with all of us on this thread. It certainly must be a sacrifice with everything else you have going on. Just a few clarifying questions:
1) I am most concerned about lifestyle, which I know you have addressed excessively. I am married with a 1 year old son and love more family more than life itself. It seems a little daunting to think my son will be 12 years old by the time I complete residency if I become a neurosurgeon, and we plan on having several more children. Can you give any more specifics about how hours/responsibilities change from year to year in residency? Does this differ greatly from program to program? I've been looking at some residency programs recently and it seems some have 2 years of research, more or less research focus, etc?
2) How does practice as a neurosurgeon vary in different geographical areas? For example, would a Neurosurgeon in Idaho or Montana work less hours than one in NYC or Seattle? How would this affect compensation?
3) Why is there so much conflicting information out there about salary? It is definitely not my only interest in becoming a neurosurgeon, but certainly important with a family and consideration of loan debt. I've read posts on this forum of people saying that neurosurgeons make 150-200k a year. That seems crazy - are these people just misinformed or talking about information they have nor real knowledge of? Is your starting salary that you have shared rare or exceptional for a starting neurosurgeon?
4) You mentioned that you know people who work 50 hrs a week, 4 days a week including call. Does that mean that they work a 40 hour week with 10 hours of call at night? How does this affect compensation? I of course know it probably means less, but just looking for more specifics.
5) Is lifestyle better in academics/private practice? This seems unclear from a lot of information I have read, and I would assume it is somewhat situational, but any insights would be great.
6) What is typical for vacation time 1) during residency and 2) in private practice?

I apologize if I have asked too much or gone into too great of detail here. I have just been reading these posts for a while and have thought a lot about the information you have presented. Thanks again!

1) Research years are a lot more lax than other years. Some programs are also generally more family friendly simply because most of the other residents also have families. Hours will typically be similar, but as you get more senior you usually have fewer hours and less call, but more responsibilities. You get to round later, etc. Final year is basically like managing your own practice.
2) I would say hours work depends more on practice setting and size of practice rather than geographic setting. It is true that some regions compensate better than others, but suburban/rural areas will almost always compensate better than large cities like NYC. If you are the only neurosurgeon in a town, then your hours and call will probably be on the high end. If you are part of a large group practice, call is fairly light and hours can be adjusted fairly easily. The most important difference between neurosurgery in Montana or NYC is quality of living. Your quality of life will be much, much higher in Montana than NYC. You will likely earn a higher salary and your money goes much farther.
3) My starting salary was probably not typical (on the high end for a recent graduate). That being said, I know of people who have started at salaries even higher than mine (but typically strings are attached). 150-200k is very low though. Most doctors understate their salaries for obvious reasons. If I were not a recent graduate, I probably wouldn't have listen mine. I'd say you can easily find a job above 400k though. You should have no problem paying back loans ,etc.
4) It's a rare situation, but it does occur. This would be at a pure spine practice. Call is pretty light, since little trauma is involved and most operations are elective. Spine is very lucrative, so compensation would still be decent. Again, it's not a very common setup though. This setup also might be impossible in the future depending on how healthcare moves, so don't plan to have a setup like this. Chances are you will be working 60-70+ hours when you start working and your hours will gradually get better.
5) Probably private practice because you have more control over your lifestyle. Compensation is typically greater and you can choose to live in an area with low cost of living. However, you would sacrifice the case variety that academics offers.
6) Residency: 3-4 weeks typically. Here's Duke's residency schedule (I didn't go to Duke, but just googled it) http://gme.duke.edu/sites/default/f... Off Policy to Jill Watkins GME 3-29-2012.pdf
After residency: varies greatly. I have 4 weeks off plus holidays. If you do a job search on google you can find jobs offering 6+ weeks.
 
How is diversity in race in the field of neurosurgery? The only African American neurosurgeon I heard of is Ben Carson. I know there are more African American neurosurgeons than him and the main reason I know about him is how he overcame his background to display his great talents.
 
How is diversity in race in the field of neurosurgery? The only African American neurosurgeon I heard of is Ben Carson. I know there are more African American neurosurgeons than him and the main reason I know about him is how he overcame his background to display his great talents.

Keith Black at cedars sinai. Also an attending at Duke, although the name slips my mind.

Sticky this thread?
 
How is diversity in race in the field of neurosurgery? The only African American neurosurgeon I heard of is Ben Carson. I know there are more African American neurosurgeons than him and the main reason I know about him is how he overcame his background to display his great talents.

I'm just a med student, but the two places I know about both have NS faculty with African ancestry.

MGH: William Curry (I think his father was a CT surgeon)
Stanford: Robert Dodd, Odette Harris
 
What is it like to shift from resident to attending? How does it feel being the one who makes the final decision and having to deal with the consequences/not having a safety net?
 
How much do you think a very talented resident, that went to let's say attended Harvard for Medical School, and was a resident at a very prestigious hospital, could make annually as a attending at a major academic institution such as Johns Hopkins, Mayo Clinic, or a University hospital such as uMich?

Thanks,
 
It looks like some people have answered the diversity question already, but I will second that diversity does exist. There aren't many neurosurgeons, so it's not always as apparent.

What is it like to shift from resident to attending? How does it feel being the one who makes the final decision and having to deal with the consequences/not having a safety net?

You have consequences as a resident, as well. The final residency year is almost like being an attending. The main differences as an attending are that I more control over what I do, what cases I take on, and how much I work. It's pretty cool being the head honcho, though :cool:

How much do you think a very talented resident, that went to let's say attended Harvard for Medical School, and was a resident at a very prestigious hospital, could make annually as a attending at a major academic institution such as Johns Hopkins, Mayo Clinic, or a University hospital such as uMich?

Thanks,

Um it varies widely. Several university salaries are available online. If you're just pre-med don't get too far ahead of yourself. You have a minimum of 4+7 years if you do neurosurgery, and I guarantee things will be vastly different by that time.
 
What is the state of autologous stem cell transplants for various brain conditions? It seems like beginning research is showing positive signs. When do you think these types of procedures will become routine?
 
Do you, as an attending, have an opinion on Obamacare? Like what do you think will happen in the future to attendings? Also, compared to other specialties you know, how are codes and reimbursements getting cut now and in the future going to affect neurosurgeons? Plus if salaries get cut, but the cost of undergrad and med school don't decrease, should people start looking at how doctors in family medicine live with high debt and one of the lowest salaries as a doctor?
 
What is the state of autologous stem cell transplants for various brain conditions? It seems like beginning research is showing positive signs. When do you think these types of procedures will become routine?

Stem cell transplants do look promising, but I don't think procedures will become routine for at least another 15-20 years. The FDA had actually approved a stem cell transplant for treatment of a neurological condition in children several years back, but I don't recall the results.

Do you, as an attending, have an opinion on Obamacare? Like what do you think will happen in the future to attendings? Also, compared to other specialties you know, how are codes and reimbursements getting cut now and in the future going to affect neurosurgeons? Plus if salaries get cut, but the cost of undergrad and med school don't decrease, should people start looking at how doctors in family medicine live with high debt and one of the lowest salaries as a doctor?

Yes, I do have an opinion on Obama care :), but it's probably best that I don't share it on this forum. As attendings we will be just fine. There will likely be decreased reimbursement short term, but I predict supply and demand, as well as political cycles will eventually bring this up again. Neurosurgery isn't getting hit nearly as hard as many other specialties. Family medicine is due for a significant pay increase soon. I personally don't think that we will ever have too much difficulty paying our loans, but it is something that needs to be looked at. Most physicians will always be upper-middle class. I typically believe that things eventually work themselves out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Hello,

I am new to this forum (in case you did not notice), and eventually I will be starting a Neurosurgical Residency . After graduation, is it common for an Attending at a major medical center to make over seven figures starting? I noticed that on Merrit Hawkins they have several positions with a guaranteed starting salary of 750k (after malpractice), but for moderate-level earning potential it can extend as far as $1.5million for the first year.

PS: See the link, and I will be going into academic medicine.

http://www.merritthawkins.com/job-search/job-details.aspx?job=10763&contract=163595
http://www.merritthawkins.com/job-search/job-details.aspx?job=10537&contract=160636

Thanks for doing this
 
I am an EM attending, but there is something about NSx that I noticed years ago: I wonder if NSx has the highest percentage of MD/PhDs out of all medical specialties. So, think of it - 6-8 years for the MD/PhD, then 6-7 years of neurosurg training. If someone goes the long way, from age 18 is 4 years for college, 8 for med school, and 7 years for residency. That is 37 just going into practice. Even for the shorter end (MSTP for 6 and a 6 year residency) still is 34. Counter that with the lame EM, FM, IM, and peds docs that didn't get the PhD, and did a puny 3-year residency, and are out at 29, 5 years ahead. (And before any lurkers get enraged, it's a joke about being lame.)

Does anyone lay this reality on the MD/PhD students before they commit? Or do NSx programs prefer the MD/PhDs, or are they self-selecting?
 
I think radonc has more md/phd's, though there are a fair amount in neurosurg.
 
I am an EM attending, but there is something about NSx that I noticed years ago: I wonder if NSx has the highest percentage of MD/PhDs out of all medical specialties. So, think of it - 6-8 years for the MD/PhD, then 6-7 years of neurosurg training. If someone goes the long way, from age 18 is 4 years for college, 8 for med school, and 7 years for residency. That is 37 just going into practice. Even for the shorter end (MSTP for 6 and a 6 year residency) still is 34. Counter that with the lame EM, FM, IM, and peds docs that didn't get the PhD, and did a puny 3-year residency, and are out at 29, 5 years ahead. (And before any lurkers get enraged, it's a joke about being lame.)

Does anyone lay this reality on the MD/PhD students before they commit? Or do NSx programs prefer the MD/PhDs, or are they self-selecting?

NSX definitely has a high percentage of MD/PhDs. Although most of the MD/PhD neurosurgeons I've spoken to have no regrets, it is a big commitment and many have said in hindsight a plain MD degree would have sufficed. NSX programs do typically prefer MD/PhD students, but it is by no means necessary. I would recommend an MD/PhD problem only if you are sure about research and doing academics, because it will help. If you aren't crazy about research and are considering private practice, it's not worth it. I thought the research was interesting, but there were other things I'd rather do. The extra years of training did not seem worthwhile to me, as I was sure I would be in private practice. Being in training until 37 would be insane...
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Do Neurosurgeons have good eye-hand coordination, or is this talent acquired through training?

Also, how knowledgeable are neurosurgeons in general medicine? do you retain some of your internship general medicine knowledge?

Thank you,
 
Do Neurosurgeons have good eye-hand coordination, or is this talent acquired through training?

Also, how knowledgeable are neurosurgeons in general medicine? do you retain some of your internship general medicine knowledge?

Thank you,

There is a certain level of hand-eye coordination required, but this isn't a huge deal, as it will sharpen with practice and training.

We're pretty knowledgeable on general medicine. Enough that we can accurately treat and diagnose the majority of our patients independently. If there is something I am unsure about I wouldn't hesitate to ask a physician in the respective area (cardiology, oncology, etc.), as they are surely more knowledgeable on the subject.
 
Hey there, massive thanks for your candour and willingness to answer questions. It's a great insight into the world of NSx, especially for those of us from overseas. I am cognizant that there will be plenty of people reading this who are not US natives, but interested in this career.

I wanted to ask if you had anecdotal knowledge, or an opinion of foreign trained neurosurgeons coming to do fellowships in the US, and then securing a residency post on a program? Is this something that even happens?

Cheers!
 
Last edited:
Top