OUWB's set-up is still puzzling to me. Setting up a system to rank those who have been rejected into multiple categories and sugar coating the names of some of the "rejection" categories seems to be a poor strategy (and unlikely to be what OUWB is doing).
If this was the case, OUWB would basically be saying that we have the following categories: (i) accepted - you're awesome, come play in our sandbox; (ii) 1st tier waitlist (the only true waitlist) - you're cool and actually have a chance of getting in our sandbox; (iii) 2nd tier waitlist (1st tier reject) - we like you, took us a little while to determine that we ultimately don't want you in our sandbox, so you don't have any chance of getting in but keep your chin-up; (iv) 3rd tier waitlist (2nd tier reject) - we decided instantly that you have absolutely no chance to get into our sandbox, but you are still OK in our eyes and we hope you ultimately find a nice sandbox to play in, please don't feel bad about yourself; and (v) rejected (3rd tier reject) - why did we even extend you an II - oh yeah, we also don't like you.
To be clear - the point of this post is that I do not believe that the above description is OUWB's thought process, but still can't figure out their thought process
I've thought OUWB's tiered system made little sense ever since my interview day when they indicated that only tier 1 waitlist students have historically made it into the school. Seems to me it should be as follows: (i) Accepted; (ii) waitlisted (include a few more people in tier 1 if you are afraid that the tier 1 waitlist isn't large enough); (iii) rejected a while after interview (i.e., current tier 2 waitlisters); and (iv) those rejected immediately. This can be summarized as: accepted; waitlisted; rejected (which seems to be what most other medical schools do).
The formal system seems to be set up to provide false hope (while at the same time the presentations on interview day take away such hope by indicating that only tier 1 waitlist has any real chance of acceptance).
I guess it doesn't really matter, as OUWB did not ask me for my opinion or appoint me to the admissions committee.