I don't think a lot of my classmates that want to go into surgery in Morgantown would agree. If you let them know you're interested, they'll get you involved. Of course there's still the odd attending or two that makes them just hold retractors, but as far as I know, my surgery colleagues are really happy with what they've gotten to do. I can't speak first hand though, because I was happy to fade into the background on surgery haha.
Morgantown definitely had the added benefits of seeing what a big, academic medical center is like. There's residents, a fair amount of fellows, almost all specialties and subspecialties. Charleston is like a mini-version of that, but it's true that you might get to do more because there are fewer cooks in the kitchen, so to speak. You definitely have the chance to do more at Eastern and make great bonds with attendings, but you'll sacrifice many of the "exciting/interesting" pathologies because they'll be sent to Morgantown or maybe Charleston so it's definitely a trade of.
Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile app
I'm really not going to argue with you over what
my experience was. Do you realize how dumb that is? It was the same experience my classmates had. People who attended Morgantown campus went into surgery despite their rotation, not because of it. No one stayed for general surgery through the match. That means something, whether you realize it or not. If it's different now, it means that it has changed, which is a good thing. Stop protesting and just accept it.
I'm still in a procedural field (going into Interventional Radiology) with similar call demands as a general surgeon, so I don't know what your hypothesis is as far as why I would do that rather than what my original goal was when I entered medical school if it wasn't for a horrible surgical experience.
Interesting pathologies are overrated when it comes to learning the basics. That's what residency and fellowship is for. I'd rather get to do (or at least be first assist in) a significant number of basic surgeries (choles, appendectomies, deep abscess drains, washouts, low end vascular procedures) than be in the 3rd row, trying to watch over the resident and fellow's shoulders while a SMA bypass is happening. If I were to do it again, I would want to get involved with the surgeries I would potentially see every day, and try to figure out if that's what I want to do with the rest of my life.
You concede that you're likely to be
more involved at the other campuses. IMO, that's what
I would want. End of story.
Anyway, the whole point of this was to tell people to not freak out if they're going to be at Charleston or Martinsburg. They'll still have a good experience.